News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by TheBeardKing on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:11PM (#13239543)
I understand the libertarian ideal of being free to choose how to give away your own money, but how do they reconcile that with the ignorance of the elite as to the social problems they never encounter? Even given the inefficiencies of government, it's hard for me to imagine that the same amount of social spending could do more good from the hands of individuals than collective agencies.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by compiler-guy on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:19PM (#13239583)
There are plenty of governments that miserably fail to distribute very large amounts of aid in a way that actually helps the target groups [0] is one in the US, and internationally, things can be really, really sketchy.

One advantage about doing it via charity is that if a charity is ineffective, or fraudulent, switching to a new one is easy. Fixing a government full of corruption or inefficiency is quite a bit harder.

Government does have an important role, but it is no panacea.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/how-newark-schools-p...

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by jwatte on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:14PM (#13240443)
When a millionaire gives a million dollars to a school in a wealthy neighborhood, all tax payers are on the hook for 400,000 or so in tax deductions. So, rich giving disproportionately channels where government opportunity costs are spent!
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by boona on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:47PM (#13241084)
> Fixing a government full of corruption or inefficiency is quite a bit harder

You wrote "practically impossible" wrong.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by throawaybay on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:05PM (#13239932)
Umm.. you vote out the corruption?
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by nickff on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:17PM (#13240018)
This assumes that the elected officials are the problem, that better options are available, and that the system will allow change.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by WalterBright on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:10PM (#13240418)
A choice and a vote are very different things.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by liopleurodon on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:17PM (#13240020)
hahahahahahaha
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by jerf on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:26PM (#13239626)
First, when it comes to stories like this, libertarianism is basically irrelevant in the real world. To a first approximation, even in Silicon Valley, there aren't any. The Valley is far better known for its progressivism than its libertarianism now.

Second, I am unaware of any tenant of libertarianism that says it is somehow bad for people to band together into charity organizations, potentially the very same ones mentioned in the article, and for other people to give money to those organizations. Nothing about libertarianism requires altruistically-minded individuals to literally go out into the streets and start handing out dollar bills to individuals or something. Libertarianism is about not being coerced to join organizations, not about organizations existing.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:33PM (#13240143)
Libertarianism is also generally aligned against the Keynesian puppeteering that has created this gilded overinvestment bubble and regressive income-dissipating treadmill.

Furthermore, non-transmuted [0] libertarianism is fundamentally against the concentration of communication/power that has caused these parasitic nouveau-middlemen companies to even be a thing!

These principles are slow-acting general concepts, and so they do not address the immediate problem. Obviously if someone is hungry, you feed them first and then figure out how to avoid them getting into that situation in the future.

[0] Every political group starts off with valid critiques and seeking sanity, but the commercially useful parts are then overemphasized to support the status quo power structure. A true libertarian is inherently against large corporations (as there is no difference between a totalitarian government from an all-owning all-contracting corporation), even though they're easily tricked into condoning them.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:00PM (#13240748)
> (as there is no difference between a totalitarian government from an all-owning all-contracting corporation), even though they're easily tricked into condoning them.

Law works because everyone concent and choose to follow it. If you have such single non-violent corporation then there is nothing stops from people to just walk away.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:19PM (#13240904)
If you reverse your sentences, you actually address your own point -

> If you have such single non-violent corporation then there is nothing stops from people to just walk away.

> Law works because everyone concent and choose to follow it

... with the implication that people could choose to walk away from specific laws, which they can but just require a sizable group to do so.

Coming at it from the other direction, a non-violent corporation can still be coercive if it say owns all of the land and you must rent for a place to exist, or even if you own your land it owns all the roads you must sign a contract to travel. Would you feel better by just viewing USG as a corporation with a contract that you continue to consent to by not having left?

The straightforward response is that a contract to use a road should be scope-constrained to the topic of road usage, and not say also preclude you from using drugs on your own property. But that's no longer as simple and universal as a belief in unlimited contracts.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:51PM (#13241112)
> Would you feel better by just viewing USG as a corporation with a contract that you continue to consent to by not having left?

