Optimizing for just this aspect ignores the fact that perhaps i don't want to use photoshop to manip an image because i can get more desirable results organically using chemicals and my hands rather than a mouse. Photography is an art for many. It may be easy to mimic the results with digital editing, but it is much more difficult to discover new and unique things.
For example, ML can mimic existing work:
https://qz.com/495614/computers-can-now-paint-like-van-gogh-...
But ML is not a painter that will produce substantially meaningful, original work.
I wish I could upvote you twice. I never understand this mentality. And then on the same side people love the ultra-generic over-saturated tone-mapped HDR with 10-stop ND filter of a creek stuff you see on the explore page of Flickr every day. It's probably too much to ask of people who aren't photographers though. I can't blame people for thinking this way when the entire camera upgrade cycle is based on always more resolution and color accuracy. It's easier for companies to sell cameras this way.
This, for me, is an act of alchemy, a bit of magic, which brings a special kind of awe and changes my attitude to the scene, to the moment I am taking the photo, and thus changes the outcome.
I rarely shoot film, but when I do, it feels special.
Light-sensitive transistors to electricity to software to memory feels much more ephemeral. Not less magic, but less al-chemical.
If this is a common sentiment then here's an idea for a product: a digital camera that donates $1 to the red cross for every picture you take, charged to your bank account. Not only would it restore this "restraint", it would help people in need while also removing the usage of chemicals that are bad for health and environment.
That all said, I agree with the op.
Because manufacturing digital cameras doesn't involve chemicals that are bad for health and environment...
I shoot film because it requires me to slow down and think about each shot
On a related note: I think there's actually a huge advantage to fixed focal lenses. They slow you down!They force you to really engage with the picture you intend to take. You can't just zoom in on your motive and snap away and I always thought that's a good thing.
So, yeah, I have quite a lot of experience with the nature of film photography.
Once the first decent DSLRs appeared on the market, I switched and never looked back.
I was objecting to the implied snobbery in the OP, e.g. "if you actually knew what you were doing, you'd want to shoot film for everything".
Yes, I do know what I'm doing, and no, I don't want to shoot film. Neither do the vast majority of working professional photographers (I'm not one, myself, but I know a fair number of them). Digital has become better in just about every respect you can name. Yes, you can find the occasional art photographer who still shoots film, but there aren't many of them.
The film guys are exactly like the vinyl record guys -- they're basing their preference on factors other than quantifiable objective data.
I'm not a professional photographer, but a fairly serious amateur - I broke 10k photos/year at peak, and have been published and done minor gallery shows. I'll shoot a few rolls of film a year, entirely for fun. I enjoy the process, and use it to impose restrictions on myself. (The last time I shot film, I was with a friend who was modeling for me. I told her we had 36 photos available, and that was that. It really made us think, rather than just blowing through 10x that many because we could.) If I need to shoot volume, or use studio lighting, or work in any sort of difficult lighting conditions, I'll use digital, absolutely.
It's quite possible to shoot both digital and film, for different reasons, and not just be a pretentious hipster who doesn't care about "quantifiable objective data".
That's why I think there is still a place for film. Fidelity doesn't equal quality.
Nobody is saying "If you actually knew what you were doing, you'd want to shoot film for everything." Someone is, in fact, saying "The only reason to shoot film is because you're a pretentious hipster". Who's being judgmental here?
Well, except for the original poster to whom I was replying. That's a pretty good paraphrase of what he said.
And I was the OP. I know what I said, and you paraphrased it terribly. If I thought people should shoot film for everything, I'd do it myself. Instead, film is maybe 2-3% of my output.
I've been shooting for almost 25 years, and invested lots of money into 35mm cameras and lenses. To replace my equipment with digital equivalents would cost many thousands of dollars. Also, I feel like film photography requires one to slow down and think more while shooting, a benefit that isn't readily apparent to every user, but (for me) results in much better photographs.
