Huh? The Intel chips just aren't powerful enough to run modern 3D games. The discrete GPUs in iMacs and MBPs are. Why the heck is it insane to write "Works on macOS if you have a gaming GPU" or by extension, insane to write "Works on Windows if you have a gaming GPU"?
What you want from companies is to stop making great 3D games to cater to the lowest common denominator of a crappy Intel GPU which Apple refuses to care about or upgrade. Rendering the world of Witcher 3 just isn't possible on an Intel HD5000 on older Macs and requesting that games like this aren't made at all so people can stay ignorant is wrong.
This is confusing to the majority of consumers. I did support for ~3 ish years across multiple jobs for people who needed computer help. I can count the amount of people I talked to who understand what you just typed up on two hands over those years.
It's simply not consumer friendly. Us folks who browse HN? Yeah, we obviously understand. But the majority of folks actually buying the games? Nope.
> What you want from companies is to stop making great 3D games to cater to the lowest common denominator of a crappy Intel GPU which Apple refuses to care about or upgrade. Rendering the world of Witcher 3 just isn't possible on an Intel HD5000 on older Macs
I'm not sure I follow. I went to school for game dev and, granted, I chose a different path but I know many game developers and they have multiple paths to degrading the experience onto some pretty terrible chipsets. Many dev studios do this while still pushing the limits on higher end machines. I always thought FarCry was great at this, I never had an issue running it on crappy Intel GPUs but it looked like crap at the same time.
> requesting that games like this aren't made at all so people can stay ignorant is wrong
It's simply not intuitive. Yes if you own a PC and buy something for it you should know about it. But when you work in support for any amount of time you realize this is far, far from reality. You're not going to be able to educate everyone and surely, into today's world of download from an app store and tap, it's only going to be more common to expect everything to "just work".
I would argue that consumes shouldn't need to care about their specs if you want to provide any type of decent user experience. Tablets and modern hardware is actually getting pretty close to making this a reality. There are honestly not a lot of games out there that can't run on the terrible Intel GPUs.
(I don't disagree with your larger point that Steam should take a lot more responsibility to put up roadblocks to purchasing games that won't run on the system the Steam client is running on.)
It's also not a big deal as long as you refund the purchase. There's no reason not to refund it within the first 30 days / first few hours of play time if the consumer's PC can't run it. I'm not one of these people who believes that consumers are automatically entitled to refunds, and in fact I ran a service that offered no refunds due to the nature of the product, but refusing in the case of an incompatible PC, when you can see the consumer has hardly used the product and it's not past the return window, is just being asinine.
There's also no reason that Steam shouldn't be able to check your computer's specs before you install a game and see if they meet minimum requirements, and then give you a warning before you proceed if they don't. It'd be awesome if that warning automatically included a "Refund Me and Remove the Game from My Library" feature. It'd be even more awesome if Steam kept track of everything this happened on and offered you the same games at 20% off once it detected an upgrade. :)
Regardless, avoiding this confusion/complexity/consumer irritation is a large reason that consoles are more popular than PCs for everyone, from the developer to the retailer to the end user. Your standard consumer knows if they have a Xbox (or at least they did before there was the Xbox 1 and the Xbox One...), but they don't know if their GPU supports a certain API level or the difference between their low-end mobile nvidia GPU and a Titan X.
That's just not true for any kind of this years AAA titles. They may barely run on an Iris Pro, but everything else is not going to provide even remotely usable framerate (if it'll start at all). I think you're hugely underestimating the huge 3D performance difference between the laptop Intels and a gaming GPU card like the currently most popular GTX 970. Intel GPUs are connected to a significantly slower shared RAM over significantly less bandwidth, they're noticably more thermally restricted (since they're sharing cooling with the main core) and have significantly less processing cores.
Having said that, I do fully agree that having a clear UI to tell you if your game is playable on your current machine is in order. As far as I know, you can already refund the game without problems, there's just not clear warning. And I DO want a warning, not an error check - we've seen countless cases of misdetection when games refused to run on hardware they didn't recognise correctly. Not to mention the usecases like mine, where I regularly buy games on Steam on my Mac just to play them on Windows.
Lowering your resolution (play windowed) and going to minimal built-in configs is usually good enough for hardware up to 4-5 years old, which is reasonably competitive with the console lifecycle. Older than this and you usually need to get into hacking the resources/config to make it playable.
There may be exceptions, but this is absolutely the rule for AAA titles. Studios could never make their money back if they targeted only users with discrete GPUs.
Only 17% of Steam users have an Intel card. Not sure how you came to that conclusion :)
Let's see the most successful games of the year:
- Battlefield 1, needs at least GeForce GTX 660 / Radeon 7850 with 2GB of VRAM. Will not start on Intel. - Call of Duty: Inifinite Warfare. Same requirement. - Overwatch, actually runs on Intel HD 4400. Needs at least 660/7950 to run well
etc. :)
For the record, I played BF 1 at 3440x1440 on my GTX 670 (which I just replaced with a 1070 on Xmas Eve). It was plenty playable. No, I couldn't crank the settings to ultra, but most casual PC gamers don't expect to be able to.
You're using Steam statistics as if they applied, proportionally, to the PC gaming industry when its users are majority PC gaming enthusiasts. This also means Steam makes up a small amount of most gaming company's sales. The majority is still done through big box stores. The statistics are interesting but I'm not sure how useful they are for determining target requirements from most gaming companies.
Reality check: a small, small minority of customers check PC game requirements before purchase. Considering Intel is the primary GPU of Apple's most popular computers I find it insane that one can claim Mac support but not support the majority of configurations in the past several years.
When I worked at retail, IT support and at Apple Care almost every single PC game issue a customer brought to me was for, you guessed it, them buying it without looking at the requirements and their PC not meeting the requirements.
Look at it from someone without a technical background (the majority of PC owners): they don't know what their system has, they don't know what many of the terms mean or what's better than another and they don't understand drivers. At all.
The PC games that required the least amount of support? They were the runs that could run on practically anything and, granted, running on something sub-optimal is going to not be as awesome but hey at least it runs. There are many game frameworks that support this type of graceful degradation. I would like to see more companies adopt this attitude so anyone can buy any PC game and expect it to at least run.