News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by ChuckMcM on Friday January 13, 2017 @10:26PM (#13396663)
I cannot say I'm very impressed with the article. I could pick out a number of millenials who are doing better than their parents at the same age. But I wouldn't use that to argue that everything is okay.

One thing that has stuck out at me has been the ways in which people have money drained from them. I think there is a huge student loan problem where young people were "sold" a crappy education. But setting that aside for the moment there is a huge difference in lifestyle that I see in people; going out to eat more, paying for basic entertainment, communication charges, credit, and transportation.

Something that seems to be missed on people is that debt is very corrosive to your future wealth. People who carry a balance on a credit card, month after month, may feel like its "okay" because they always have enough to at least pay the minimum but it isn't. When they don't take the time to each bag lunches, breakfast and dinner at home they are sending more of their money out into the world and out of their future. When the world tells them every car has to have backup cameras it means they are going to have bigger car payments. Coffee habits, in app purchases, cable TV instead of free over the air TV.

Some people budget badly, some don't. But before you slam an entire "generation" I think it makes sense to look a bit deeper at the forces at play.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by closeparen on Friday January 13, 2017 @10:41PM (#13396717)
You are slamming an entire generation by claiming that the problem is spending irresponsibly on frivolous things. I don't blame you - it must feel great to feel that the problems of the world are rooted in others being less virtuous than you.

The trouble is, my generation faces lower real wages and higher housing costs, and those effects are so large that Starbucks habits are basically noise in comparison.

That narrative doesn't pat you on the back for your superior discipline, so you're not impresssed with it, and you pivot to anecdata about the moral weakness of kids these days.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by echlebek on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:21PM (#13396848)
Millennial here. I just got the property assessment notice on my modest 1 bedroom condo. The "value" of it has gone up by $200,000 (around 30%) in the last two years according to the assessment office. So I can expect a nice fat tax bill later this year.

The boomer generation, in full control of politics my entire adult life and for the foreseeable future, has made real estate in my city into a ponzi scheme, and I don't ever expect to live in a house here.

What I can expect is to shoulder the tax burden of a large population of people who have not saved nearly enough for retirement, are leveraged against their massively overpriced properties, and are projected to live for a very, very long time. And the data shows that quite clearly.

> Between 1982 and 2010, mortgage debt grew from $99 billion to $994 billion (in current dollars), while consumer debt increased from $48 billion to $460 billion. [1]

> The average market value of an owned dwelling quadrupled, from $71,800 to $303,500 (current dollars) between 1982 and 2008. [1]

> The indebtedness of Canadian households increased from $147 billion in 1982 to $1,454 billion by 2010—in current dollars. [1]

> More than 1.5 million families who have a main provider between 45 and 64 had no private pension savings in 1999, the agency reported Friday. These households will have to rely almost solely on public retirement plans Old Age Security and the Canada or Quebec Pension Plans. [2]

[1] http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/75-001-x/2011002/article/11429-... [2] http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/many-not-saving-enough-for-ret...

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by ThrustVectoring on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:52PM (#13396954)
>What I can expect is to shoulder the tax burden of a large population of people who have not saved nearly enough for retirement

Them saving more wouldn't help much. Saving has a counter-party, someone who gets real goods and services now in exchange for repaying the debt later. Who's the counter-party for the retirees' savings? Obviously it can't be the retirees, since they're busy, you know, being retired.

What'd increased saving would cash out to is shoveling money into repaying education loans held by pension funds that pay the boomers, rather than paying taxes that fund retirement programs. It doesn't mean you don't support retiring boomers, it just means that you get better compensation today for doing so.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by jknoepfler on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:09AM (#13397008)
I'm sorry, did you just complain about making 30% ROI on $200k over two years? Oh no, your tax burden.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by EliRivers on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:17AM (#13398082)
This is nonsensical. I have to pay that extra tax NOW. That's real money that I have to pay out. An extra 30% on something I nominally own? That's not real. I can't pay the taxes with that. What should I do to get that extra 30%? Take out an extra mortgage on that alleged increase in house value? Sell it and move to a worse house in a worse neighbourhood, somewhere I don't really want to live that I can still afford the taxes?

