To operate an index fund, for instance, you have to buy and sell millions of shares everyday. A 1% tax would make impossible to operate an index fund cheaply.
Cuban's proposal is not serious. Yeah, I know he's rich and all, but he doesn't understand how the stock market works.
Back to basics. I kind of like the idea.
A sales tax would vastly increase costs for everyone involved. Your parents pension fund would generate lesser returns because it costs them more to enter and exit positions. Your "back to basics" quip is bullshit. What does "going back to basics" even mean? People trade because they think they can make a profit or hedge their risk. That's all there is to it, nothing "more basic".
Huh?
I buy stock to make money. I make money when I buy at a lower price than I sell said stock. Note that price plays a role in both transactions.
Serious question - who buys stock for reasons other than price expectations?
This would have to be accompanied by new regulations on derivatives and dark pools, but on the surface it doesn't seem like a bad idea.
Currently, all major banks have:
1) Shadow markets setup (dark pools) to allow big investors to take positions without anyone knowing.
2) Servers sitting beside the exchange that get to see all trades before the public does.
Neither of these things should be legal.
I don't know if I believe that high-frequency traders provide a necessary liquidity. I can see both sides on that, but I think we will never know until we impose a tax like Cuban is suggesting. If we don't like the results, we can always repeal the tax.