News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by franciscop on Friday December 23, 2016 @02:26AM (#13243420)
This kind of description can be made of any hardware piece. We came from a whole room, slow computer to an iPhone that can make billions of operations per second. I see the previous post as complaining about this not happening on the industry.

Of course making an iPhone (or a OnePlus phone if you want to get into low-scale) is not easy, but the technology has advanced and standardized enough to be considered "cheap" for what they offer, and really cheap compared with 10-20 years ago.

Why hasn't that happened with ultrasounds? Certainly most of the components have been around for a while and the process of making a "simple one" (in the way the average smartphone is simple ) should be a solved problem.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by blackguardx on Friday December 23, 2016 @03:14AM (#13243607)
I'm a hardware engineer and might be able to explain a bit. Industrial electronics doesn't seem to move at the same pace as consumer electronics from the outside, but there often is incredible progress at the same pace and perhaps faster than the consumer segments. It is often hard to discern to the outsider, because they lack domain knowledge to recognize these advancements.

On top of this, in certain fields, costs appear to remain stable and even go up a bit over time. In these industries, there typically isn't much demand for lower specc'd (AKA outdated) hardware. Often these products last such a long time that the used old models serve as the low cost market. Apple even copies this model by keeping their older products around longer than other companies and selling them at a lower cost.

In addition, the development of many industrial electronic products is extremely expensive and the markets are small (think 100s to 1000s per year). The company typically has to charge a very high price to stay in business.

While it's easy to look at something and think "I can make that with an Arduino or Raspberry Pi," this is basically the hardware equivalent of telling people you can make Facebook in a weekend (which used to be a popular claim here on HN years ago).

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by mping on Friday December 23, 2016 @04:50AM (#13243938)
For me its the same as pharma. Can you tell me if a government (ex India) would like to devote resources to make cheaper ultrassounds they wouldn't be able to? I only buy non-technical arguments, unless the bill of materials is on the same order as the price of the equipment.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by bayesian_horse on Friday December 23, 2016 @05:30AM (#13244067)
With pharma I think the main "cost" involved is about the risk of investment. It takes billions of Dollars to potentially make billions of Dollars from a single product. More likely you invest hundreds of millions of Dollars with no return at all.

It takes a special kind of company, almost a bank, to stomach that kind of risk. And this extraordinary risk also demands extraordinary rewards.

Medical technology isn't really the same thing.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by frozenport on Friday December 23, 2016 @01:44PM (#13246460)
The assessment of pharma isn't true, and is evidenced by their high profit margins along with price difference between different markets - same exact thing is substantially cheaper in the EU than in the USA.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by temac on Friday December 23, 2016 @10:01AM (#13245011)
How do you pay R&D engineers, prototypes, production, sales, support, etc... with such a low quantity volumes if the price is on the same order as the BOM?

Actually, depending on your precise definition of "same order", I could argue it already is. And while the gross margin will seem high if you are only used to consumer stuff, this is an almost useless metric for low volumes, where the net margin do not necessarily follow.

There are also not a ton of different vendors, so even dreaming about mutualizing some R&D costs (and that will mostly not happen), you would not save a lot.

Once again, cheap portable machines (but not able to do a lot) already exists.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by guitarbill on Friday December 23, 2016 @03:25AM (#13243647)
I came here to make exactly the same argument. Or cars, if we pick something that also needs certifying (from a purely manufacturing perspective). I get that most people would rather have a car, so more cars get made, so they're cheaper. (Athough roughly comparable, and there's different models. To me, it seems a car is more complicated than an ultra-sound system).

The author of the original article made a good point that there may be a market for cheaper, non-medical ultrasound. The author of this article totally ignores this. Of course he's going to say they ought to cost as much as they do.

> but for now take my word [...] seriously, you don't want to use these things without strong safety regulations.

Why? Instead of being a condescending asshat and lording his career achievements over us, this guy could have explained if and why it might be dangerous to build one yourself, again for non-medical use. Wouldn't a good article with great arguments be more convincing than a list of credentials?

(edit: I'm reasonably convinced that devices in hospitals probably should cost that much, but this article didn't change that significantly. some of the details about impedance matching were interesting)

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by Xylakant on Friday December 23, 2016 @04:22AM (#13243837)
Cars, iphones and laptops are sold in quantities that are magnitudes larger than ultrasounds. Even if every school bought one for students to experiment with, you'd still only have all schools and doctors in the world as potential market. On top of that, medical devices are supposed to work in comparatively harsh environments (strong disinfectants etc.) for a long long time. Iphone lifetimes are measured in years, not decades and don't you dare and try to get a spare part for a 10 year old macbook. All of that means that evolution is much slower in that market - more small steps rather than big disruptive changes.

I'd also challenge that cars are more complicated than ultrasounds. They do have more moving parts, but allowed tolerances are magnitudes larger than a few microns in all places.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by ChicagoBoy11 on Friday December 23, 2016 @07:46AM (#13244466)
... but the "magnitudes larger" that they are sold is also endogenous to the regulatory framework around them. Suppose you had to get a PhD in physics to be able to get a drivers license. All of a sudden we would see a lot fewer buying -- and therefore far fewer people selling -- cars since it is so expensive to actually be able to drive them.