I bought a house that I wanted to live in, that I could afford the taxes on, and now I can't afford the taxes through no fault of my own. There is no solace to be taken in the fact that if I sold it, I might get 30% more than I paid. I don't want the money. If I wanted the money, I wouldn't have bought the house to live in, in the first place. I want what I bought two years ago; the house I could afford to live in. 30% increase in alleged value is of no use to me, and it's costing me money.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Saturday January 14, 2017 @09:32AM (#13398509)
That is exactly the kind of thinking that brought Prop 13 to California back in the 70s.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by EliRivers on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:47AM (#13399216)
The thinking is fine. The thinking is identifying a problem. Prop 13 was wrongfooted and created a new set of problems. We shouldn't ignore a problem just because someone else once royally screwed up a solution to it.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by Jtsummers on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:12AM (#13397016)
It's unrealized earnings. They don't have $200k to spend on taxes, and if they sell the home they still need to buy (or rent) in an area that's very expensive to live. That extra tax burden is not something most people plan on (smart or not, sometimes these booms are more unexpected than others).
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by phil21 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:35AM (#13397076)
Some people just want a place to live close to work/whatever that doesn't have high maintenance (e.g. rent/mortgage/taxes).

In a "hot" city it's trivial to get very modest places that have monthly tax bills more than rent is on a similar sized place in the mid-tier NFL city I grew up in. That's a lot of cashflow to be burning - even if the investment is appreciating faster than the burn. It eventually forces you to sell and move, when your goal was not an investment but a place to live and make a home.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by echlebek on Sunday January 15, 2017 @10:30PM (#13408030)
It's only effectively realizable if I move to a different city, so yes, I did complain about that. I want real estate prices to stabilize.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by Jtsummers on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:33PM (#13396894)
> The trouble is, my generation faces lower real wages and higher housing costs, and those effects are so large that Starbucks habits are basically noise in comparison.

No, that Starbucks habit isn't noise. I consumed Starbucks coffee daily after Christmas a few years back (got a lot of gift cards for them for some reason). It was $2/day for a cup of coffee. $10/week. Continued through the year, $500 (holidays and such mean I won't commute, vacations I may still indulge). That's 2 car payments if you buy a modest car. That's a significant chunk of your rent, possibly all of it, if you're not in NYC or SF or somewhere equally absurdly expensive.

It's like a code smell. If you're consuming pricy drinks on a frequent basis, what else are you doing that you could do for a fraction of the price yourself? Look at every other $1/day habit you have. Sodas? Modest 1/day habit (along with being unhealthy) if you don't buy them at the grocery store is around $2/day (bottle or fountain). That's another $500/year. Netflix + Hulu + Spotify + HBO Now + Amazon Prime + Cable? Do you really need all of them? I didn't, kept Netflix + Amazon Prime and saved $1200/year, more than a rent payment.

There, between coffee, soda, and media, I've saved > $2000. If your income is low, as this article discusses, this is a significant percentage of your income. 4% if your income is only $50k. Higher if you consider your net-income on that and not your gross-income. You still want coffee? I'm in an espresso club at work, 8 people, espresso twice a day, costs me $20/year for my contribution. Drop the sodas, they aren't healthy for you anyways, drink one once a week or so as a treat.

Examine your spending, really look at it. You'll find that you likely have a lot of places where you "leak" money, because it's just a coffee, or just a soda, or just a cocktail. Then it doesn't become an occasional spending thing, like once a week or month. But more frequent, daily or several times a week. Your money is gone and you don't know where it went.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by closeparen on Sunday January 15, 2017 @05:20AM (#13403361)
On the question of "why is Alice poor and Bob well-off" a difference of $10k on the income side is 5x more interesting than a difference of $2k on the expense side, no?

But more generally. "Do you really need this?" is the right question to ask about the expense, effort, and unpleasantness you tolerate from the overhead in life, such as education, work, housing, transportation, sustenance, etc. And yes, you probably need at least the minimum viable product in each category, and the savings to continue purchasing it during unemployment and retirement.

