Until you show up uninsured at the same ER for the same visit and end up with a $10,000 bill because you don't have insurance.
Whether it hits your deductible or not, insurance negotiates rates that are easily 75% cheaper than what you'd pay without it.
That's the problem, though. If I can't afford it, then it doesn't matter whether they charge me $1,700 I don't have, or $1,700,000 I don't have. Either way, I'm not going to pay it, and it's going to end up going to collections and dinging my credit.
Let's say the worst possible case happens and I get cancer. They don't treat you for that in the ER, other than the bare minimum to keep you alive. But to get those ungodly expensive $3,000 a dose drugs would require too much out of pocket. I wouldn't be able to get them with or without insurance.
Some hospitals allow you to fill out extensive paperwork to apply to have greater bill reductions, and you need to send in several years of tax returns, bank statements, a personal financial statement, an explanation of your situation and why you can't pay in full, etc. It's a grueling, paperwork intensive, and invasive process.
This is one of those "preliterate peoples do not develop epidemic myopia" sort of things, perhaps.
Here's the actual ER bill as proof of what they charged me:
The amount you pay every pay period, to your insurance plan and to your health savings account (if applicable), really ought to be on your pay stub. If you're paid electronically your company probably makes that available to you somehow via pdf.
You go there in the worst pain of your life (kidney stones are truly terrifying), and you think they're there to help you. Not use you to pay for their fancy, unnecessary, dangerous toys.
Although I am in (mostly) good physical shape, I found it beyond creepy and refused to do it. But I worry about them increasing the discount in the future. It'll be harder to say no when it's $1000, or $2000. And let's be real: it's not a discount, it's a penalty for when you don't do what you're told.
And given how my insurance doesn't even cover a 30-minute ER visit without sending me a bill in the mail for $1700, it's hardly even worth having insurance at all. At least at my age.