Some move beyond the certainty of belief and get trapped in nihilism.
Those that move through nihilism gain a perspective on meaning itself, realizing that meaning is relative and can be objectified. All of meaning and reality become a playful flux of creation. Buddhists are the most studied in this regard.
A quick and easy read on different levels of human development can be found here:
http://newpossibilitiesassociates.com/uploads/9_levels_of_in...
For something with far more substance, I suggest metaprogramming by John Lilly [2]. At least he had the conviction to spend more than half of his life experimenting (radically) on himself.
[1] http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-f...
[2] https://www.amazon.com/Programming-Metaprogramming-Human-Bio...
Are you suggesting the two individuals you mentioned are the originators of that line of thought? Why is it important to you that these two individuals are name dropped?
Besides, mentioning the originators of certain ideas and models and guiding people to their work is surely adding a lot of substance to the discussion.
Not defending the text you're talking about, but if you feel like it's "deeply flawed" could you please point out some concrete examples?
- Kohlberg's stages of moral development: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Kohlberg%27s_stages_o...
- Some Thoughts on Kohlberg's "Stage 7" [pdf]: http://glasnost.itcarlow.ie/~garveya/Stage_7.pdf
My dad had an old saying:
"There's shit you can do shit about, and there's shit you can't do shit about".
Definitely can't do anything about whether we are in VR right now, or whether or not we actually exist.
It sounds trite, but forcing yourself into situations where you absolutely must deal with the immediacy of "now" is a good solution to existential angst.
I don't think it particularly bad advice myself.
Alternatively - the spatial scales are very different and an entire galaxy or ours is not observable by their 'naked' eyes.
Honestly, who wants to talk to some snot-nosed humans? They probably don't bother checking until the universe becomes one giant superorganism anyways. And even then maybe they just make their observations and ignore it as it tries to wave them down.
Except there it's the higher level contacting humans.
"You" seem to think that beliefs exist on a conscious self-aware layer of thought, thus "you" should be aware of them but if "you" have done any serious psychonautics or experienced traumatic events in childhood, "you" will realize that is not the case. It takes a lot more than simple affirmation to rid "yourself" of such demons. Reading books about ceremonial magick and the techniques that had to be invented over the years to deal with such problems can be very enlightening, if not fascinating.
So, when the mind experiences cognitive dissonance, the effects propagate to the upper layers and "you" may become aware of them. I guess my point (through experience) is that as long as there is a "you" there to begin with, cognitive dissonance and dissociation will be problems that "you" will have to deal with :-)
As to your original question, it has long been my view that "most people" are not self-aware enough for such matters to even register. Even those who do have the curiosity and inclination, don't really like spending a lot of time in that UNCOMFORTABLE space, and quickly reach for the nearest distraction or escape (living in a make-believe dream world) to help them cope with daily life. When the luster starts to fade, a new dream bubble (new goals and aspirations) is quickly conjured and entered.
I highly recommend Celia Green's "The Human Evasion" [1] to you, something tells me you will enjoy it very much.
It is fascinating to contemplate that dissociation may be the next stage in human evolution (leading up to ego-death and an emergent hive mind?) and that it may happen on a mass-scale, not through mysticism or magick or psychonautics but technology that has become so ubiquitous nobody can really escape from.
Of course it's kookery (which I'm forced to say to avoid mockery), but it's quite relevant.
See also the nam-shub of Enki from Snow Crash.
If you can't even convince yourself that you will experience the future then there is no reason to do anything. Suppose every moment you are transferred into the head of a different person. Or let's say that time runs backwards. What possible motivation do you have to do anything? Why take your hand away from a hot stove if you have no evidence that you will experience the after effects?
Limiting perception should not limit the objective reality, but I hypothesize it does limit the ability of the perceiver to easily manifest their own non-objective reality here in this "real world". Strangely enough, I just picked up Galapagos by Vonnegut yesterday and he's presenting a similar concept and I'm curious to see where he goes with it. I've been remiss in reading more of him.
When you are going in or exiting a VR or gaming existence, it feels just like shifting existing "goals" into existing "get it done slots". In Astronomer, for example, the "goal" is gathering Oxygen to breath/live and the "get it done" part is gathering building materials to construct devices which help you learn how to do more things. It feels like a life because I've done similar things in the real world to survive. I get sad when my little guy/gal dies, so who's to say they aren't "real"? I hope someone is sad and happy for my existence as well!
I wonder if the the dissociation may result from the resistance to comprehending an eventual truth which cannot be "unheard"? I'm OK with it because I think about it all the tim, but I'm sure it's frightening to just have it spontaneously happen to you without realizing what it is that is occurring.
Does anyone else have that? Late at night. After video games? I am 33.
I've come to piece with this now though, by managing to really accept that I actually don't care either.
As for "how do you know" - from memories. Same way you know everything else except last few hours since you last woke up.
Memory of what in deep sleep? Do people who come out of coma know how long they have been under for? In deep sleep, only amness remains.
The difference is between "I think, therefore I am" and "I am, therefore I am"
I say that a bit jokingly, but I imagine its a bit of the same feeling.
I came to understand that years ago. It was agonizing at first, but I've come to terms with it. I learned that if I align myself with things that are probably true, I can be happy. Certainty is simply not required anymore.
It seems to me that people who don't understand this principle (that almost nothing is certain) would be more prone to dissociative effects. As for myself, I find it hard to imagine VR would have any effect on my state of mind since I'm not convinced reality isn't VR anyway. :-)