For the rest, I'm much more interested in, "is this worth it?" Good food, books, TV, movies, concerts, theater, and yes, Sunday afternoons at the coffee shop are what all that overhead is for, particularly when shared with people whose company I enjoy.

If I need to find an additional $2k, I will pull it from overheard (be slightly less picky about my next apartment, or put up with a less pleasant commute). Not cut all the enjoyment from my life.

I use (and love) You Need a Budget. My entertainment category is about 5% of my take-home, with savings of about 25%, and I'm satisfied with this. (Of course, I am extremely fortunate to be early in life with a great education, high income, and good health).

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by ChuckMcM on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:27PM (#13396871)
Fair enough, my goal was to respectfully look at the number of additional expense items that are available today which were not part of the "Baby Boomer" menu.

Since I'm an engineer and have been since the 80's and a hiring manager for much of the last 15 years I can tell you that the starting wage for an electrical engineer or a computer programmer with a four year degree is around $85,000 (that was IBM's "standard offer" regardless of geography for a New College Grad with a 4 year degree). My starting wage in 1984 was $25,500 (which was Intel's standard offer for New College Grads with a 4 year degree). According to (https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl) my salary in 1984 would be $60,000 today. That suggests to me that for my job and education there has been a 42% increase in salary.

I certainly agree that where I live (the Bay Area) the price of housing has outpaced that increase in salary, especially in home ownership. That appears to be stabilizing a bit as additional housing comes on line but it remains to be seen if that truly reflects what it costs. I also got married to an engineer and so we were both bringing home "engineering" salaries and that gave us the ability to get into a house in 1988 with a 12% adjustable mortgage rate.

So what does this anecdote tell us? Not a whole lot. Engineers make more today out of college than they did in the 80's. Not really a huge surprise.

I think Internet access is essential today, at its cheapest its probably $30/month, more if you combine it with a phone. That is a cost I didn't have to pay. But its an example of things that people today do have to pay.

Informational value? Not high.

The truth is that not all people born between 1985 and 1995 make 20% less than their parents in 2016 than people who were born from 1955 to 1965 made in 1986. Some make more, some make less, some make about the same. How many? That would be an interesting thing to know but this article doesn't tell us how to understand that. It picks out some anecdotes, sprinkles in some common boogeymen (student loan debt) and implies we're all headed for the crapper.

So it didn't impress me very much.

PS. Don't dismiss the coffee habit out of hand. $500 a year compounded at 4% a year over 40 years (21 -> 61) is a bit more than $50,000 you don't get to spend in retirement.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by maxerickson on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:44PM (#13396929)
Googling "Young Invincibles" (mentioned in the article) quickly leads us to:

http://younginvincibles.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/FHYA-...

(admittedly, by way of

http://younginvincibles.org/

http://younginvincibles.org/financial-security-report/

http://younginvincibles.org/financial-health/

)

They don't particularly show their work there, but it is believable that they are generating the various analyses from the Survey of Consumer Finances done by the Fed (aka decent statistics).

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by ChuckMcM on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:51PM (#13396947)
Thank you for the report link.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by massysett on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:44PM (#13396931)
Sure Internet is $30, but it replaces a whole bundle of other services. Back in 1984 the cost to develop a couple rolls of film and make some long-distance phone calls would easily equal today's internet bill.

The cost of education and health care is what is crushing today's generation, not backup cameras, Starbucks, and iPhones.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by Jtsummers on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:10AM (#13397012)
It compounds, though. You can't tackle your debt if your other cash outflows are too high. iPhone, Starbucks, sodas, cable TV (versus Hulu + Netflix + Amazon, which many have in addition to cable TV), that's 2-4k/year. If your debt is $100k or less, that's 2-4% of the principle that you can pay off as extra in one year of living more modestly, which means you can get your home and other things much earlier.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by developer2 on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:07PM (#13396796)
>> those effects are so large that Starbucks habits are basically noise in comparison

Right, because spending $1500-2000/year on Starbucks and another $2000-$4000+/year on McDonald's and other takeout for 2-3 meals a day is "noise". Consumerism is a very real thing today. There are lower middle class people who blow $30-50 a day on Starbucks, energy drinks, going out for lunch, and ordering pizza for dinner. Throw in alcohol, cigarettes, and/or weed.

