News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by leetrout on Monday January 09, 2017 @08:51PM (#13361849)
When I was a volunteer firefighter circa 1999 we were forced to learn the definition of fire that would appease a lawyer / court in case we got subpoenaed.

Apparently somewhere else there had been an arson fire and the fire chief was on the stand and the defense asked him what fire was and all he could come up with was "it's hot" or something similar. I don't know if it caused the case to be won or lost but our Chiefs decided we wouldn't chance the embarrassment.

I'll now forever remember that "fire is the rapid oxidation of a combustible material resulting in the release of energy in the form of heat and light".

Still waiting on that subpoena and my chance to put this to good use. Or at least trivia night or something...

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by jventura on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @05:56AM (#13364008)
I was also a volunteer firefighter around those years as well but we had to learn the definition of fire using the fire triangle [0]. It is a simple model to reason about fire and how to extinguish it: just remove any of the three components (oxygen, heat or fuel).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_triangle

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by OscarCunningham on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:00AM (#13364735)
Halon fire extinguishers are interesting in that they disrupt the chemical reaction of the fire directly. There's still fuel, heat and oxygen, but they just don't react.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by hermitdev on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @06:00PM (#13370053)
When I was an intern, I worked in IT for a Fortune 500 company. They'd recently decommissioned their old tape loaders for the mainframe and had moved to an automated tape silo, so no longer had need for the tape room. They converted the tape room that was connected into a conference room, but they didn't disconnect the HALON. Although, smoking wasn't allowed in the facility anyway (this was early 2000s), they always made a point to remind us visitors (the data center was a several hour drive from corporate) to not smoke, and if the alarm went off, you had about 10 seconds to exit the room before the door automatically shut, with no way to exit from the inside and all oxygen would be evacuated from the room, and you would die a horrible, horrible death.

I always tried to get a seat as close to the door as possible.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by mianos on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @06:55AM (#13373301)
Locking doors and oxygen removal would have been just a fun story. Halogen gas, at a concentration needed to disrupt a fire, is only mildly dangerous and you don't need to remove the air when you are using halogen. The halogen does not work by displacement but actually disrupts the combustion process. No need to lock the doors.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by couchand on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:46AM (#13365118)
And that is a great example of Spolsky's Law of Leaky Abstractions.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by harperlee on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:19PM (#13369105)
Although to be fair the link that was provided also adds the "chain reaction" in a fire tetrahedron.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by leetrout on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:41AM (#13365590)
And fun/scary fact- they DON'T work on lithium ion batteries... I think it might slow it down but it doesn't stop them.

https://batterybro.com/blogs/18650-wholesale-battery-reviews...

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by stoolpigeon on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @07:46AM (#13364421)
That's what I was taught in the Navy for my various firefighting courses - along with types of fires, how to handle the various types, and so on. Very useful stuff.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by jschwartzi on Monday January 09, 2017 @11:43PM (#13362635)
That reminds me of how one of my Physics instructors made us memorize Archimedes' principle:

The buoyant force on an object is equal to the weight of the displaced fluid.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by dnautics on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:32AM (#13362854)
to be honest I don't think that this article answers the question 'what is fire' but more 'what exactly is the flame of a fire'
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by couchand on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:49AM (#13365139)
There is mention early of fire in the technical sense, before moving on to considering flame in greater detail. For my part, on reading the headline I expected and hoped that the discussion was about flame. Naming things is hard.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by hvidgaard on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @01:56AM (#13363196)
Isn't the flames the fire? If you only have embers, you wouldn't call it a fire.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:49AM (#13365143)
Can you have a flame without the fire? You certainly can have something very similar. Personally, I think those names are all confusing and ill-defined.

Does "fire" imply in sustainability? Does it need to be combustion? Does it even have to be chemical?

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by richmarr on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @06:34AM (#13364128)
> If you only have embers, you wouldn't call it a fire.

Well, you might

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_seam_fire

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by dnautics on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:22PM (#13369140)
You can certainly have fires without flames. Particularly notorious is hydrogen, which burns cleanly with no flame (just heat ripples). This is one of the major challenges for hydrogen fueled vehicles:. First responders need to be aware that the combustion properties for a hydrogen vehicle are different and could be deceptively more dangerous than their trained instinct.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by sandworm101 on Monday January 09, 2017 @09:24PM (#13362020)
Heat and radiation, some of which is called light. Infrared energy isn't really heat, nor is it generally called light as it isnt visible.