With these ultrasounds, there is such a heavy regulatory framework at work -- from regulations impacting the device itself to regulations preventing hospitals from being built to regulations preventing hospitals from having as many of these as they want -- that they make the actual quantity demanded of these things artificially small. Your point about evolution of the technology also falls trap to this same fallacy: Again, if all of a sudden you are artificially making something much more expensive to produce, it should be no surprise to you that the refresh rate on the device would be smaller. Here you also have the added effect that since we rarely pay for our own medical care and instead rely on insurance, many of the incentives that would exist for companies to make cheaper, faster, better equipment also disappear. Lastly, I fully concede that it is quite possible that there is some basic, inherent quality of ultrasounds that make them more complicated than cars or any other pieces of tech. But that isn't important. The importance is realizing that the derivative of the state of these machines looks very different from other technology industries where competition and the free market are much more of a factor.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by temac on Friday December 23, 2016 @10:15AM (#13245074)
Ultrasound systems is probably the cheapest modality, there is quite a lot of competition in this market, there is a lot of innovations in this market, the machine are getting cheaper and more compact, and at least in the developed world there is no penury of ultrasound systems, the regulation are there to prevent somebody to build a shitty machine that for example burns you with and endoscopic probe (you would not like that), and the interpretation of ultrasound images requires to be highly trained (you won't even understand the basic physical features you have before your eyes if you are not trained, due to various artifacts that are intrinsical to the technology), which limit the potential for delivery machines to a significantly larger market, because all those machines would be of no use.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by LiesNStartupPR on Saturday December 24, 2016 @01:15AM (#13248841)
I do appreciate being called a "condescending asshat", I might get a t-shirt with that on it, thanks.

I though my credentials were one paragraph instead of many, but maybe I need to count again.

As for lording it over you with qualifications - I just needed to make it clear that I actually do have a huge amount of experience in this area, otherwise instead of being a "condescending asshat" people would be asking who the hell do I think I am commentating on this.

I make no apology for knowing what I'm talking about, there's too many articles written by people with no idea about the topic.

And don't take it personally, I've something of a reputation in ultrasound for being blunt.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by temac on Friday December 23, 2016 @10:09AM (#13245049)
A car is not necessarily more complicated than an ultrasound system.

Now the definition of "complicated" can be subject to debate, but you could be surprised if you compare the production prices of simple/high-end cars and simple/high-end ultrasound systems.

Really high volumes help a lot for all components. There are more and more components in ultrasound system that can be reused OTS from other markets, but even then, those larger markets are not necessarily larger than the cars market!

And it is not too dangerous to build one yourself for non-medical use, although it might be a little harder than you seem to think. But if you are reasonably skilled, I believe it is doable to design a toy system reasonably cheaply (but simply, do not expect to be able to use a raspberry pi GPIO and obtain something non-shitty). Go on if you want!

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by crististm on Friday December 23, 2016 @03:07AM (#13243582)
Indeed, but for the imaging industry there are only two potential clients: medical and welding. The hobby/educational/large masses market don't make the cut so to scale down the costs.

The IT industry price ranges were also in the millions of dollars before people had a need to play Angry Birds on a device in their pocket

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by JPLeRouzic on Friday December 23, 2016 @03:10AM (#13243589)
* Several IC makers are selling integrated devices (TI, Analog, Maxim), for example at TI: LM96530 (Beamformer), LM96511 (VGA/LNA) and LM96570 (TR Switch). Those are eight channels ICs, they cost $200 together. There are ICs for 16 or even 64 channels.

* Another claim is the need for a huge number of piezos, this probably a view from a remote past: With adequate coding and enough channels to enable beamforming, there is no meaning in having this extravagant number (200) of transducers IMO.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by LiesNStartupPR on Saturday December 24, 2016 @01:18AM (#13248855)
The basics of imaging require a certain number of elements. The acoustic window must be a certain size for the application, the elements must be smaller than a wavelength to avoid grating lobes (0.5 wavelength for perfect phased arrays in that regard). Divide one into the other, and you get a number of elements that's usually between 100 and 200.

On what basis do you make your statement that this is too many elements? IMO implies opinion, do you have any facts or physics to back up your statement?

Laws of physics do not change with time.

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by JPLeRouzic on Saturday December 24, 2016 @09:46AM (#13249942)
>> do you have any facts or physics to back up your statement?

I do not think that beamforming needs more than a few emitting sources neither a Nobel prize. Check no further than your Wi-Fi router's antennas.

The technology you are describing is entirely different and older, as in your description there is no beamforming.

In the technology you describe, there is a requirement for two emitters/receivers to be separated by less than a wavelength, however this strong requirement does not exist for beamforming.

What makes beamforming useful is modulating and coding the beam. Another thing important is the SNR, as it is the addition of the waves that creates "beams".

When I checked Google patents I found beamforming patents in ultrasound imaging since 1986, and super-resolution (pionnered in astronomy and microscopy) in ultrasound imaging since 2005 (US 20050160817).

Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by guitarbill on Friday December 23, 2016 @03:31AM (#13243674)
e.g. the LM96530 is lifebuy, so it's basically discontinued. LM96511 & LM96570: not recommended for new design. In other words, those ICs are basically obsolete.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by JPLeRouzic on Friday December 23, 2016 @05:03AM (#13243980)
Thanks for pointing out right to the important thing: Those ICs are not new, they are on the market since some years.
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by temac on Friday December 23, 2016 @10:24AM (#13245126)
And have probably been used in some cheap systems?
Re:Why Are Medical Ultrasound Systems So Inexpensive? by guitarbill on Friday December 23, 2016 @08:52PM (#13248202)
I don't know if the $200 quoted by the OP for all ICs is bulk pricing when they were new or $200 now when they are limited and special parts. But it's moot anyway, I doubt the ICs are the major price point.