I feel compelled to point out for passers by that this is not really completely true: very few 35mm lens formats are wholly incompatible with modern digital bodies, and most support graceful degradation for things like autofocus. However, the crushing truth is that older optics are often insufficient for modern digital full frame sensors. A normal f/1.8 50mm plastic-fantastic Canon lens will give you sharper resolving power 90% of the time than an older equivalent, and only costs $100. Sure, you lose something in bokeh, but that's often irrelevant. Also, there are many compelling technologies that have emerged in lenses recently that are very useful for realistic shooting scenarios: stronger autofocus, quieter operation, better anti-flare coatings, lighter construction, superior per-image documentation (eg. specific zoom lens position recording in EXIF), ability to immediately shift between a far broader range of sensitivities than film and shoot confidently in near-dark, etc. You get none of that staying still, even though the benefits of equipment familiarity should never be understated. Where film does shine is resolution with good optics and larger (>35mm) formats, and dynamic range (though this will come under threat soon, and cannot match multi-exposure HDR).
I'm not a film apologist - digital is awesome, and for most use cases, superior. If I were a working photographer, I'd definitely be shooting digital. For artistic photography though, on a hobbyist level, I'm fine with film. When I need a digital camera, I have a pretty decent sensor built into my phone that I can use.
The only 'problem' is that the smaller sensor means that the old glass is effectively longer. In practice it means that some of the old glass gives beautiful results because you are only using the centre part of the lens, resulting in less distortion.
While certain of the new digital bodies are compatible with certain older film bodies and can use the same lenses and accessories, that's not universally the case, AFAIK.
Even the newest Nikon cameras can use F-mount lenses from 1959. Some of the metering modes are not available in some or all cameras. Some cheaper digital cameras cannot autofocus with lenses that don't have built-in autofocus motor.
http://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/nikortek.htm
Canon DSLRs can use old EF lenses (since 1987).
Olympus OM lenses (since 1972) can be mounted to Olympus (and other) Four Thirds cameras using an adapter.
Also, ancient M42 lenses (since 1949) can be connected to most modern DSLRs using adapters.
Unless the camera system had autofocus in the body (which, as far as I've been experienced with, really only is medium format bodies) the lens always has had autofocus. Canon, Nikon etc.
The problem is that a lot of adapters for old lenses only feed mechanical (if even) instructions to the lens, for aperture and the like, and don't send over autofocus instructions.
Luckily manual focus will work just fine.
Nikon's compatibility with old lenses is quite stunning. They did one major change to their mount in the 70s but every mid-range or highrr camera since then has had 100% compatibility with any lens. Metering, aperture control, everything. The AF system still works too. You just have to use your hand as the AF motor and the camera will give you an indication when it thinks focus is correct.
Nothing about the experience of developing film sounds interesting to me.
Would you mind sharing other subtle nuances of shoot on film vs digital?
With film you have to supplement a lot of what's achievable in digital via guessing and checking with careful thought. You also have many fewer opportunities to get the shot right before you exhaust your film and probably blow the moment replacing it.
This makes film into a forcing function to perform excellent technique and to pre-visualize your shot. This creates better technique.
It's also nice that film has a very high effective resolution (when drum scanned), that film grain is a favorable aesthetic right now (it was usually considered ugly before digital), and that film has a logarithmic response to light meaning that it can handle a wider dynamic range than digital.
On the other hand, scientific imaging is definitely something where non-emotional performance matters and I doubt people use film for any kind of scientific work these days.
Not sure if that situation still exists in DV but for digital photography that stopped being true a long time ago (the balance started shifting almost 10 years ago), most digital sensors support more stops than even the best brands of film.
That said, subjectively I still feel that way. It might have something to do with digital noise and how the experience of actually witnessing different exposures feels between the two media.
I see a lot of photographers starting out not learning the craft. Some of the convenience of digital can reinforce bad habits. You can shoot a thousand photos in a few minutes, switching between a bunch of modes and options that you don't truly understand, and inevitably get a few decent photos. This isn't a fault of digital, it's just human behavior. I think for this reason, a lot of schools are still using film when teaching photography.
