It's incredible how much dhh got right from the start, and I believe the opinionated nature taught a generation of developers how to structure a project. It's unfortunate that ruby stagnated.
I also agree with you regarding Ruby/Rails. Ruby and Rails are both elegant technologies, and have had a significant influence on how we write web applications today. You cannot take those contributions away, regardless of how many "better" languages come out. I think both Ruby and Elixir have their strengths and weaknesses, but that doesn't mean either is bad. Saying so would be like trashing a screwdriver because it isn't very good at driving nails.
I think zealotism has a fine line, but I don't think it's all bad. It's almost like protestors that believe in something strongly. Sometimes they cross the line, but them protesting gains visibility which results in change.
But I do like the language and the environment.
I remember laughing to myself thinking how much more productive I would be than my classmates.
Boy was THAT a rude awakening.
An example: A large part of the Erlang standard library is not translated in Elixir. Instead, you call Erlang methods with a seamless interop. José & co. understand that there's no need to reinvent the wheel and no benefit in another abstraction. I like that.
My least favorite part about Elixir is that it has become a "trendy" language among the web crowd. While the community is overall great, there's always a loud minority of "beginner experts" both claiming it's the best thing ever and deriding those for using other tools. I've seen a lot of random, unwarranted Rails bashing and Elixir shilling (never from a team member or community leader though!).