Yes I agree.

So lets assume we have someone who has monopoly on land (like USG) and who is non-violent (unlike USG). How do solve this: Trade Sanctions/Non Cooperation. Bitcoin is a similar development.

> The straightforward response is that a contract to use a road should be scope-constrained to the topic of road usage, and not say also preclude you from using drugs on your own property.

Agreed.

> But that's no longer as simple and universal as a belief in unlimited contracts.

Existence of unlimited contracts does not imply one have to agreed to one unreasonably. That is, think before agreeing to a contract (and arbitrator).

Also note the contract to remove unlimited contracts would (probably) be unlimited itself.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @06:16PM (#13241308)
> who is non-violent (unlike USG).

I assume you really mean non-aggressive (eg a libertarian would respect a masochist consenting to having violence done to them). Except we've moved the boundaries such that USG is actually non-aggressive (domestically, at least) - you've merely assented to a contract that says you will not use drugs, or USG may imprison you (this could be plausibly beneficial, say you wanted to avoid drugs and were worried about temptation).

> How do solve this: Trade Sanctions/Non Cooperation. Bitcoin is a similar development.

I fully agree, but this is besides the point I'm making. For example, you're actually implying these approaches are inapplicable because USG is not a corporation!

> That is, think before agreeing to a contract (and arbitrator).

Okay... So tomorrow, USG offers you an explicit contract by which remaining on its property (eg inside its borders), you agree to follow its detailed code incorporated by reference (currently called "laws"), as interpreted by its courts. You have a year to decide. At the end of the year, do you agree to this contract or do you leave?

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Thursday December 22, 2016 @07:40PM (#13241843)
> I assume you really mean non-aggressive

Yes.

> Except we've moved the boundaries such that USG is non-aggressive (domestically, at least) - you've merely assented to a contract that says you will not use drugs, or USG will have the right to imprison you

No, In Libretarian Land no one has right to imprison anyone for any reason whatsoever. This is a simple objective contract and I expect unanimous consent.

But you can also have have two Lands one support giving up of this particular freedom as part of contract and one simply outlaws it. More choices the better (which also means few govts being true socialist states, is ok). Let the market decide.

> For example, you're actually implying these approaches are inapplicable because USG is not a corporation!

You would not need this with Libertarian Government (LG) because LG would be very minimal and limited. Even if LG does a bait-and-switch (possible) other LGs/Govts can trade war. I should point out I dont support there be one global LG but numerous smaller LGs. Depending on one single entity is risky irregardless of its intentions.

> At the end of the year, do you agree to this contract or do you leave?

Lets say I sign it. After 5 years relocate to another country B. Then USG claims I owe them citing the signed USC. But for USC to be enforcable, B also have to consent to it. That is, I dont pay just because I signed the contract but because the consequences would be worse if I dont.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @09:43PM (#13242405)
> no one has right to imprison anyone for any reason whatsoever

Sorry, I chose the wrong word and have since adjusted it. Not "right", but mere "option" - based wholly on the contract you signed specifically agreeing to such.

> because LG would be very minimal and limited

This has no bearing on what I'm saying, since in this example USG is a corporation. There can also be a perfect LG that simply enforces the contract you signed with USG, or you can just imagine dutifully holding yourself to the contract.

> Lets say I sign it... Then USG claims

Don't add another hypothetical twist. If you sign the contract and stay, how would your basic situation differ from what it currently is (assuming you are currently in the US) ?

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Thursday December 22, 2016 @10:54PM (#13242709)
> There can also be a perfect LG that simply enforces the contract you signed with USG,

Thats not possible. LG would only enforce its own very minimal, objective & limited constitution. As a corporation within LG, USG would have to make USC enforcable without help from LG.

> or you can just imagine dutifully holding yourself to the contract.

Only if its in my interest to do so.

> If you sign the contract and stay, how would your basic situation differ from what it currently is

Its not. I am probably missing something, mind writing the whole question in one form again ?

