News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Sunday January 01, 2017 @03:04PM (#13297045)
> I had used peace to beat the thugs around the head.

Oh no, you did not. You used the full power and latent savagery of a crowd. It might have turned out very differently (but made a better story to tell much later on).

And the girlfriend is not a peace seeker. She did not help defuse the situation at all.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by swift on Sunday January 01, 2017 @03:43PM (#13297228)
How would you have handled this situation? I think the author handled it extremely well and I'm proud of him for doing so.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Sunday January 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#13297482)
I would have left the party and then see if my friend/girlfriend was okay and if she needed support (professional or not).

I would certainly not try to get strangers into a bigger brawl.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by tehwalrus on Sunday January 01, 2017 @05:05PM (#13297649)
But what he did was not get them into a brawl. He simply challenged them publicly. This is the very purpose of free speech!

I also object to the characterisation of the crowd as a mob. Democracy and mob rule are the same words (etymologically), we simply pick which one we use based on whether we like the application. This was unquestionably mob rule for ethical purposes, aka democracy. I don't think the tyranny of the majority can be applied to the defense of attendees asked to leave a party for assaulting a guest.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:57AM (#13300629)
> But what he did was not get them into a brawl. He simply challenged them publicly. This is the very purpose of free speech!

That's precisely what he did. Challenging people publicly is a very aggressive move. He escalated the situation by using more intimidation and if the thugs had retaliated it would have been a very different story.

He got lucky, that's all. People pulling that kind of stunt under influence generally end up beaten down in a corner.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by LordWinstanley on Sunday January 01, 2017 @06:07PM (#13297944)
>>I also object to the characterisation of the crowd as a mob

What about the characterisation of the other group as "violent thugs"?

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by danharaj on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:21PM (#13298225)
They sexually harassed someone? That's violence.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by LordWinstanley on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:22AM (#13300520)
Allegedly [!] one of them did. So the rest are 'guilty by association'?
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by tehwalrus on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:02AM (#13300652)
Actually under the law of England and Wales they would be.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_purpose

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by literallycancer on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:33PM (#13298273)
His girlfriend claimed it was sexual assault, doesn't mean it was.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by woofyman on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:32PM (#13298265)
Sadly, in the United States, this is how you get yourself or someone else shot.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by SG- on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:19PM (#13298216)
Get bar staff/security.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by lolc on Sunday January 01, 2017 @03:17PM (#13297111)
In what other more peaceful ways could she have defused the situation?
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Sunday January 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#13297505)
By leaving the party and/or leaving things at that (and getting support from security/police/etc if things escalate).

She shouldn't get back to her friend/boyfriend asking him to `fix` things caveman style. That's a very bad line of thinking and will usually get anyone close to her into troubles. It's like dating a walking grenade. Try not to.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by danharaj on Sunday January 01, 2017 @05:11PM (#13297677)
Your ethics make public spaces hostile to vulnerable people.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:01AM (#13300644)
No, the thugs in the aforementioned story do that.

The incident was already over. The girlfriend was asking for revenge (not justice) and the guy described in the article how he had to react « as a man ». That's escalation.

Now if you are caught in the middle of such situations there a number of methods you can try to defuse the situation: http://lifehacker.com/ive-worked-bar-security-heres-how-to-t... (I know it's from lifehacker but the article has really good tips. Ignore the pictures).

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by literallycancer on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:35PM (#13298278)
Your ethics make public spaces hostile to everyone. What if she mistook the guy for someone else? Then what, crowd beats a random guy to death?
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by extra88 on Sunday January 01, 2017 @05:44PM (#13297841)
He didn't do anything that should couldn't have done herself. Not everyone would think to try what he did but if she had done it, it would have been more likely to have turned out okay.
Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by lolc on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:12PM (#13298183)
Yes, that would have been even better. It would be nice if every person had the resolve to react like this.

"She didn't do anything to defuse the situation" implies that she could have handled the situation better. As per the story she was shocked, intimidated, and looking for somebody to help her. It's not her duty to "defuse the situation". She was not the one escalating it in the first place.

Re:The day Violent Thugs were driven out by Hippies with glo... by johnchristopher on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:14AM (#13300710)
No, no. I don't think or know if she could have reacted differently when the aggression happened. That's another part of the story.

The 'not defusing the situation' is about how she came back to someone asking to 'fix it'. That's when escalation happened. That someone being under the influence of drugs at that moment made another bad move by 'trying something' which escalated the situation one more step.

Don't play stupid in that kind of situation: a knife can be pulled out really fast and the thugs could have left the place the same way but with one seriously wounded person. And for what ? For seeking revenge by shaming of fighting the guys (that was a possibility on the mind of the author, he states getting beaten happened once and he turned out okay, whatever) for damage already done.