To your point about "gauge" (v.) vs. "gage" (v.), the end of the Age of Sail (ca. 1860) overlaps the rise of steam machinery by a century more or less. If steam drove the difference in usage that chart displays, then we need to explain why that took a hundred years after the advent of steam power to happen. We also need to explain why "gage" (n.) was left behind to the extent that it was.
Pedant though I am, my querulousness is not entirely without limit, and I have other things to do today, too. I'll concede "archaic" and soften it to "old-fashioned" if you'll acknowledge the plainly obvious fact that "gage" in this usage is a clear typo, just one of many which existed (and may still exist) on the rather longwinded page under discussion, rather than a deliberate stylistic choice on the part of that page's writer, who does not seem overall to have invested a great deal of close thought into his use of language thereon. Fair?
I'm not up for that. I'll settle having read the dictionaries and considered the evidence presented in order to communicating with the world at large on its terms. Using "gage"(verb), I'll be able to communicate with the prescriptivists and the descriptivists. And apparently the Army.
Irregardless, for all intensive porpoises, it's a doggy-dog world. Now excuse me while I kiss this guy.
Unfortunately, merely counting spellings of the word in books as that graph does isn't sufficient evidence. It fails to account for how the word is used over time. It's fully possible "gauge" as a noun experienced a radical uptick following the Age of the Sail as steam machines were introduced. These usages would obscure the frequency of the "gauge"(verb) vs. "gage"(verb).
Nevertheless, the corpus of "gage" merely underscores its acceptability. Even if it's not as popular, it continues to be used to today, as your evidence shows, so it is both correct and not archaic.
I value greatly the perspective you've brought, but it's just not aligned with the evidence and facts. If one were to adopt that worldview, one would have to call every less popular option archaic. But would it make sense to say that red is an archaic color for a car, because it's less popular than white and black? https://www.terrapass.com/images/blogposts/car-color-popular...
Finally, with respect to the descriptive usage of language, I will document these entries directly from "the wild" as used by our colleagues on Hacker News, deploying 'gage' in the Larry Wildman sense:
1. "... I'd love to get feedback on and gage interest." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9410624
2. "now I'm trying to gage how crazy it is to devote..." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7469954
3. "Was hoping to gage the interest of any Hn'ers in long island." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2663638
4. "Show HN: Gage- Validate your ideas with user feedback (gage.io)" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8639928
5. "...if possible, gage how many Heroku Web Dynos I should add." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6214062