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @11:13PM (#13242775)
> LG would only enforce its own very minimal, objective & limited constitution. As a corporation within LG, USG would have to make USC enforcable without help from LG

In general libertarian thought, the government enforces contracts between private parties. What you're describing sounds more like anarcho-capitalism.

> Only if its in my interest to do so.

In Libertarian thought, following contracts is a moral requirement. I have no disagreement with what you're asserting here - actually I think it's a good check against overbearing contracts. But we have to share a context in order to have a discussion. The tenets you're describing aren't libertarianism, at least in the US sense of the word. My entire point here is to help US-thinking libertarians avoid falling into the trap where their philosophy is bastardized to justify replacing government with all-powerful corporations.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Friday December 23, 2016 @11:20AM (#13245489)
> In general libertarian thought, the government enforces contracts between private parties.

> Okay... So tomorrow, USG offers you an explicit contract by which remaining on its property (eg inside its borders), you agree to follow its detailed code incorporated by reference (currently called "laws"), as interpreted by its courts. You have a year to decide. At the end of the year, do you agree to this contract or do you leave?

If USG is the government then this is not libertarianism. If USG is corporation (ie private party) who is the LG then ? The world ?

Lets say LG=World then is it USG the land owner ? I think not, so I dont have to leave if I own a land.

> In Libertarian thought, following contracts is a moral requirement.

Even in LG, you may have contacts of any scope but the contract with the LG would be very minimal. USC is not a libertarian constitution.

> My entire point here is to help US-thinking libertarians avoid falling into the trap where their philosophy is bastardized to justify replacing government with all-powerful corporations.

This does not follow from the fact that LG enforces private contracts. Its still upto you whether or not to sign away your freedoms.

Nonetheless, Libertarianism would be big improvement from current state, and only slightly less from AnCap.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by warkdarrior on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:26PM (#13240533)
> A true libertarian is inherently against large corporations

Wouldn't that limit the freedom of the owners/shareholders to grow their corporation to whatever size they want? And who gets to decide how large is large? The government?

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mindslight on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:12PM (#13240838)
Firstly, even without a concrete mechanism morals still exist. You're actually the one referencing the idea of an omnipotent government actor and needing to create an explicit constraint.

But an underlying philosophy of libertarianism is actually to find mechanisms that don't involve centralized ("state") actors. For one example, if more individuals sought out Free software, the Googles of the world would have a less "scalable" audience.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by wav-part on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:06PM (#13240792)
No. It means small compititors band together to compete against the market leader.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by paulddraper on Thursday December 22, 2016 @02:34PM (#13239679)
> Even given the inefficiencies of government, it's hard for me to imagine that the same amount of social spending could do more good from the hands of individuals than collective agencies.

(1) Imagine harder.

Get personal experience or talk to someone with personal experience with WIC, food stamps, disability, medicare/medicaid, etc. and you'll find out how inefficient, wasteful, and abused these things are. And I don't just mean by a little bit. I mean by A LOT.

(2) I agree that collective agencies can be more effective than individuals.

But not the government kind that are (a) awfully inefficient and (b) exact their contributions by force. I donate a significant portion of my income voluntarily to organizations of my choice that do good in better ways than writing legally mandated entitlement checks.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by jwatte on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:19PM (#13240477)
All of the welfare budget together (of which some fraction might be waste or fraud) is only a small fraction of the governments budget.

Corporations the size of governments are equally inefficient.

Finally, one major way we could make government more effective is to institute a public, national id number and allow data sharing between between agencies. But we don't trust our own government enough to do that. (Many civilized countries do, and it works great for them)

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by areyousure on Thursday December 22, 2016 @06:34PM (#13241451)
The person you responded to included "medicare/medicaid" in their list of government services. They each cost over half a trillion dollars per year.
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by paulddraper on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:45PM (#13240656)
"great" is relative.

Every other days some article rises to the top of HN about government surveillance.

