News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sound of Silence by Udo on Friday January 13, 2017 @10:19AM (#13391415)
People are starting to realize (en masse now), this is the downside of permitting group identity-based "discussions" to flourish. Whatever you say, people are going to try interpreting it against the group you are perceived to belong to, eagerly pouncing on things that are in "conflict" with their own group identity. I put conflict in quotes here because this ultimately empty conflict is what actually drives both sides. Facts and open discussion are utterly irrelevant in this process, instead your words just get parsed for trigger phrases.

There is an argument to be made that internet discussions have always been at risk, and I think it's indeed a known pathology. However, subjectively, it seems to me this has escalated in a massive way within the last two years - to the point that important issues have effectively been taken off the discussion table because the participant pool is entirely made up of people fighting content-free meme wars.

In my opinion, the only way to combat this is to violate the rules of these meme wars and start talking about content again. But I wouldn't recommend it for high profile personalities whose job entails getting along with as many people as possible, because the fears of backlash are absolutely justified even if you might garner more respect this way in the long term. Worse yet, once a discussion has been taken over by mindless reactions like this, it becomes very difficult to form your own opinion rationally because it involves separating what the memes want of you from whatever the facts and your internal thoughts say.

As a rule of thumb: if both parties are angry at you, you're on the right track.

Personally I think the current state of things is either unsustainable, meaning the group identity thing is going to burn itself out over time, or it's a new low-energy state as far as human thought process goes which means it's going to be permanent. Either way, at least some influential people need to fight this, even if it means you'll be perceived as having rough edges.

Re:The Sound of Silence by rntz on Friday January 13, 2017 @10:55AM (#13391714)
> As a rule of thumb: if both parties are angry at you, you're on the right track.

No; this is an excuse to pat yourself on the back for being contrary. Don't validate your beliefs by how much they make others angry, any more than you validate them by how much they make others happy.

> the group identity thing

Group identity and culture wars are not new (and are certainly not going away). It's plausible to me that the internet is making this worse - a premise of your post - but I'm not yet convinced. It's possible they're merely coincident. What concrete reasons are there to believe the internet is a primary cause of today's increasingly vitriolic culture wars, rather than merely a new venue in which they are being pursued?

Re:The Sound of Silence by Udo on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:17PM (#13393075)
Not sure how to reply to this, it seems I certainly failed to get the point across here.

> No; this is an excuse to pat yourself on the back for being contrary. Don't validate your beliefs by how much they make others angry

That was absolutely not what I intended to say with this admittedly tongue-in-cheek quip. There is a kernel of (subjective) truth in there though: if you find yourself agreeing with one side of a meme war 100% on everything, it's most likely time to rethink some assumptions. Conversely, if you're not agreeing wholesale, you just have a target on your back, that's a given. So I could have worded that better, it doesn't have anything to do with being contrarian for the sake of causing offense.

> Group identity and culture wars are not new (and are certainly not going away).

I thought I addressed that. Again, I probably worded it too obtusely.

Re:The Sound of Silence by mst on Friday January 13, 2017 @04:59PM (#13395093)
In defense of your quip, if I get called both a misogynist and a radfem for the same opinion, I can fairly reliably expect that over the subsequent few days I'll get a number of people with moderate opinions contacting me privately to thank me for saying what they were thinking but were too scared of internet shitstorms to post publically.
Re:The Sound of Silence by yakult on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:55PM (#13396963)
There is danger in the middle ground as well, though. Many middle grounds are factually incorrect, for example between evolutionists and people who believe god put fossils underground to troll archaeologists.

Further, as a strategy it is exploitable: say you have opinion X and I want you at X+1. I can manipulate you by loudly proclaiming X+2.

tl;dr: there are no easy heuristics here. Treat the entire communication environment as hostile and manipulative, form your opinions with great care, and double check all your sources.

Re:The Sound of Silence by mst on Saturday January 14, 2017 @08:23AM (#13398265)
I find it highly unlikely that Jessica was referring to being unable to say publically that evolution is a real thing.

Additionally, I said that, having already formed my opinion X, if I get that response, I can predict certain things. This is very different from your 'exploit' which requires the reverse process.

I'm afraid you've provided cogent and valid criticisms of a completely different set of statements than I actually made.

Re:The Sound of Silence by james-watson on Saturday January 14, 2017 @02:29AM (#13397374)
I enjoy that you had the courage to bring "factually incorrect" into this conversation.

If someone, anyone, goes looking for the facts, there is only one destination in which they will end up. The facts aren't hard to find. They are all in boring science textbooks. But nobody reads those anymore.

The current culture war is waged by those who profit off ignorance against those who crusade for truth. You may think this is a black and white view of it, but it isn't. One side wishes to obliterate facts, the other wishes to incinerate pretty lies at the expense of hurt feelings.

So yes, there are a great many positions that are factually incorrect. All of them, to be exact, except the factually correct ones.

The problem of course is that facts can be inconvenient to those who seek power.

Re:The Sound of Silence by rntz on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:43AM (#13462440)
> That was absolutely not what I intended to say with this admittedly tongue-in-cheek quip.

