News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by ghaff on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @05:38PM (#13322780)
This is so annoying to me. I love Maxfield Parrish's work, as well as other American illustrators, and this would be a great addition to any city. Perhaps I'm biased but I just have a lot of trouble understanding the objections that have derailed a couple of the past proposals.
Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by bobsky on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @05:58PM (#13322917)
From the outside it looks like a superb deal, but issues are in the details. Most notably, the Museum is being proposed on PUBLIC land and thus the conflict in meeting the requirements.

As quoted in the article from Presidio Trust board member:

“If it’s your land, you can do pretty much what you want,” Bechtle says. “But with public land, there is just a higher level of scrutiny.”

The trust developed design guidelines for the site. The building could be no higher than 45 feet; as for looks, the trust didn’t want a building that replicated an old-fashioned architectural style...

...in short Lucas proposal didn't meet the guidelines and he didn't want to compromise.

Personally, I think the museum is a fantastic deal and any city would be blessed with the gift -- still hoping SF & Lucas find a mutual agreement (one of which not be exclusive to Lucas items/curation).

Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:11PM (#13323436)
I don't have a whole lot of respect for guidelines like the building being no higher than 45 feet - well I don't mind it as a guideline but as a hard limit it's a kind of bullshit constraint. You couldn't accuse his proposal of looking like old-fashioned architecture so I presume they're fighting over the former issue.

But honestly. I think constraints like that are just a bargaining chip in San Francisco's social power game, where Lucas has the money and the political support but not the elite social pedigree of San Francisco's philanthropic set (who in turn suffer an inferiority complex relative to their competitors on the east coast): http://www.greenwichtime.com/bayarea/place/article/Major-pla...

Let's not forget that right now the site is occupied by a sportswear outlet and 20 years ago was little better than a parking lot. Tech billionaires show more interest in space, hospitals, and vehicles (perhaps because those fields offer quantifiable metrics of success) so I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for someone to come along with a check & collection for a more obviously highbrow museum in a city that's already amply supplied with such options.

Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by ghaff on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:10PM (#13323011)
That's fair enough. On the other hand, I never really understood the objections in Chicago.

Yes, Lucas wants to create a monument. Building it in the middle of nowhere where no one will visit doesn't serve that purpose, but then it doesn't really serve the public interest either. I do hope that some reasonable accommodation can be arrived at in a location that will give many people access to the art.

Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by massysett on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:48PM (#13323284)
If it's worth visiting, people will go even if it is in the middle of nowhere. Lots of places in the middle of nowhere off highways get visitors--think of outlet malls and theme parks. If it's filled with Star Wars stuff, those fans will trek out to see it. Lucas's issue is that he wants to build a monument to himself in a prominent place. This isn't about making his art available. It's about him building an edifice to glorify himself.

Some folks have to do great things to get monuments built (Lincoln). Others donate money and let others have a say in what edifice gets built (Smithson, Carnegie, Mellon). Still others build their own edifices but buy the land on the open market (Trump, the Sears Tower). Lucas wants to build his own edifice on prominent public land, all while retaining complete control for himself. That's his problem.

Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by logfromblammo on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @05:58PM (#13322924)
I would personally veto any museum that had a design requirement of "provide enough space to exhibit anything and everything that George Lucas wants to show off."

If he wants the museum to happen, he'd better withdraw his big, fat thumb from the pie a little, and let someone else determine just how much of his personal art collection qualifies as "cultural treasure".

You have to figure that there's at least one person in every major American city who has seen the Star Wars Christmas Special, in addition to all the people who "have a baaaaad feeling about this," after seeing the movies he has directed personally, and the "enhancements" made to certain works for their DVD release.

That's why all the cities want to know what exactly he's going to put into the museum, and replying "that's proprietary information" just raises a huge, Hutt-sized warning flag over the whole project.

Besides that, I just visited the Art Institute of Chicago a few days ago, which sort of anchored my expectations for "art museum". No city wants to green light a project expecting "art museum" and end up four years later with "that useless, ugly building full of m-f-ing Gungan codpieces and Ewok hats."

Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by h4nkoslo on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:24PM (#13323117)
The history has been that odd preferences for the content & operation of museums and foundations very rarely outlive the founder, so you're looking at at most ~20 years of purely interior weirdness.
Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by ghaff on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:30PM (#13323163)
It mostly has at the Gardner in Boston but even that's been shaken up a bit recently.
Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by pmyteh on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:08PM (#13323416)
There are some glorious counterexamples, though: the Sir John Soane museum in London is both magnificent and magnificently weird...
Re:George Lucas Can’t Give a $1.5B Museum Away by ghaff on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:08PM (#13324112)
I'm going to have some time in London at the end of January. I haven't been there and may need to check it out.