As an artist, I have a use for both digital and film photography. There's something about the way film feels, and the way the process of shooting film makes me feel, that makes me enjoy it so much more. My old Pentax cameras are very substantial, physical objects. The shutter opens and closes, and you can feel it - it's a physical act. Digital cameras don't have the same physicality about them. I still use both digital and film, they each have their own advantages to me and have their place.
Darkroom work was rewarding in its own way (for B&W). But, honestly, it was always a means to an end. I knew people who would spend all day making the perfect print. I never had that kind of patience.
I'm not one for strong opinions either way, I think there's a place for film photography and also for digital, and I like both.
Funny, I shoot film on my Minolta X700 (for over 25 years) because I DON'T have to slow down. What I see in my viewfinder is exactly what I'm going to see on film. The joys of real SLR versus Digital SLR. Your camera screen is not reliable for color reproduction - raw optics are.
If you shoot raw you can always tweak the color balance in post-production anyway.
The Minolta X700 does do that via a secondary faux-shutter mechanism and a light sensor. If you actually bothered to have a battery installed (which dies after about 8 shots,) the tiny auto-exposure sensor inside would take over and the faux secondary shutter would move out of the way.
I have no idea what the faux shutter is because the camera had a fairly conventional horizontal fabric shutter. The actual innovatation is with the closed-loop AE mode where the camera will account for a faulty aperture or more importantly, non-TTL flash by measuring light reflected off the film in real time.
Wrong. It's a mechanical shutter and the only two things the battery is used for is auto film advance and exposure metering.
Trying to tell me something about a camera I've owned for over 3 decades and have had apart almost as many times is very un-wise.
Have you actually tried a modern DSLR?
1) Autofocus can be turned off if you don't like it.
2) There's no (electronic) "screen" involved when you're looking through the viewfinder of a good digital SLR. It works exactly the same way as the viewfinder on film SLR. Exactly.
3) The same is true with respect to "sensors". Every DSLR I've used lets you shoot in full manual mode. No sensors involved.
4) I'm not sure what "video" has to do with it, since you can't take video on a (still) film SLR anyway.
Excepting some lenses themselves have one built-in that you cannot disable.
"There's no (electronic) "screen" involved when you're looking through the viewfinder of a good digital SLR"
Tell that to my Sony SLT which has... wait for it... an electronic viewfinder. Oh, and many people find that focusing manually using an EVF is easier than with an OVF because the EVF allows you to magnify an area to clearly see when the subject snaps into sharp focus (assuming no cruddy interpolation,) which is why DSLRs are coming with an electronic viewfinder.
"Every DSLR I've used lets you shoot in full manual mode. No sensors involved."
Is that including the sensor which is required to take the picture?
"I'm not sure what "video" has to do with it, since you can't take video on a (still) film SLR anyway."
What do you think is inside a Super-8 camera (which has still film modes?) The exact operating mechanisms, down to the split prism (well, some used a half-mirrored optic) that you would find in a typical SLR. Oh, and then there's this thing called rapid continuous shot (battery assisted, of course) where you can shoot up to 30 shots per second with my old camera, which means... wait for it... VIDEO SPEED PHOTOGRAPHY.
There is a lot of discussion of the merits of film versus digital capture which really isn't the point or why someone would necessarily choose to shoot film today. Much like how a better camera doesn't automatically take better photos the same goes with the film vs digital debate. A camera, and film/digital sensor, is a tool that is used accomplish an ends (capturing an image). One tool might be easier to use or have more control or some other quality of preference. Similarly, a given film might subjectively have a preferred color palette or a sensor have more flexibility. I shoot film because it requires me to slow down and think about each shot; I can't fallback on "guess and check" for exposure or composition.
Another thing to note is that much of the film market (both pro and consumer) have stabilized in recent years. Kodak (also Kodak Alaris) and the other manufacturers have adapted to be able to meet the lower demand of a niche market. A great example of this is Ilford.
Anyway, I am just excited to have an excuse to shoot some slides this year!