News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by ianferrel on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:12PM (#1331372)
A per-share tax makes no sense, because a share is an arbitrary measurement. This would effectively be a regressive tax on small-time investors.

As Cuban himself mentions, it would put pressure on companies to do reverse splits. But I believe he underestimates how much pressure. You'd see stratification, with most companies issuing the A-class big investor shares with prices in the $10s of thousands ($100s?) and B-class cheap shares.

Middle class people buying small amounts of cheap shares in retirement plans would pay the bulk of this tax.

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by tansey on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:42PM (#1331407)
I was thinking the same thing. Wouldn't a percentage tax make more sense? If you just require a 1% tax on all transactions, it would basically be equivalent to what Cuban was saying (he mentioned a $0.05 tax for shares under $5), and it wouldn't pressure companies to do reverse splits. Even people who trade frequently (e.g. 1-2 times a day) wouldn't likely see much cost associated with this.

This would have to be accompanied by new regulations on derivatives and dark pools, but on the surface it doesn't seem like a bad idea.

Currently, all major banks have:

1) Shadow markets setup (dark pools) to allow big investors to take positions without anyone knowing.

2) Servers sitting beside the exchange that get to see all trades before the public does.

Neither of these things should be legal.

I don't know if I believe that high-frequency traders provide a necessary liquidity. I can see both sides on that, but I think we will never know until we impose a tax like Cuban is suggesting. If we don't like the results, we can always repeal the tax.

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by nandemo on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:53PM (#1331433)
A 1% tax would still be huge. Traders measure trading cost in basis points (100ths of 1%). Such a tax would affect not only high-frequency traders, but also all market makers and even long-term investors like pension funds and mutual funds.

To operate an index fund, for instance, you have to buy and sell millions of shares everyday. A 1% tax would make impossible to operate an index fund cheaply.

Cuban's proposal is not serious. Yeah, I know he's rich and all, but he doesn't understand how the stock market works.

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by sgk284 on Sunday May 09, 2010 @12:05AM (#1331511)
I think he understands it just fine. Implement a tax that requires people to actually buy stock for reasons other than its price. Make it too expensive to trade millions of shares every second to make small fractions of a return. Make people buy shares because they want to see the company succeed, not to make a quick buck.

Back to basics. I kind of like the idea.

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by vecter on Sunday May 09, 2010 @05:11AM (#1331766)
I don't think you understand that people who make markets (add liquidity) decrease YOUR investment costs. These market makers can only trade millions of shares per second (a vast overstatement) IF there is actual demand for that. Suppose there is such demand. Then, the market makers are providing a valuable service by supplying liquidity for people who want to buy or sell.

A sales tax would vastly increase costs for everyone involved. Your parents pension fund would generate lesser returns because it costs them more to enter and exit positions. Your "back to basics" quip is bullshit. What does "going back to basics" even mean? People trade because they think they can make a profit or hedge their risk. That's all there is to it, nothing "more basic".

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by anamax on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:51AM (#1331614)
> Implement a tax that requires people to actually buy stock for reasons other than its price.

Huh?

I buy stock to make money. I make money when I buy at a lower price than I sell said stock. Note that price plays a role in both transactions.

Serious question - who buys stock for reasons other than price expectations?

Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 09, 2010 @08:08AM (#1331885)
Some people buy (a small number of) stocks for dividends. But that's very rare, since dividends are taxed twice while capital gains are taxed only once.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by sitmaster on Sunday May 09, 2010 @01:19AM (#1331583)
More like back to the stone age. Look at the Indian stock market: they have transaction taxes on the order of .01-0.1% and the bid-ask spreads are huge. A tax like this would make it even more difficult for average people to get a fair price.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by c1sc0 on Sunday May 09, 2010 @06:53AM (#1331826)
yep, 1% would be insane, I started trading actively for the first time on friday & I would certainly not be in the game with my money with a 1% trade punishment
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by kqr2 on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:34PM (#1331390)
You could limit this tax to short term trades so it wouldn't penalize long term buy and hold investors.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by jsyedidia on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:42PM (#1331410)
Yes, the simplest solution is a 0.1 % tax on short-term trades. It's actually pretty strange that practically everything else one buys is taxed by the government but not shares. No surprise that we get all this useless and dangerous high frequency trading, and an obscenely large financial sector.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 08, 2010 @11:03PM (#1331441)
Capital gains on shares are taxed. Short term capital gains are taxed at a higher rate.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by tansey on Saturday May 08, 2010 @10:43PM (#1331412)
Futures contracts are considered long-term capital gains, even if held for short periods of time.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by rdtsc on Sunday May 09, 2010 @02:45AM (#1331656)
Why not do it per transaction then per value of transaction. Individual transactions are around $5-$8 for non-day traders. So there is already a flat fee to buy or sell. It is very inefficient to issue a lot of small buy/sell orders. So this would discourage the high frequency of trading. Then there is an additional price based fee. The higher the value the higher the fee. The size of the individual share would make no difference then.
Re:Mark Cuban: place a 25 cent-per-share transaction fee on ... by mark_l_watson on Sunday May 09, 2010 @10:58AM (#1332096)
I totally agree with you. It would be better to charge a flat rate, perhaps 0.5%

Cuban's basic idea is good though. That said, the chances of Congress passing legislation that would limit Wall Street profits is very low. And, neither a democrat or republican president would sign such a bill if by some small chance Congress passed it.