News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Saturday January 14, 2017 @03:48PM (#13400464)
This reminds me of "The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics": http://web.archive.org/web/20160806191858/https://blog.jaibo...

Our culture has a very strange belief that you shouldn't benefit from the less fortunate. Even if you benefit them too. People that have never donated a dollar to charity in their lives, will come out of the woodwork and complain about "exploitation".

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by kome on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:00PM (#13400532)
"People that have never donated a dollar to charity in their lives" is a particularly American, or let's say anglophone, way to approach social justice.

Charities are based on good will, but "the less fortunate" do not need "good will": they need social rights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_rights

If you don't see "exploitation" when people need and they are willing to sell their blood, I have no idea what you mean by exploitation.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darawk on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:52PM (#13401075)
What's wrong with selling your blood? To me it seems like selling your time is a far more personal, unrecoverable injustice. And most people just call that 'work'.

If you want to make it out like these people are being 'exploited', then you can make the case just the same that all property is exploitation. Railing against poor people donating blood plasma, or organs for that matter, is profoundly misguided.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by amorphid on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:07PM (#13401433)
Not an expert on the subject, but I recall hearing somewhere that selling blood gives people an incentive to lie about their health history.

"Do you shoot up illicit drugs with shared needles?"

"Um... No. No I do not."

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darawk on Sunday January 15, 2017 @01:19AM (#13402643)
True, but that is the system being exploited by those individuals, not the other way around.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by amorphid on Sunday January 15, 2017 @01:24AM (#13402655)
I don't want a tainted blood transfusion, so it does affect me.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darawk on Sunday January 15, 2017 @04:18AM (#13403182)
Right, it effects everyone except the person who donates. The thing i'm arguing against is the idea that the donors are being exploited.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by amorphid on Sunday January 15, 2017 @04:31PM (#13406501)
Thanks for clarifying.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by timv on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:02PM (#13402233)
Yes, but don't many job applications have equivalent incentives for lying?

- Have you ever been charged with a criminal offence? - Do you use recreational drugs?

Etc. I don't think that the blood donation questionare is especially problematic on that regards.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by CamelCaseName on Sunday January 15, 2017 @12:49AM (#13402570)
The difference is who is harmed. A company may have to fire and replace a lying employee, so the shareholders lose some money, but a person contracting HIV from a bad blood transfusion is substantially more devastating.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by timv on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:57PM (#13432876)
Sure, but as darawk argued in a sibling thread, that's not evidence that the poor are being exploited.

As far as the "Low-Income Americans" from the article are concerned, all sorts of jobs give them an incentive to lie, why should donating blood be considered more exploitative because of it?

The question of whether buying blood has a net positive public health benefit is a very real one, but it's unrelated to darawk's ancestor post arguing that selling blood is just another form of work.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:21PM (#13400923)
You are missing the point entirely, and being exactly the kind of person I am complaining about.

Buying plasma doesn't hurt anyone. It doesn't make the poor worse off. It's certainly not "exploitation". And it's doing more to help the poor than the vast majority of people that don't do anything.

There is a problem in the world, that people are poor, desperate, or in need. But the plasma industry didn't cause poverty, and they aren't making it any worse. If anything they are making it better, if only slightly.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by tunap on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:44PM (#13401025)
But they did ratchet back the prices! Back in college I went with friends to donate plasma(I had a job, didn't 'need' the money). It was interesting and paid $75 for < 2 hours of my time. Wow! I went back once(twice?) a month as allowed. It was a great boost to my income, plus got to watch free movies and free juice and snacks on the way out. Fast forward several years and local labs pay $35 or $25 per seasion and it turned into a 4 hour episode of mostly waiting around to get the 20 min(?) procedure, watching movies. Sure it beats a poke in the eye, but the incentive for anyone but the poor and desperate was gone. Nowadays I'll give blood for free(& snacks!), will not waste half a day to enrich the lab's bottom line.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by jrs235 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:55PM (#13401091)
Where I am you can donate twice a week and usually takes an hour, during busier times it might take 1.5 hours depending on a short wait and how quickly you cycle (the more hydrated you are the faster it can go and your weight determines how much you will have to donate). First donation of the week they pay $20, second time is $50. That's $70 a week, $280 a month. I donate. I don't need to but why not get paid to read?
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by tunap on Saturday January 14, 2017 @06:13PM (#13401189)
That seems like a lot of plasma your body has to replenish. Sure the platelets are put back, but sounds extreme... IANAMD.

