Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by blauditore on Friday December 23, 2016 @08:32AM
(#13244604)
Ideas themselves should not be overrated. People often think the main part of building a successful product is having the right idea, and expect some form of compensation for submitting a good one. But as a matter of fact, if there is a problem to solve, many others have probably had similar ideas and the difference will be made in their implementations.
So the "compensation" of ideas with other ideas like here seems perfectly reasonable to me and should not be extended or gamified any further.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by hacker_9 on Friday December 23, 2016 @09:18AM
(#13244800)
Yep, it is the execution of the idea where the money is. Most well known products are simple to explain / understand, but it was their implementation and ability to retain users on their platform that make them successful.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by Animats on Friday December 23, 2016 @12:11AM
(#13242993)
Reminds me of the slogan on the trucks of Sunset Scavenger Company, the predecessor to Recology: "Satisfaction guaranteed or double your garbage back".
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by fiatjaf on Thursday December 22, 2016 @06:31PM
(#13241431)
Very cool.
I tried many approaches (although I didn't finish any implementation besides the first one, the worst) on idea sharing and feedback. This is probably a little better than the best I've thought in all these years.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by RealIdeas on Thursday December 22, 2016 @06:49PM
(#13241554)
Thanks. Yours looks very nice. I've been thinking of allowing comments on the ideas themselves but I like your approach better (where the comments fall into different categories).
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by lhnz on Friday December 23, 2016 @10:10AM
(#13245055)
Ideas which are 'actionable pieces of intellectual leverage' are actually massively underrated, and unfortunately grouped alongside mere daydreams.
If you happen to have a collection of design/market/engineering insights that could actually inform a working solution, you'd be a fool to just dump them into the public domain as free 'ideas'.
Executing the creation of a factory to produce lightbulbs is comparatively valueless, compared to inventing the first lightbulb. It's not only easier, it's also less important to society.
New ideas are actually incredibly important, and they might even be getting harder to find [0]. As Thiel said in 'Zero to One' [1]: "Every great business is built around a secret that’s hidden from the outside." Unless you have incredibly deep pockets or a monopoly, ideas are likely to be the only thing protecting you from your competition.
As an aside: the money isn't in execution, or in innovative ideas, but in the creation of economic moats [2].
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by isuckatcoding on Thursday December 22, 2016 @11:41PM
(#13242893)
Love this. I've been looking everywhere from reddit, twitter, hn to forums for inspiration for ideas (because I suck at coming up with my own).
I have more ideas about brick / mortar businesses (i.e. buy this thing off website X, rebrand and sell for Y% to make profit) than I do about SaaS business (which is my primary interest).
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by rolfvandekrol on Friday December 23, 2016 @09:23AM
(#13244824)
Just submitted an idea, which i think is pretty good idea, that i'm probably never going to implement myself, because i usually get lost in yak-shaving halfway (tried it three times). Let's see what ideas come out of this :)
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by kfk on Friday December 23, 2016 @07:40AM
(#13244451)
For me as an all round analytics manager in enterprise there are plenty of pain points. I am not sure I'd call them ideas, but it would be great to share those, also to see who else has them.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by sh87 on Saturday December 24, 2016 @03:17PM
(#13251448)
This is great and positive and all things nice. How about making this more valuable by somehow connecting me with 10 people who know about this problem area or have tried or are interested in building a solution to this and more important : people who are facing this issue and are wanting to try out my solution to the problems that I am trying to solve ?
To be honest the only thing that will inspire me to build something is seeing 10 real people face real issues that I believe I can solve. Queue Management for example. Its 2016 (almost 2017) for heaven's sake and I still see people queuing up at cash registers, coffee shops and department stores alike. That's what I want to solve. How is 10 new ideas helping me ?
Edit: This unintentionally turned out more like a rant than constructive criticism. Its just that I have a feeble sense of what I want and this does not feel like it. Credit to the author for actually building it, putting it up here and having the courage to be open to feedback.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by RealIdeas on Thursday December 22, 2016 @07:59PM
(#13241938)
"If I submit 10 ideas, where are the 100 new ideas going to come from?"
Same place as the first 10, from other people's ideas. If you're an idea generating machine the DB will eventually run out of ideas to give you.
"Why would someone swap one good idea for ten bad idea?"
This is answered in the FAQ. You get 4 from the top rated ones. Chances are if you haven't worked on your idea by now, you probably won't do it at all. Share your idea and you might get one or more that you will work on. Even if you don't get an idea you think it's "good" you might get inspiration from them or put a twist on these.
"What do you plan to do with "all" the ideas?"
