I just wanted to make my point that it doesn't need to have progressing levels for the basic thrill. I really like clever human-designed levels though :) Much more surprising and less optimization, more quick grasping and adaption required.
There's a very big and important difference between "random" and "procedurally generated". Most great roguelikes (or roguelike-likes?) have strong procedural elements in their level generation, but certainly randomness is an important input.
I'll add brogue since I am a roguelike traditionalist. :)
Rogue-like games plague the Steam store [1], though there will always be games like Legacy that rise to the top of their category. You could say Candy Crush is an objectively successful game too, but I see it as a micro transaction laden piece of trash.
[1] http://store.steampowered.com/search/?term=rogue&tags=1716
The claims you made beyond that are invalid
Surely... Though, you can't point to community and critical acclaim like you could with Rogue Legacy, which is why they were linked and why the other poster was suggesting you back your statements with evidence. It's less so for people to like you or your comments and more so for people to gauge the veracity of your statements...
i see this sentiment and similar echoed a lot and the issue i take with it is that there are degrees to everything. Just like there are good and bad hand designed games, there is the same spectrum of procedural games
there are many games that do this extremely well but they are mostly not very well known indie efforts. Off the top of my head:
* Dungeon of the Endless
* Invisible Inc
* Downwell
* Rogue Legacy
* Spelunky
* Teleglitch