There's nothing stopping a climate change scientist from being fiscally conservative or religiously oriented, there's plenty of room in America for pro-gun pro-choice advocates, or other amalgamations of thought...
Similarly, there are plenty of pro-gun rights liberals, Christian pro-choice activists, and anti-globalist pro-spending liberals...
Americans need to focus on policies, not parties.
The problem isn't liberal colleges or disconnected rural districts... it's the simplified "us vs them" mentality, the complete disregard for policy nuance and critical thinking.
Pray tell, to what extent would the median-intelligence US citizen understand the words "nuance" and "critical thinking", let alone possess, to a nontrivial extent, the virtues named by those words?
After all, the "us vs them" mental data-structure suffices for many things that many people enjoy, such as spectator sports. (And in expressing how HN discussions are in a bubble insofar as participants mostly possess undergraduate educations and/or jobs that normally require such; simply put, that's not a microcosm of the entire US population.)
(I'm not saying your suggestion isn't what must happen; I'm saying it isn't in the realm of what can happen.)
Critically-minded citizens should act as Socratic teachers. Our job is to ask the right questions, gently probing until we've disassembled their chains and lead them to the light.
It's a slow path, taken one question at a time.
Unfortunately, the nature of a country of three hundred million people means that you've got to scale, and Socratic dialogue doesn't scale.
Of course, we've had our educational system trashed, so I'm not sure that's an answer, either...
If the problem reduces to our crippled education system, what else can we do besides individual citizen engagement and education?
This is a problem that's been building up over decades. It will take at least as long to fix... if not longer, given our political disadvantage.
I dunno. It's a hard problem. Plato liked philosopher kings. Maybe we try that. (Disclaimer: this is a joke. A joke is here. Do not well-actually me, humorless internet denizen. Thanks in advance.)
That's not a bad thing. We have a solution, we know we can implement it. It's unscalable but still very easy on the individual level.
I have some ideas on this, I'm working on one at the moment in my spare time, but...well. We'll see. ;)
History has shown us the two sides of this coin... broadcasted dogmatic thinking (audience > 100), and empowering critical thinking at a smaller scale (audience ~ 10). The former tends to infect societies that have failed at the latter. We've yet to see anyone achieve broadcasted critical thinking.
The Southeast alone has acres upon acres of rural settlements (okay, fine, towns) with low population-density; it would take a significant expedition to spread "opportunity" to a noticeable portion of that population.
It's not like rural areas are completely red washed... most areas are below a 70/30 split, and the middle third are on the fence. We just need to help the 30% talk with the middle 30%.
The test in academia should be not ideology, but whether your theories withstand scrutiny. Should environmental science departments hire climate change deniers, for ideological diversity? Should biology departments hire creationists? Should political science and history departments hire people who say Saddam Hussein had WMD and Obama is Kenyan?
No, but part of the issue is actually embedded in this question. The description "climate change deniers" has become the accepted way to describe dissenters of certain climate theory.
Name what other scientific theories in which dissenters are labeled as such? Big bang deniers? standard model deniers? The anti-science string theorists? Of course critics of all these theories exist and we consider them still scientists. If valid critics don't exist, then something is very wrong.
The "anti-science", "denier" and from the opposing side "climate change hoax" memes are intended to shutdown discussion resulting in no information exchanging groups of different viewpoints and perpetuating the divergence of their views. Education on such subjects stalls when there can not exist a discussion where opposing sides have respect.
That's not true; many are called "crackpots" and the like, and are excluded and ignored; the difference here is that these non-scientists are funded and backed by ideologues and the fossil fuel industry.
Not all ideas are valid or scientific; in fact, most are not. The standards for being taken seriously, especially by scientists, are clear.
Not a term that is regularly circulated in scientific discussion. More typically these are labels around subjects in which politics has involved itself. When politics becomes involved, the stakes become much higher as money and power are involved and it becomes in ones best interest to silence opposition often by any means because the opposing opinion now is a direct threat to your career, business etc. Whereas beforehand opposing opinion was just that, an opinion with no more power to influence change and not threatening.
We can see this precisely unfold with climate change. Prior to 1997 conservative and liberal views were more closely inline. However, 1997 was the first time a political solution was proposed that favored political world views of liberal vs conservative. All of a sudden now opinion matters and critics became more involved and vocal. I would suspect if the political solution favored conservative world views then the terms 'climate change deniers' would be originating from the right as opposed to the left. The left would have become critical if they felt the solution was an impact to their political world views.
http://www.livescience.com/56396-americans-misinformed-on-cl...
2) Typical conservatives are free market only in their rhetoric. Most are crony capitalist and will intervene in the market as they see fit.
3) A true free market solution could only be based on property rights. True cost can't be calculated from damage done as in this case it is too abstract. But based on property rights companies could be required to be carbon neutral and in that sense what ever cost is required to achieve that would be required of the company.
No, it would be affirmative action if they were given preferential treatment in order to increase their numbers. If instead just existing discrimination against them were removed, that would not be affirmative action.
> Should environmental science departments hire climate change deniers, for ideological diversity?
Strawman - no one is suggesting that.
Historically, many great scientists have been conservative as well as religious. Many people that fall into those groups accept evolution, climate change, and so forth - for example, the Catholic church accepts both of those.
Science isn't a partisan issue. But on college campuses, it looks that way with conservatives a shrinking minority.
I've seen no data, and I've only heard those stories as part of the propaganda campaign to discredit anyone who might oppose the ideologues' movement.
EDIT: For some data, see the parent's other post here:
That's very common, if you talk to conservatives on campus.
Now, this isn't necessarily focused, intentional discrimination. It might just be the usual "it's hard to be a small minority" issue. The majority might be "only" as guilty as it is when it doesn't accomomodate other minorities.
But there is more - just look at what people say about conservatives in this very thread. They are a hated minority. Some of their peers are even open enough as to admit their bias in surveys,
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/08/08/survey-finds-...
> That's very common, if you talk to conservatives on campus.
This is the kind of situation where I feel the need is great for real data and not anecdotes. There are just too many tropes and rumors. And even if the data bears it out, it could very well be that the people who are "afraid" are responding to false information, the same as people are afraid of terrorism.
> just look at what people say about conservatives in this very thread. They are a hated minority.
I haven't noticed anyone expressing hate in this thread. Also, we need to avoid conflating the concept "conservative" with the ideological movement that has appropriated it.
Finally, the idea of being a 'persecuted majority' is a staple of many propaganda campaigns. The Germans were told they were persecuted by the Jewish people, for example. People in the current ideological movement (we need a name for it besides "conservative") say the "MSM" persecutes them, though Fox News dominates cable news, the Wall Street Journal is the leading newspaper in the business world and one of the leaders otherwise, News Corp is very powerful in UK media, and talk radio (Rush Limbaugh, etc.) is almost all conservative - they aren't persecuted, they are the people in power. Similarly, the GOP is the dominant political party in the U.S.; the "conservatives" are the persecutors, if anything.
Any what do you do, hypothetically speaking, if this requirement keeps out a large proportion of a specific ideological group, or if the process of science changes the views of individuals of that group, to the point where they leave it? And, what if, said ideological group is unwilling to accept that?
The Middle Ages were defined, in a sense, by the priority of ideology over rationality. The enlightenment was a rejection of ideology in favor of factual accuracy about the world. The ideology may say the Sun revolves around the Earth, but the facts say otherwise. The ideology may say that that climate change isn't happening, but the facts say otherwise.
Tbh, I think that is ultimately what we are dealing with - a very popular culture and ideology that eschews reason in favour of conformity.