The business that will pick up the slack in this example is one overseas. These employees would lose their job and would be unemployed, not increasing demand with higher wages.
Unless you are hoping trump enacts some seriously strict trade tariffs, it's pretty stupid to believe that every business hit with this raise will survive with the same number of employees due to increased demand.
Add to it we're running out of busywork to have people doing, costs of automation are plummeting, jobs that were initially thought by the majority of people to be safe from the robots are turning out to be not-so-safe, and the elite continue to live under the delusion that they can continue stockpiling wealth while the rest of us scrape by.
There are a lot more poor people than rich people, and your money isn't going to help much when they're breaking down your door with torches and pitchforks.
My point is that this business is a bad business if it can only exist because the state subsidizes its employees with social programs. Eventually demand will pickup because of the wealth transferred to the lower economic class.
Don't discuss downvoting in a response to someone. It doesn't make for good discussions. Especially since you're likely not replying to the person who downvoted.
>My point is that this business is a bad business if it can only exist because the state subsidizes its employees with social programs.
Then why couldn't you articulate that in the first comment? It was just a tirade against the wealthy elite mixed in with unsubstantiated claims of increased demand that fail to take into account that the wage increase isn't global.
I don't believe this is the case. However, you can't downvote a response to your own comment.
Edit to add: To confirm, I still have a downvote arrow available to me on your comment.
I think that the idea that paying people more, who spend more of their income proportionally, increases demand isn't really unsubstantiated. Maybe I didn't substantiate it, but only because I thought it was well known. Apologies for that.
The mistake you are making here is in thinking that the majority of people are employed by wealthy people. Tirades like yours make people believe this is just forcing billionaires to open up their wallets, but 99% of businesses are small businesses and they account for something like 49% of employment.
https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/FAQ_Sept_2012.pdf
So minimum wage increases tend to be more of an attack directly on the middle/lower class small business owners who are operating on thin margins.
>Maybe I didn't substantiate it, but only because I thought it was well known.
Don't pretend like you misunderstood the problem and use a faulty assumption to appeal to incredulity (still without providing evidence nonetheless!). The faulty assumption you built this demand argument on was that all of these businesses will easily absorb the wage increase and there will be no jobs lost. There will be no increase in demand and there may be a loss in demand if a huge chunk of small businesses layoff parts of their workforce or relocate.
I wonder if the majority of small businesses are able to employ all those people because they force tax payers to subsidize their low wage payments. I guess the question then is whether it is best to have the lower classes struggling to survive on little wages while accruing more and more wealth to the top. Does this arrangement produce enough of a benefit to all involved to obviate the need to redistribute that accumulated wealth.
I think that the accumulated wealth of the 1% needs to be redistributed. I think it's not only better for society, but its also more moral...and I get that I'm using slippery language unlike the "hard science" of economics. (I detest economics because it poses as a science while mainly serving to provide intellectual cover to the purveyors of the status quo.)
So, yeah, I was being a dick. You caught me.
What would work would be a nice infusion of inflation. You can spend $X today on Y of labor or Z of capex, or hoard it until next year when the same $X will only buy (0.95)Y of labor or (0.95)Y of capex "stuff", your choice how much "stuff" you want to get for your $X
Inflation is another debate. Traditionally wages rise later rather than sooner in that environment.
And no, other businesses won't replace them in CA, because their production costs are higher the moment they start the production. It's basic economics.
And then there are robots.
Businesses like this can only operate because taxes are used to subsidize their employee's lack of a living wage.
If you aren't proposing that businesses give away free money, are you instead saying that the government should reduce what it gives away in social welfare for low-wage workers? That could make low wage jobs unworkable if workers can't afford to actually commute to work or live nearby. That would in turn force wages up.
I think that I, and people like me, should pay more --proportionally -- to lower levels of inequality before it rips the republic apart. The wealthy actually have the best of all worlds currently. Lower taxes and high government expenditures mean that the government actually has to borrow the money from them to subsidize those low wages. Instead of just taxing them, the government now owes interest.
I think that the wealthy have begun to believe their own bullshit and it's dangerous. Democracy should be used to fix the situation before it becomes worse.
What does "out performing" mean in this regard? Tax revenue, GDP, and employment could all be very high in a state where the majority of people are living worse off than people in other states because of a massive cost of living.
Maybe you could just provide some references to these examples?
There are considerable expenses on top of just salaries when you employ people; most countries have some sort of an "employee tax" levied on employers plus other requirements.
You can say well Europe but the minimum wage (and all other wages) in Europe is lower than California and on average than the US.
And yet as of today in the United States an employer of 50 or more has to either separate business operations into two distinct units or buy employer-linked insurance.
I am not sure how it was a different question. The government mandates they become involved.
EDIT: Jesus. I apologize for making an economic sounding argument for this. I've taken it out. How's this...the wealthy elites need to pay people more for the sake of the stability of the social fabric. Find some economic rational for that if you like. (That's what economists really do anyway...Provide the theoretical underpinnings for the operation of their class.) They need to understand that having slightly smaller profit margins will be good for them as well, in the long run, due to a more stable republic. I understand that, as libertarians, you guys don't think that government can play a part in that. I do. We have a fundamental disagreement about that.
Propitiation follows: I know that all of you guys are very economically literate libertarians. I should never have fronted like I was anywhere in your league. I could tell you were not only attractive but powerful and noble as soon as you came in the room. Your ability to recite the economics that you picked up at Uni is not only impressive but frightening. Surely, your might and prowess will be known through the ages.