You can talk about wages and the price of a home all you want. Nobody 20-40 years ago threw 30-60%+ of their net pay away on daily impulse/routine purchases. Now it's extremely common.

For the pool of people who work 40+ hours a week, while not spending money on any of the stupid things listed above, who still find it hard to make ends meet - those are the people I sympathize with. However, even many people who claim to be wise with their spending like to think that their $7/day Starbucks is just a "small indulgence". $7/day * 5 work days a week * 50 weeks a year = $1750/year. Make it $9-10 dollars a day, for $2500/year, to add a muffin to your morning coffee.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by bradleyprice on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:30PM (#13396879)
I completely agree here. I genuinely feel bad for those who do work hard and try their best. But that is not the case for most of the people I personally know.

I really get tired of hearing people complain about low wages and being broke, but aren't willing on doing anything about it. Ranting on Facebook from their $700 - $800 Iphone while drinking a $5 coffee.

I've worked really hard for everything I have. Late nights on my own, studying to better myself. Missing opportunities to hang out with friends, concerts, etc. But, at the end of the day, I chose to focus on my skills, knowledge, and career. So, when I see these same people complaining, I feel like they are degrading the time I spent and luxuries I gave up to get to where I am.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by developer2 on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:02AM (#13396987)
I forgot about the phone. My sister and her husband fell for that trap. They went further into debt and locked themselves into an expensive family plan for 3 years for their new iPhones.

We live in a really odd time. The concept of money is abstracted away in virtual credit cards - at amounts our parents never had access to. We buy computers and cell phones - things our parents never had. The very idea of spending that kind of money for what you get in return would have been entirely inconceivable for their generation. Today, these things are considered as necessary essentials rather than luxuries.

Good on you for your hard work. I can attest to the fact that it is extremely difficult to ignore conventional modern consumerism. It took me a suicidal "early life crisis" 4 years ago - at the age of 27 - to "get it". I went from being severely in debt (no student loans, just a voluntarily repossessed car and maxed out credit cards), to responsibly paying off every penny. For the first time in my life, I actually have a savings account with some money put away. My spending habits are still not ideal, but I'm doing far better now than I ever did before I hit bottom.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by m0llusk on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:03PM (#13399299)
Putting anecdata in spreadsheet form doesn't fix the problem. If you look at spending data people are putting less into things like food and clothing and transportation than ever before in part because housing and medical costs are out of control. That isn't some made up feel good story pulled out of the air, it is solid verifiable data from government agencies that collect this data as part of tracking people and transaction for tax collection and other reasons.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by sAuronas on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:48AM (#13398163)
Housing costs are probable twice as much... unless you live in CA...then they are 10 times as much. Imagine buying that ranch in the Oakland hills for 70k in the 80s that's worth 800k. There is the ability of these same boomers to fight new construction. Oh and prop 12! Why not defer all the taxes until the sale of the house!? Boomers in CA living in 800k houses paying taxes frozen at 70k. Awesome deal.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by nunez on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:44PM (#13396924)
Herein lies the rub: carrying debt to maximize life now can potentially destroy your future, but the alternative is minimizing life now to improve your potential (and non-guaranteed) future later. It would be a real shame to avoid living the life you want now in hopes of an awesome future, only for the future to hand you a really shitty hand (I.e. Medical bills vaporizing all of your wealth)

I think finding balance is key.

Side note: I'm 29 and have credit card and student loan debt. I'm not proud of it and paying it back is inconvenient, but I'm able to afford the burden at the moment and am enjoying a higher quality of life because of it. I also contribute to my 401k and chose funds with low management overhead, so my future self isn't being completely left out to dry. I literally wouldn't have been on the career track I'm on now had I not taken student loans.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by Jtsummers on Saturday January 14, 2017 @01:35AM (#13397237)
> carrying debt to maximize life now can potentially destroy your future, but the alternative is minimizing life now to improve your potential (and non-guaranteed) future later.