I am referring to my experience in the '90s and it may have been allowed more than 2xs a month, but that is all I was comfortable with. When the payout was reduced >50% I desisted.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by jrs235 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @06:18PM (#13401211)
825 ml per time. I weigh approx 165 lbs. They give you a pint of saline.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by tunap on Saturday January 14, 2017 @06:46PM (#13401354)
That was a helluva rush when the cold water flowed up my bicep and into my chest. I was weighing in around 170 then, they always asked why I was so skinny... perhaps probing for indications of a drug problem? Am 6ft 0in, and 25 years later still 170lbs. Yay.

Back on topic: Adjusting for inflation(stagflation), that's a hell of a lot less today than when I initially quit. In your opinion, what percentage of people donating are not indigent? Back then I would have said maybe 25%, and those were all hard-up students from the University 4 blocks away.

edit: changed 'starving' to 'hard-up'. Technically, indigent too.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by jrs235 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:26PM (#13401515)
Not indigent? 100% The center is located where it would be difficult to get to if indigent. There are three colleges in town and a large portion of donors are college students. Most others I would guess are blue collar or para professionals. I think the income comes in handy for a majority of donors. It might help many make ends meet. I don't think anyone would donate for free.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by WhitneyLand on Saturday January 14, 2017 @06:35PM (#13401294)
Wow, you would take this opportunity away from them?

As a father this situation would be horrible if my only chance to provide things for my daughter was taken away to "help" me:

"he was giving plasma because his daughter had a birthday, and he needed $7.50 to buy her a bathing suit and money for a cake"

Sure, you can say it would be better if the dad had some other opportunity available, but that's changing the subject. This is what he has right now, that gives him more happiness than anything in his life.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by gravypod on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#13400615)
Does that sentiment hold when your donations are to pro-bono legal firms?
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by aqme28 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:26PM (#13400652)
The "donations" in this case aren't really donations. They're being paid in exchange for their blood plasma.

So I don't see the comparison to pro-bono legal firms.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by chimeracoder on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:43PM (#13400733)
> The "donations" in this case aren't really donations. They're being paid in exchange for their blood plasma.

Which gets back to the question - what's wrong with that?

The alternative is not to pay people for donating plasma, and we can see quite clearly that that doesn't work - every country that does not pay for blood plasma donations runs a shortage, and most of them end up importing plasma from the US.

So, we have to pay for plasma, or else we won't have enough, which means people will literally die. Given that we have to pay for plasma, what's wrong with letting anyone who's medically eligible to donate do so?

Most of the common arguments against tissue donation (safety, incentive to lie, etc.) either don't apply to plasma donation or are no longer relevant thanks to the cost and accuracy of modern testing methods. There is no medical or financial reason not to permit the practice, and I'm struggling to see a moral one that doesn't eventually result in people dying because we refuse to collect the life-saving tissue that people are perfectly capable of providing and willing to provide.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Retric on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:18PM (#13400902)
People also die due to disease contamination of the blood supply when you pay. Donation only blood supplies are much safer in the short and long term, until we can manufacture a replacement.

Sure, right now we gave good tests for most diseases, but the next AIDS has no test making the long term risks real.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by gravypod on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:20PM (#13400916)
I don't think you read the post you replied to in full. He stipulated that the current testing methodology is good enough to prevent any death from blood purchasing.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Retric on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:17PM (#13401478)
None of the current tests are 100% accurate for known diseases. So, no it's really not safe today. Further as I said, the risk for the next outbreak is significant.