[dead]
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by UncleMeat on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:03PM (#13240378)
This is an empirically testable statement and people have tested it. A huge number of people use financial or other assistance for only a temporary amount of time.

"Some people will waste the charity" is a terrible reason to avoid charitable giving.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mars4rp on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:12PM (#13239990)
do a little bit of more research on this, there have been handful of real studies on this, and they all showed people are more well off when they are get paid cash. no one better than you know your needs. and also you are not going to have the overhead and administration cost of providing services. one of the best government programs is tax credits, it gives cash to the poor and it is the only thing that left and right can agree on !!
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by brown on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:06PM (#13240390)
Could you provide sources? Search results are not so clear.

Should You Give Money to Homeless People?

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/03/should-y...

"The short answer is no. The long answer is yes, but only if you work for an organization that can ensure the money is spent wisely."

Reversal of Fortune is a 2005 Showtime documentary that asks the question "What would a homeless person do if they were given $100,000?"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversal_of_Fortune_(2005_film...

"When asked by Oprah how much of the $100,000 he still had, Ted replied "none." Ted also mentioned that he is homeless again, and content with his current circumstances."

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by mars4rp on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:34PM (#13240590)
http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/10/25/240590433/what-...

one thing that I remember, we are not talking about $100,000. I can see your point that giving that much money to a homeless people is a bad idea, but giving them $300 a month is better than food stamp. giving them $2000 a month is better than a shelter! and so on

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by sedachv on Thursday December 22, 2016 @07:25PM (#13241772)
> Reversal of Fortune is a 2005 Showtime documentary that asks the question "What would a homeless person do if they were given $100,000?"

That sounds like such a great film about this issue. Ted sounds like a really hard-working recycling bum. Since Ted is employing himself, Ted is an entrepreneur.

A good thought experiment to put this into perspective is: what happens to the average employed person when they are given $100,000? Except we do not have to do a thought experiment; this scenario occurs thousands of times a year all over the world for lottery winners. The largest study of lottery winners that I know of found that receiving (average) $100,000 doubles the chances of a person going bankrupt: http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/REST_a_00114

Some people who win the lottery and go bankrupt end up worse off than before winning the lottery (also worth looking at: http://brandongaille.com/22-lottery-winners-bankrupt-statist...). Ted, on the other hand, after spending a few months living the high life, went back to his old recycling business.

A lot of former tech entrepreneurs who gave up their dreams of running their own business (even some who went through Y Combinator!) can stand to learn a lesson from Ted's perseverance and positive attitude.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by jwatte on Thursday December 22, 2016 @04:20PM (#13240482)
A sample of one!
Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by codeddesign on Thursday December 22, 2016 @06:21PM (#13241352)
Agreed. The large majority of people are in debt due to society telling them to spend more and people wanting to live beyond their means. As a society, if we were taunt how to be financially responsible, the large majority in general would be more financially stable. If you have excess finances, you are more likely to be generous. The main issue is that since everyone is in debt - even millionaires we feel we have more wants and needs that availability to give. 68% of Americans have non-mortgage related debt. That tells me that republicans, democrats, liberals...etc are so self wanting that we are willing to go into debt amd over spend and only willing to help others when our way of life is not directly affected. "(Scrolling down Facebook wall..) Oh those poor kids in Seria! ..I'm going to do my part by commenting and then go to bed"

http://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/29/eight-in-10-americans-are-in-...

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by AJ007 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @03:30PM (#13240118)
I'm not sure in aggregate everyone is able to save their way to prosperity. There must be places for the capital to be deployed. A lot of savings end up going in to speculation which basically could be classified as gambling or waste. Take a look at China right now, a country with an incredibly high savings rate but much of it going to speculation.

The better problem to look at is what the savings are being spent on: investments that raise the quality of living for everyone.

Re:Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires c... by dvtv75 on Thursday December 22, 2016 @05:48PM (#13241097)
I believe there has been a fair bit of research into this, and poor people are more likely to be good at managing their money than those with significant disposable income.