Define maximize and minimize. Is a life lived "to the fullest" worth it, when you find yourself frequently fighting off panic attacks as you realize you have to work until you die? Is a life spent maxing out a couple retirement accounts (IRA, 401k for most of us in the US), along with cooking your own food, and traveling to more modest hotels and always in the cheap airline seats really minimized? You still have time to spend with friends, and you have less stress, and you can still see many (maybe even more) of the places you want without breaking the bank.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by nunez on Sunday January 15, 2017 @12:04AM (#13402442)
I can tell we are probably going to agree to disagree here, but yes, doing all of those things sucks for me.

Making my own food takes time that I could spend doing something else. I also hate cooking, so it sucks even more. I did find cheap frozen food that's good, easy to track and fits my diet, so there's that.

I fly every week for work. Sitting in cheap airline seats for more than three hours is torture in my book. I do realize that some care less about this than others, but getting comfy seats, a decent meal and drinks while being in an enclosed metal tube a mile high really does make a difference for me.

Modest hotels are usually okay, but we need to define "modest" here. If "modest" == hostel or motel, then I'm out. I've done both of those things. I'm good. I don't need the Ritz but a clean, quiet and private room, a comfy bed and security are absolutes for me and motels and hostels vary wildly on having these things.

I would much much rather find ways of maximizing my income. That's actually easier, IMO.

Working "until you die" isn't a bad thing in my book. I really enjoy my work and have for years. I would like financial independence so I can choose what and with whom I'd like to work on and with, but I still see myself working at 60-65 to some capacity in this field, possibly longer.

Example: Being a consultant is really nice if you can find work and enjoy traveling. People pay a lot for your knowledge and they get to benefit from it. I also like the sales aspect of it. I also also like free dinners and drinks!

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by cookiecaper on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:57PM (#13396971)
>carrying debt to maximize life now can potentially destroy your future, but the alternative is minimizing life now to improve your potential (and non-guaranteed) future later.

Isn't this just called "work" or "discipline"? You put up with the drudgery of effort because you want to be able to enjoy the benefits of your labor later. Everything works that way. Not going to get around it.

You're right, though: there is absolutely a balance to be struck. I think the parent's point is that the balance is not being struck well by many. My POV is that that's true, and that cultural and economic forces that encourage this imbalance make it difficult for your average Millennial to avoid.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by maxerickson on Friday January 13, 2017 @10:58PM (#13396770)
I cannot say I'm very impressed with the article. I could pick out a number of millenials who are doing better than their parents at the same age. But I wouldn't use that to argue that everything is okay.

Yeah, anecdotes usually don't stand up well to statistics.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by maxerickson on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:08PM (#13396800)
When the world tells them every car has to have backup cameras

Do you mean they will pursue the camera's aspirationally? It's going to be a mandate soon:

http://www.autonews.com/article/20140331/OEM11/140339979/u.s...

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by ChuckMcM on Saturday January 14, 2017 @12:50AM (#13397119)
No, I mean that the ability to make an "affordable" car is hampered by excessive regulation. In real dollars an entry level car today is 18% more expensive than the same car in the 80's primarily due to additional safety equipment and a lack of 'economy' SKUs. For example, try to buy a car with only the required safety equipment, manual transmission, manual locks/windows etc. Very hard to do unless you go out of your way.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by jacobolus on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:31AM (#13397688)
There are also less than 1/3 the deaths per car mile traveled in the USA today compared to 1980, and cars today produce dramatically less air pollution.
Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by cookiecaper on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:54PM (#13396962)
I agree with you. Our whole economy has been restructured around fat cats finding ways to eek people out of more and more. Without taking a step back, it's hard to realize just how pervasive that's become. I don't attribute this as much to greater discipline by older generations as to cultural and economic differences that made a simpler, more sustainable life the default course.

There are a lot of things about life that are much better now than they were a long time ago. There are new challenges too. To me, this sounds less like an opportunity for a cross-generational blame game and more like an opportunity to collaborate and work to find a good solution.

I personally don't think we're on a stable trajectory as a civilization. Many boomers have virtually no retirement savings (I've heard numbers that say up to half) and over the next decade, continuing to work is not going to be an option anymore for lots of them. They're not going to be able to pay their house payments anymore, let alone anything else. This is what I see as the next major economic crisis.