Thank you for clarifying.

> There is a kernel of (subjective) truth in there though: if you find yourself agreeing with one side of a meme war 100% on everything, it's most likely time to rethink some assumptions.

Yes. But "you're probably wrong if you agree with anyone completely" and "you're probably right if you disagree with most people" are very different.

> > Group identity and culture wars are not new (and are certainly not going away).

> I thought I addressed that.

I think here it's me who has been unclear. That was just an introductory remark. The substance of that part of my comment was to wonder whether the internet is really what's been exacerbating the current culture wars and factionalism, or if it's just coincidental. I still don't feel confident either way on that question.

Re:The Sound of Silence by abecedarius on Friday January 13, 2017 @04:27PM (#13394833)
The printing press seems to have been a prime cause of the Protestant Reformation with its attendant wars. Years ago a friend predicted to me that social media would increase conflict analogously. I'm not sure he was right, but clearly events have gone in the right direction.
Re:The Sound of Silence by msabalau on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:31AM (#13392114)
Given that the 20th century is the century of genocide, it seems less than certain that the long term trend is "increasingly vitriolic".
Re:The Sound of Silence by ysavir on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:57AM (#13392366)
The 20th century isn't the century of genocide; it's the century of media covered genocide.
Re:The Sound of Silence by rntz on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:46PM (#13393416)
This is true. It does seem, however, like that is the short-term trend of the last decade or three. Things don't have to be as bad as the mid 20th century to be worrying.
Re:The Sound of Silence by jacobush on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:34AM (#13392147)
We always have nukes
Re:The Sound of Silence by maxxxxx on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:20PM (#13393105)
"As a rule of thumb: if both parties are angry at you, you're on the right track."

That's the same fallacy as saying "The truth is somewhere in between". If everybody is angry at you, maybe you just said something universally stupid. Or maybe you were right. You can't make this a rule.

Re:The Sound of Silence by mentat on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:38PM (#13393320)
Perhaps expands to "in a world where anger is a proxy for nonconformance, and where even nuance is nonconformance, and if nuance is good because reality is not two sided, then having people angry at you is indicative of maturity in an immature world".

There's a lot to disagree with there, probably mostly around two sided-ness though there's mostly a lack of tech in meme wars, they haven't figured out how to make smaller groups and dynamically manage them effectively. I know that nuance as a sign of maturity is also directly under attack and that there's no apriori way to justify it.

Re:The Sound of Silence by Udo on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:22PM (#13393135)
I addressed this in the other comment. It was a shitty way to convey a slightly different point. Sorry about that.
Re:The Sound of Silence by ScottBurson on Saturday January 14, 2017 @01:51AM (#13397285)
It's fine. It's a rule of thumb -- the very phrase you used -- not an absolute.
Re:The Sound of Silence by EdHominem on Friday January 13, 2017 @05:32PM (#13395381)
The logical complement is more reasonable: "If everyone is happy with you you're likely doing things wrong."

And the more general: "If idiots are happy with you, you're likely an idiot too - or just acting like one."

Re:The Sound of Silence by maxxxxx on Friday January 13, 2017 @07:34PM (#13396037)
I think both of these can't be generalized . Sometimes they are true, sometimes not.
Re:The Sound of Silence by chillingeffect on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:47AM (#13392281)
I generally agree, but would suggest amending "permitting group identity-based 'discussion' to flourish." The issue IMO, is not the activity of the discussion, but the impoverished shortcut of identity as a classification. My apologies if this is what you intended. It came out to me as if the discussion were to be avoided, rather than the lens of identity.

All "identities" are crude prejudice. They're a pair of glasses we put on to try to perceive things a certain way. This is an artifact of "Motivated Reasoning." Anticipating someone's vote based on their melanin is harmful and self-defeating in the long run. As you say, we should discuss content, or "issues." Instead of negating everything e.g. YouKnowWho does, we need to debate each bill on its own merit.

Re:The Sound of Silence by wodencafe on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:07AM (#13391829)
To your point about online discussions, it's made worse by most websites getting rid of usernames, and replacing them with your real name.

Or worse even, they use a Facebook discussion plugin, so whatever you say is attached to your Facebook account.

Re:The Sound of Silence by bduerst on Friday January 13, 2017 @11:43AM (#13392249)
How is that? I thought that adding a potential reputation cost to discussion actually helped curb anonymous trolling.
Re:The Sound of Silence by gohrt on Friday January 13, 2017 @03:27PM (#13394407)
It curbs privacy and the ability to explore controversial ideas. As Facebook shows, there are more than plenty non-anonymous trolls.
Re:The Sound of Silence by mgkimsal on Friday January 13, 2017 @01:15PM (#13393058)
it also makes it easier to associate views with someone, whether they want those views known outside of a smaller group or not.
Re:The Sound of Silence by gohrt on Friday January 13, 2017 @03:27PM (#13394406)
It curbs privacy and the ability to explore controversial ideas.
Re:The Sound of Silence by nitrogen on Friday January 13, 2017 @05:07PM (#13395167)
It's possible that the actual effect is to limit discussion to those who don't care about their reputation.