Re:Ask YC: What is your favourite paradox?
by mattmaroon on Monday March 10, 2008 @10:42PM
(#133777)
In that same article you linked it explains why those paradoxes don't prove shit.
True. Perhaps I should have put quotes around proves. Still, I remember what a big impact Zeno had on me as a young philosophy student.
You should have studied math. ;)
Zeno is still my favorite. To summarize in modern terms: in order for a particle to move 1 inch, it must first move 1/2 inch. Before it can move 1/2 inch, it must move 1/4 inch. Before it can move 1/4 inch, it must move 1/8 inch. And so on. The paradox is, if a particle has to traverse an infinite number of infinitely small spaces before it can move even one inch, how is it possible that it can move at all?
Some mathematicians pull out calculus to "disprove" the paradox, but to me it disproves nothing. For example, you can show, mathematically, that sum( 1/(2^N) ) = 1 as N goes from 1 to infinity. The problem is that you have to go to infinity before it will sum to 1. If space is infinitely divisible and a particle has to traverse an infinite number of subspaces in order to move just a nanometer, I still don't see how it's possible that it could move at all.
Re:Ask YC: What is your favourite paradox?
by anewaccountname on Tuesday March 11, 2008 @12:54PM
(#134378)
Time is very similar to space; what you are saying is like saying you don't see how it take up any space at all.
Love Zeno's paradoxes. And apparently they aren't fully resolved today -- is the universe quantized? Is spacetime really continuous, or is that an unrealistic mathematical abstraction?
Zeno's paradox (deliberately?) confuses a thing — motion — with its measurement. You can always measure something with higher resolution, but so what?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno's_paradoxes
Those ancient Greeks knew their shit.