People don't realize how different our lifestyle today is from any commonly established convention of human habitation. That's been increasingly true over the course of the last 100 years, and we may be far enough detached from the roots now that toppling over is a concern.

People usually live on land that's established as familial territory, aren't required to "pay rent" for much of anything, and use their own land to feed themselves. While this may sound "primitive", it's a lifestyle that can be maintained without the permission of an outside employer, and if you can't make it to your 9-5, you're not imperiled.

Suburban lifestyles are dependent at least on a large existing distribution network and supply chain, and in most cases, the continuing ability to pay rent (or "a mortgage payment") for a very, very long time. Then the children move out and reboot that cycle instead of using the advantages that their progenitors had secured (somewhere to live without paying rent). More traditional family living arrangements are likely going to be needed moving forward.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by jacobolus on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:36AM (#13397698)
Most people throughout the history of agricultural societies have been landless peasants working as serfs for the local lord.

The utopian dream of the self-sufficient yeoman farmer has mostly been a rare exceptional case.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by cookiecaper on Saturday January 14, 2017 @09:01PM (#13401912)
I'm neither an anthropologist nor a historian so my weak grasp on the details is probably going to get me in trouble if I get much deeper into this argument.

I'll just say that personally, I feel that such sentiment is primarily a construction by the same people who are trying to sell us the need for every adult couple to get a new mortgage, to have six figures on loan for education, to pay $75k+ for new cars every 6 years, and so on. I believe they see the citizenry as an asset that should be exploited to bear interest throughout its working life, and longer if possible. This effectively makes the costs of all durable goods 2x-3x more expensive than the already-high sticker price.

Obviously I don't deny that indeed there have been fiefdoms, slaveholders, and other undesirable living conditions, and I'm not advocating for that type of thing. However, I don't think the sentiment that it was nearly-universal is anywhere near correct, nor do I think that a lot of people in a more traditional culture would view their situation with the same suspicion or contempt that the modern Westerner would.

Re:Millennials earn 20% less than Boomers did at same stage ... by jacobolus on Sunday January 15, 2017 @02:36AM (#13402871)
How do you get from «the vast majority of humans ever living in agricultural societies throughout history were serfs» to “a construction by the same people who are trying to sell us [...]”

I promise I’m not trying to sell you anything. I hardly ever drive a car and only own a used one because my wife likes road trips (I’d be happy to get rid of it), have mostly avoided student loans, live relatively frugally (with the notable exception of buying too many used books), and think it sounds just fine if you do the same. If you want to argue for Marxist critiques of late capitalism or for Buddhist asceticism or whatever, I’m happy to concede the point.

In general, I’d say the people who are trying to sell you something don’t give a damn about economic or social history, and aren’t going to bother “constructing” some vast conspiracy to trick you about the past.

My direct experience is mostly with researching my own ancestors, who were landless peasant farmers living in Ireland, and with decades of close experience with indigenous rural peasants in Mexico (such as my godparents), whose families were mostly quasi-slave migrant agricultural laborers for the past few hundred years, under the oppressive control of the Spanish.

Admittedly, both of those cases were people living at the fringes of empire under an imperialist/capitalist global order. But my research of other times and places suggests that conditions were much the same in most times and most places (e.g. throughout pre-industrial Europe, China, India, and the Middle East). If you want a nice introduction, try Graeber’s book Debt: The First 5000 Years.

Whether rural peasants would view their situations with “suspicion or contempt” is something you can directly ask of the remaining rural peasants in the world. I don’t know about suspicion per se, but for the most part they would prefer to have running water, electricity, televisions, cellphones, modern medical care, non-leaking roofs, a stove that didn’t fill their rooms with outrageous quantities of wood smoke, education for their children, a stable source of income, etc., even at the expense of leaving their families to work in horrendous factories and live in urban slums.

Obviously it’s harder to ask people from a few centuries ago, but I’ll note that my own ancestors took the first available opportunity to flee their ancestral homelands and travel across an ocean away from all of their support networks at great risk and expense, for the mere promise of a better deal.