Re:Dd is not a disk writing tool (2015)
by asdfaoeu on Sunday January 08, 2017 @09:31PM
(#13353539)
This doesn't seem to be the case for me
Edit: Ok so I misread your comment and you were talking about >&2. Which is weird because it actually has different behaviour in bash vs zsh. Having said I can't think why you would want the bash behaviour, although the bash behaviour does seem more consistent.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
In the particular example I used, the Bourne shell behavior probably has no practical use (but I can write code of no practical use in many languages).
It's not particularly surprising that the zsh behavior is different than bash; zsh redirections are only Bourne shell-like in simple cases.
I dislike zsh's behavior because it isn't what the user typed. It should be simple to look at a command line and see how many pipes it makes; see the processes that will be involved in the pipeline. Zsh's behavior seems to me to be clever and implicit; I'd much rather have dumb and explicit.