Similarly, many chemical fires release substantial amounts of UV, but i doubt anyone would see much of it in an emergency through all the smoke and ir. Think rocket fuels.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by nsxwolf on Monday January 09, 2017 @09:59PM (#13362177)
I've frequently seen "light" used to refer to the entire electromagnetic spectrum in physics discussions.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by swift on Monday January 09, 2017 @11:15PM (#13362522)
Yeah, I typically hear visible light referred to as, well, "visible light". It may depend on the whims of the particular textbooks and professors you learned from, but in my physics classes we always used "light" to refer to the entire electromagnetic spectrum, and I only realized relatively late in life that some people don't use the terminology that way.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by nsxwolf on Monday January 09, 2017 @11:20PM (#13362541)
Plus I like to think of all light as being "visible" to some material or apparatus. Our eyes just happen to be tuned to a particular part of the spectrum. You don't even have to look very far to find other animals that can see wavelengths we can't, like ultraviolet. Radio antennas "see" radio waves, film emulsions and CCDs "see" X-rays, etc.

Also with radio we talk about different materials being "transparent" to one wavelength or another.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by hermitdev on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @06:09PM (#13370121)
If you ever want to have some fun flying, carry some lead crystal in your carry on luggage. A number of years back, I was visiting my parents for Christmas, and they gave me a set of lead crystal tumblers. Apparently due mostly to the lead and partly to the cut of the tumblers, they appeared as hand grenades on the luggage scanner. The look of absolute puzzlement on the TSA agents' faces were priceless. They could not reconcile what they saw on their scanners with what they held in their hand, even when I explained what it was. I've had similar experiences flying with lead crystal ornaments. Which, while always a gift, I never have wrapped while I'm flying, because I know, inevitably I'd need to open it, anyway.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by nsxwolf on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:46PM (#13375780)
That's great! I wouldn't have helped them! I would have just said "Those are drinking glasses."
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by harperlee on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:22PM (#13369134)
It's amazing to think that, for the wifi module, the rest of the laptop is more or less transparent, as in a crystal case.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by sandworm101 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @03:56AM (#13363583)
And ive seen oxygen and argon called "metals" (in stars). Each field has thier own terms.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by zodiac on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:09AM (#13364513)
Well the metallic state has a pretty precise definition, presumably the oxygen in stars exists in that state. (Whereas oxygen in air does not)
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by MereInterest on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:18AM (#13364545)
Nope, not at all. In astrophysics, "metal" refers to any element heavier than helium, regardless of oxidation state. It is a useful definition, because only hydrogen and helium were present from the big bang. The metallicity of a star then determines the age of the nebula that formed it. More metals (in the astrophysical sense) means that other stars had to exist, make heavier elements, and explode prior to that stars birth.

It's a different definition, but it is quite useful in the field.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by sandworm101 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:14PM (#13366551)
Again, "the metalic state" is for a different field. Same root words, different definitions and uses depending on context.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by johncolanduoni on Monday January 09, 2017 @11:23PM (#13362551)
Physicists (even those who work in optics) routinely use light to mean anything on the EM spectrum, so I'm not sure where you're getting the "right" technical definition.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by sandworm101 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @03:53AM (#13363570)
Because this is a firefighter's definition for use in a courtroom. It isnt about physics but the realities of flame. In the real world there are things like "invisible fire", common at racetracks during the day, that need to be accounted for. Tge physics of stellar astronomy do not.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by johncolanduoni on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:19AM (#13363650)
"nor is it generally called light" sure doesn't sound like it's talking about the specific, legally relevant definition used by firefighters.

Also most physicists whose work is centered around EM radiation aren't astrophysicists and plenty of them work specifically with visible light, so your patronization is off the mark.

Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by sandworm101 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:24AM (#13363679)
Most physicists also do not have much experiance with uncontrolled fire. To say that all fires produce light will be confusing if trying to explain non-visible flames to a lay jury.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by kgwgk on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @07:42AM (#13364408)
If you want to be pedant, the energy from the combustion is released in the form of heat (some of which is called radiation (some of which is called light)).
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by bandrami on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:35AM (#13365535)
Eh. Heat is energy with certain entropic characteristics. Electromagnetic radiation carries that energy, but is not itself the energy.
Re:What’s a fire, and why does it burn? by kgwgk on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:35PM (#13366797)
I was paraphrasing a previous comment. Heat is the energy transferred between systems and that's how I interpreted the "energy is released in the form of" in the original comment.

I'm not sure what is your point. Do you think that saying that the "energy is released in the form of heat and radiation" is better? To me that seems like saying "energy is released in the form of heat (i.e. energy transferred) and radiation (i.e. one the transfer mechanisms)". Do you like "heat (some of which is transferred through radiation (some of which is called light))" better?