Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by peteretep on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:05AM
(#13326471)
Random thought: the more deep learning is used in training, the less humans will be able to retroactively explain decisions; this surely has liability implications
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by bobcostas55 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @07:35AM
(#13326620)
Perhaps NNs need functionality to come up with fake rationalizations for their decisions just like the human brain does.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by worldsayshi on Thursday January 05, 2017 @09:35AM
(#13327356)
I'm thinking that this idea about "fake rationalization" is a bit backwards. We say that many actions happen before we are aware of it or have a rationalization for them but becoming aware of why we did something after the fact doesn't mean that "you" weren't part of the decision. Aren't your reflexes a part of "you"?
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by bobcostas55 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @09:48AM
(#13327465)
Of course, but nobody is going to say "my reflexes did it". We come up with stories, lines of argumentation, etc. Even though these are "ex post" we often manage to convince ourselves...
In Homer's time the Greeks viewed the unconscious as an external (divine) force, the most famous example being Telemachus's sneeze. In a weird way this feels more intellectually honest than the thing we do.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by peteretep on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:17PM
(#13333891)
> we often manage to convince ourselves
In this case, presumably the trick is to convince a jury.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by javiramos on Thursday January 05, 2017 @09:38AM
(#13327372)
NuTonomy has an autonomous driving technology based on formal logic [1]. It seems like formal logic is a better approach for retroactively explaining software decisions.
[1] http://spectrum.ieee.org/transportation/self-driving/after-m...
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by Fricken on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:08AM
(#13328225)
Google too uses plenty of formal logic in their autonomous OS, it's a frankenstein of various machine learning techniques. Narrow pattern recognition alone, while powerful, is unlikely to ever be suitable for things like negotiating busy four way stops.
There is the presumption that all you gotta do is gather enough training data and shazam!, you got a self driving car, but that's bollocks. There is a tremendous amount of elbow grease that foes into developing and validating an AV to six sigma reliability. Six sigma might not even be good enough for something as safety-critical as a driverless car.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by rthille on Thursday January 05, 2017 @03:37PM
(#13331133)
It doesn't need six-sigma, just to be significantly better than humans, and for the manufacturer to take on the liability.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by Fricken on Thursday January 05, 2017 @04:06PM
(#13331398)
In strictly rational terms It has to be better than 1 fatality for every 100,000,000 miles driven, but public opinion isn't exactly rational so it probably needs to be even better than that.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by xorxornop on Friday January 06, 2017 @01:26AM
(#13334385)
It'll be that way at first, yeah, but once it becomes obvious how much better the AI drivers are, it will start to become irresponsible to not use it
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by wavefunction on Thursday January 05, 2017 @08:01AM
(#13326757)
I don't see how this is true. With a machine system you would at least have the ability to log the mathematical operations and results, which would be complex, sure.
But more complex than figuring out if another person is lying about a very nuanced and opaque decision they made?
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by feel_the_need on Thursday January 05, 2017 @08:29AM
(#13326926)
The scope of your question is too large. Do not compare the complexity of AI to the human brain. Instead compare AI to traditional robotics. In expert systems rules are laid out and logic chains can be followed. AI is a black box of a billion random weighted nodes. The system does not care about 'why' when reducing loss.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by catwell on Thursday January 05, 2017 @09:32AM
(#13327330)
Yes. This is why https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13111516 was on the front page last month.
Re:Nvidia and Audi aim to bring a self-driving AI car to mar...
by whistlerbrk on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:15AM
(#13327691)
I feel like this is very actively being addressed, for example by visualization of intermediate features.