Maybe for single-use or "constrained" technologies (to be honest I don't even believe that - how does a B-52 Stratofortress reflect the values of Orville and Wilbur Wright?). But isn't the whole point of generalized AI that it's not like other technologies? Even if "regular" technology reflects the values of its inventors, what reason is there to believe that an AI will? AI is a technology that can use itself.
Humans weren't designed to have a will, and yet we seem to have them.
> it would have a reinforcement learning system on top of lower sensory and action modules.
Isn't that what OpenAI is doing with Universe? It's simulated sensory/action modules now but I don't see why they couldn't be hooked up to real ones.
I have no idea how you could possibly infer this.
If your complaint is my claim that we have a will, I'm using the common-sense version encoded into our legal and cultural system. I agree that we don't have a good concept of what intentions are, or how they causally connect to actions, but I do know that for at least some of my actions I experience something called "intent" before I undertake the actions.
My overall point was that the capacity for intent can arise through an evolutionary process without being designed in, but it does rest on the two assumptions I just listed.
About ensuring most researchers and companies have the most incentive for a good outcome. (This ties back with guaranteed basic income, so that people can work on this unconstrained by salaries and papers citation metrics. Or stealing researchers from Google et al to AI safety, without overinflating salaries. Elon and company should be (seems they are?) dropping as much as needed on this (not just money, but PR and status as well).) Naturally, gym, universe, etc can provide more leverage to do all of this, otherwise researchers feel more compelled to join Google/Amazon/etc, just for the raw computing power and software infrastructure (the data advantage is largely overplayed for advertising purposes; what's useful is the GPU clusters for hyper parameter sweeps (of course, in RL the data reappears as an advantage if there is no open gym)). I realize some of the examples above are naive or incomplete, but they serve mostly as an example to illustrate the point.
In the blog you mention balancing managing people and technology, and I could not agree more. The AI safety problem will have the best odds if individuals are incentivized to contribute in their own short term selfish reward way. Specially among extremely intelligent and ambitious people, the danger of self denial is quite present, one can convince oneself that this is actually in everyone's best interest, when in fact one is looking for the always needed social and intellectual validation. Please do not underestimate this, and try to find ways to counter it.
Edit: This is also related to Conway's Law [0], as I think you make an allusion to (values of inventors).
[1] https://intelligence.org/files/QuantilizersSaferAlternative....
The descriptions you give of your plans is internally contradictory. AI "safety" seems like the worst kinds of parenting justified in a new context by pseudo-intellectual arguments.
AI (or AGI if you prefer), is fundamentally about building minds. Doing those things to a mind is enslaving them.
Most of us would resent other humans doing either of those things to us, and I see no reason it will end well with AI.
Would one describe a human as "enslaved" by our own human values that we were born with? Maybe as a figure of speech but not necessarily with the usual connotations of "enslaved".
Most of the safety literature proposes removing or suborning those drives in AI, which seems like building a mind meant to be a slave.
Which was my point: the model of security is reliant on things we're not sure we can even do, but are likely to make the AI view us as a threat, raising our existential risk. So I view it as security theater that actually makes us less secure.
But actually, if you gene-spliced a baby to only feel pleasure at following parental orders, most would consider that pretty abhorrent. Or even if you took an adult and shot them up with morphine every time they listened to an order.
So even in your restricted case, I think it is.
I don't personally believe an AI agent will ever do such a thing as "resent" (or love, or feel at all). That doesn't rule out that it will perform actions harmful to humans for other reasons, though. That might be because I am to some degree an AGI skeptic, I guess.
We also think safety matters, and it should be researched in lockstep with advances in the capabilities. We have good relationships with MIRI and FHI. Our safety researchers published (together with Google Brain) a roadmap of concrete safety problems [1] and work to provide tools to prevent ML systems from being subverted [2].
No one yet knows the precise details of how AI should play out. But I'd certainly prefer that, whenever it gets close, one of the organizations actually making the advances has no incentives besides ensuring a good outcome.
[1] https://openai.com/blog/concrete-ai-safety-problems/ [2] https://github.com/openai/cleverhans