Same as everyone else who submits an idea: get inspiration.
"Would you post answer to your own questions for your own site?"
I don't understand the purpose of your question.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by saycheese on Thursday December 22, 2016 @08:49PM
(#13242150)
The purpose of the question, "Would you post answers for your own site?" - being I don't understand and/or would be interested in the answers to the questions before for RealIdeas.site:
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by RealIdeas on Thursday December 22, 2016 @09:57PM
(#13242449)
This is all covered in the FAQ. Problem: no vetting process on similar sites. Solution: have someone read the ideas. It's free, not meant to make money. I just posted it on HN. I don't see similar sites with a vetting process out there.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by panorama on Friday December 23, 2016 @02:18AM
(#13243398)
I don't understand the negativity. This is a Show HN. And Show HNs don't have to be completely original things that have never before appeared on the Internet.
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by icebraining on Friday December 23, 2016 @05:47PM
(#13247623)
Why would someone swap one good idea for ten bad idea?
"He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me."
Re:Show HN: RealIdeas.site (submit an idea, get 10 real ones...
by automatwon on Friday December 23, 2016 @04:23AM
(#13243842)
Is there not a "low-tech" solution to this already?
Like an invite-only forum that extends invites to people who share an idea in the public thread? With increasingly more access as users continue to contribute ideas that receive positive feedback from their peers?
So the "compensation" of ideas with other ideas like here seems perfectly reasonable to me and should not be extended or gamified any further.
I tried many approaches (although I didn't finish any implementation besides the first one, the worst) on idea sharing and feedback. This is probably a little better than the best I've thought in all these years.
Oh, it looks like Wayback Machine has my first attempt at this thing stored: http://web.archive.org/web/20130814135339/http://www.ideacra...
If you happen to have a collection of design/market/engineering insights that could actually inform a working solution, you'd be a fool to just dump them into the public domain as free 'ideas'.
Executing the creation of a factory to produce lightbulbs is comparatively valueless, compared to inventing the first lightbulb. It's not only easier, it's also less important to society.
New ideas are actually incredibly important, and they might even be getting harder to find [0]. As Thiel said in 'Zero to One' [1]: "Every great business is built around a secret that’s hidden from the outside." Unless you have incredibly deep pockets or a monopoly, ideas are likely to be the only thing protecting you from your competition.
As an aside: the money isn't in execution, or in innovative ideas, but in the creation of economic moats [2].
[0] http://www-leland.stanford.edu/~chadj/IdeaPF.pdf
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Zero-One-Notes-Startups-Future/dp/B00...
[2] https://news.morningstar.com/classroom2/course.asp?docId=144...
I have more ideas about brick / mortar businesses (i.e. buy this thing off website X, rebrand and sell for Y% to make profit) than I do about SaaS business (which is my primary interest).
Does anyone have an example of such a TOS? One that basically says you relinquish all rights to the ideas you give on this website.
To be honest the only thing that will inspire me to build something is seeing 10 real people face real issues that I believe I can solve. Queue Management for example. Its 2016 (almost 2017) for heaven's sake and I still see people queuing up at cash registers, coffee shops and department stores alike. That's what I want to solve. How is 10 new ideas helping me ?
Edit: This unintentionally turned out more like a rant than constructive criticism. Its just that I have a feeble sense of what I want and this does not feel like it. Credit to the author for actually building it, putting it up here and having the courage to be open to feedback.
Why would someone swap one good idea for ten bad idea?
What do you plan to do with "all" the ideas?
___
Would you post answer to your own questions for your own site? Those being:
What's the problem?
What's the solution?
Why would anyone pay for that?
How would you reach your audience?
Are there other solutions out there?
How is your solution any different?
Will you reject bad ideas?
"Why would someone swap one good idea for ten bad idea?" This is answered in the FAQ. You get 4 from the top rated ones. Chances are if you haven't worked on your idea by now, you probably won't do it at all. Share your idea and you might get one or more that you will work on. Even if you don't get an idea you think it's "good" you might get inspiration from them or put a twist on these.
"What do you plan to do with "all" the ideas?" Same as everyone else who submits an idea: get inspiration.
"Would you post answer to your own questions for your own site?" I don't understand the purpose of your question.
What's the problem?
What's the solution?
Why would anyone pay for that?
How would you reach your audience?
Are there other solutions out there?
How is your solution any different?
Negative? I am only reflecting the questions back at the post/site that they're asking themselves.
"He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me."
Like an invite-only forum that extends invites to people who share an idea in the public thread? With increasingly more access as users continue to contribute ideas that receive positive feedback from their peers?