Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by oddlyaromatic on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @04:12PM
(#13377516)
I think this is mostly about what the formal and informal definitions of being depressed are. Informally people describe depressive states, and feelings of sadness, loss of hope, desperation, and so on as "being depressed". Those feelings are awful, but if they are coherent with real circumstances like grief, or a job you hate, then those feelings are somewhat appropriate and changing circumstances should help. Depression, the disease, is not coherent with reality or circumstances. It unfortunate that the same word it's used for these related but different states.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by jpfed on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @04:36PM
(#13377699)
>Depression, the disease, is not coherent with reality or circumstances.
Where are people getting this idea? I mean, I suppose I could accept it as a definitional exercise in the same way that I can accept the idea that "gurple" is a bluish tint of red. But if you look at, say, a recent DSM, it doesn't say that external circumstances preclude a diagnosis of depression.
Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by oddlyaromatic on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:52PM
(#13378211)
I have in my life been very closely connected to several people with depression and maybe that experience is influencing my opinion too much, I will check out some resources and diagnostic criteria, as it has been a while!