PS: Risks of AIDS are conservatively estimated at 1:1.5 million per transfusion, but some people get a lot of transfusions. Here is one example from 2008: https://www.cdc.gov/Mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5941a3.htm AIDS is also rapidly becoming drug resistant making reduced transmission even more important.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by gravypod on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:28PM (#13401520)
This would very well still be a risk if they were all donations and not monetary transactions. The onus is on you to provide evidence to show a corelation between purchased blood and AIDS/HIV.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Retric on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:46PM (#13401609)
The CDC did that years ago which is why donations stopped being monetary transactions. The current risks are lower in large part due to testing, but screening questions are still a significant part of the blood safety net and history has shown people lie when money is involved.

They do have the if there is any reason you suspect their might be an issue bar code because people still lie even without money simply because of social pressure.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by gravypod on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:39PM (#13400716)
Trades of goods are equivalent to currency.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by woodruffw on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:39PM (#13401002)
To paraphrase Kant:

You shouldn't use the less fortunate (or anybody, really) as a mere mean to an end. Paying the homeless a pittance to behave as moving antennas is about as close as you can get to treating someone as a mere mean. The same goes for paying the disadvantaged $40 for their plasma - we can all intuitively recognize that a minimal "solution" that treats the individual as a mean and not an individual (autonomous, self-legislating, etc) is not a "right" one.

The idea that recognizing this while not giving to charity makes you a hypocrite is puzzling. There's no conflict between the positive right to give to charity and the negative right to not be exploited.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:50PM (#13401061)
Who cares? The only relevant question is "Do their actions make the world a better place?" Or perhaps, "Are they improving these people's lives, or making them worse?" And yes, they are improving their lives, if only slightly. They are making the world a better place.

The people who claim to care about these poor people, have done nothing to help them. Their revealed preferences show they don't actually care at all. They just want to signal how virtuous and moral they are. The policies they support would actually make them poorer. And they know that and don't care.

It is the worst kind of hypocrisy, and I believe it's responsible for many of the world's problems.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by woodruffw on Saturday January 14, 2017 @06:05PM (#13401151)
Are they improving their lives? They don't think so, and I don't think so either. $40 twice a week is not a substitute for self respect or a job that you can admit to your children.

> "Do their actions make the world a better place?"

Do they? Is a "better" world a one in which people are forced to sell their plasma to survive? In your dimly utilitarian view, you've neglected to consider whether such a state of affairs is truly a good one (much less a maximally good one, as most utilitarians would actually demand).

> The people who claim to care about these poor people, have done nothing to help them. Their revealed preferences show they don't actually care at all.

Sure, if you think voting and advocacy count for nothing. Charity and philanthropy are good, but they're general obligations not directed at any individual or group of individuals. Whether or not people choose to give to your pet injustice (there are many of them, after all) is not indication that they passively abide by it.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Sunday January 15, 2017 @01:22PM (#13405445)
You have a weird view that selling plasma is something shameful or degrading. I've participated before. There is nothing shameful or humiliating about it. I don't see anything objectionable about selling plasma, and they pay enough to make it worth the time.

>Do they? Is a "better" world a one in which people are forced to sell their plasma to survive? In your dimly utilitarian view, you've neglected to consider whether such a state of affairs is truly a good one

You twist my words. Is the world optimal? Of course not. Does that have anything to do with the plasma industry whatsoever? Again, the plasma industry did not create poverty. They are not "forcing" anyone to sell plasma. They are not making the world any worse than it otherwise was. The people who sell plasma are better off - otherwise they wouldn't continue to do it voluntarily.

>Whether or not people choose to give to your pet injustice (there are many of them, after all) is not indication that they passively abide by it.

If you want to know what someone really believes - what they really value - you need to look at their actions, not their words. People lie about their beliefs and values, even to themselves.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darpa_escapee on Saturday January 14, 2017 @08:16PM (#13401745)
> "Are they improving these people's lives, or making them worse?" And yes, they are improving their lives, if only slightly. They are making the world a better place.

And people that profit off of child labor are helping hungry kids eat.

This is an absurd metric.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Saturday January 14, 2017 @08:41PM (#13401841)
If what you say is true, and child labor is keeping children from starving to death, then how could you possibly oppose it?

The main objection against child labor is that it is extremely detrimental for the children. If you literally believe the children benefit from it, then I can not understand your objection.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darpa_escapee on Saturday January 14, 2017 @09:19PM (#13401966)
Did you know some slave owners granted their slaves semi-autonomy as long as work got done?
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by Houshalter on Sunday January 15, 2017 @01:25PM (#13405461)
Are you seriously comparing selling blood to slavery? What does that have to do with anything?

Slaves work because if they don't, the slave master will beat or kill them. The plasma industry isn't going to beat or kill you if you don't sell them blood.

You may have problems in your life that make you so desperate, you need to sell your blood. But the plasma industry didn't create those problems, and they aren't making your life any worse.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darpa_escapee on Sunday January 15, 2017 @03:45PM (#13406294)
> Are you seriously comparing selling blood to slavery? What does that have to do with anything?

No, I just see the metric as a particularly weird line to draw.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by chongli on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:23PM (#13400931)
Believe it or not, some people are averse to charity or even oppose charity on principle. In many cases, it could be argued that charity sustains poverty [0] and that it would be better to endeavour to eliminate poverty entirely. One phenomenon that most dismays me is cultural capitalism [1]. This is a big part of the problem.

[0] http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/charity/against_1.shtml

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GRvRm19UKdA

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by 0xfaded on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:55PM (#13400782)
A donated dollar is one less taxable dollar, so in practice provides a means for individually diverting taxes to charities one finds agreeable.

In the US I've even heard people using this rational to avoid fuelling the military industrial complex. However a well functioning government that best served society would not have this problem. In principle it's the government's job to take care of society's needs, not the charities'.

I think the existence of Planned Parenthood is a case in point. Undoubtedly they provide a necessary service, but in what world should a pregnant teenager not have access to a doctor?

In practice charities act as a highly inefficient decentralised mechanism for providing basic needs to those that can't afford them. In some cases, the charities are stellar. In others, they come with a religious taint (e.g. access to a doctor through a church). In the worst case a charity can operate as a scam, see the untouchable tele-evangelists.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by peacetreefrog on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:30PM (#13400961)
Not sure what this has to do with plasma apart from the word donate
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by jeffdavis on Saturday January 14, 2017 @05:06PM (#13400840)
"In principle it's the government's job to take care of society's needs, not the charities'."

I disagree strongly. Concentrating responsibility concentrates power, which is dangerous. Governments should share power internally, share between levels (federal, state, local), and leave a lot of the power with the people (who may use it for private enterprises, NGOs, etc.).

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darpa_escapee on Saturday January 14, 2017 @08:26PM (#13401786)
Unfortunately, in the history of the world, charity hasn't even come close to helping as many of those in need as successful government programs. The incentives to provide enough support to different charities aren't there. Charity follows trends and whims, not needs. For example, the top cumulative donations went to charities that do not serve the needs of the poor, despite how many people are still in need of assistance despite government programs.
Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by rvdavis on Sunday January 15, 2017 @09:51PM (#13407940)
> Charity follows trends and whims, not needs.

You imply government policy does not follow trends and whims, which is observably false.

Re:Thousands of Low-Income Americans 'Donate' Blood Plasma t... by darpa_escapee on Monday January 16, 2017 @03:17AM (#13408778)
I am not implying any such thing.

What I am implying is that, unfortunately (again), government is the one entity that the common person is given a say in. They aren't a member on any boards, they don't manage philanthropists' thoughts or funds and they own no capital from which to generate their own wealth.

What I am implying is that they can influence the government into addressing their needs, even if superficially.