Ask HN: Leaving a company I recently joined?
Less than a year ago, I was hired as a software programmer at a high-tech company which you've heard of. I find the work very interesting, it pays well, and I very much enjoy it.
I've recently been approached by another high-tech company which you've also heard of about the possibility of working there instead. While the talks are at a very early stage, I might find this position more attractive in a number of ways.
I wonder, however, about the questions of ethics and loyalty in leaving so soon a company that has invested in me, not to mention the effects it could have on my friendships with current coworkers, and the future impact on my career.
Your feedback is appreciated.
(
28 comments
| 18 points
| on HN
)
But if you're particularly concerned, then I'd suggest telling the new company that while you're tempted by the offer, you feel you have more to accomplish more at your current job before you're ready to leave. Then ask them to check in with you again in several months.
Odds are that they will either sweeten their offer, or else schedule a reminder to contact you again in a few months. Once large companies find a prospect they want, the odds of just forgetting about you are fairly low. Smaller companies are more liable to do that simply because they fill the position they wanted you for, and then they don't have any appropriate openings. But big companies usually have a variety of reasonably openings available at any time. (Unless you are very senior indeed, which I doubt you are.)
The people telling you not to be selfish do so because when you act selfishly, it goes against their selfish interests.
For example leaving Mahalo to go to Yahoo would be a no-brainer, even if you got paid less. Leaving Apple to go to Yahoo would be stupid. Leaving Google for Facebook... tougher call. The details make more of a difference than "+1, Insightful" type posts about loyalty, happiness, and such.
Making a difference. Facebook has about 1000 engineers/product people, Google has about 10000.
Interesting, popular product. Over 400 million people using, it's exciting, once-in-a-lifetime type of product despite the issues revolving around privacy etc.
Money If you have opportunity to get any stock options inside Facebook, you have possibility to get quite amount of money after IPO.
I assume that you have smart coworkers in both places. Google has more middle management and thus company politics, but it's still relatively flat for an organization of its size.
The rule of thumb is to never, ever take a counter-offer. But negotiating for one up front can sometimes work well.
If so, nothing else matters. The industry is not in a position to pick and choose based on how long you keep your jobs. If someone can get a year's worth of good work out of you, then that is a great deal for everyone. Because 99% of the people that interview for programming jobs have absolutely no clue about programming.
Ignore the "job hopping is bad for your career" hype. Those people are not interested in hiring good programmers, they are interested in having "headcount". You don't want a job like that anyway, so there's no loss to you. There are plenty of companies that actually want good programmers, so work for those instead. They won't care how long you were at your last job. (I wouldn't anyway...)
I suspect the "job hoppers are flakes" bandwagon includes a lot of people with big stakes in companies that need willing worker bees. If you get a better offer, jump on it. If you keep getting better offers, keep jumping on them.
The other big question to ask, if your current company hit a tough patch (not an unlikely scenario in this climate) how would they treat you? Would you be first or the last to be pink slipped? Are you sure. For example, It's more than likely there are managers and founders who will save their skins before giving a rat's arse about yours.
If you're concerned about friendships at work, fair enough. If you stop working daily with people many friendships will become less active. However, you can still stay in touch with people. And in 5 or 10 years, when most people have moved on from both companies, you'll hopefully keep a few friends from both.
As for the impact on your career: don't worry about it. Nothing wrong with changing to a better job. If anything, I'd say it will improve your resume (as in: worked for google then for facebook, awesome.)
Once you have a specific offer, then you have a decision to make.
Questions on ethics and loyalty should not even arise because companies most often than not make more money per employee than individual salaries. Do they feel guilty?
As for friends you can always keep in touch even after you leave your job.
Finally if this doesn't not convince you, just think of it this way if there were layoffs and your team was under the axe, will your company even give it a second thought about laying you all off?
What if the new company has problems and they need to lay you off? What if you new boss/team mates are jerks and keep making your life at the new company hell? ... What if you need to leave the new company a month after you join it.
New things are exciting, because they are different. But do remember that they have challenges as well.
While the above will likely not be the case for you, companies might think of you as not being loyal and might not want to invest in you much.
I personally would give my company 18 months at the least, and if I am getting restless I would have a nice long chat with my boss before leaving.
I don't know if the thought/plan/idea has crossed your mind, but be very, very careful about walking in to current company with other companies offer and trying to negotiate to stay. E.G. "They offered me this (be it money, perks, hours, or anything else) and I'd like to stay here but ([list of items from previous list that are most appealing]) is quite tempting. Can you counteroffer?".
It may be different at different companies (I'd hope so) but I've observed friends & coworkers do this and end up in a worse situation staying. They've signaled to people above that they're disloyal/easily distracted/however you want to phrase it and the perception changes. The company in most cases felt they really needed to make an effort to keep the person, but the treatment and trust changed significantly afterwards.
TL;DR - Be careful about negotiating with company #2s offer to stay at current company with perks/salary/etc from company #2. You may find they keep you out of need but keep you at a distance going forward.
As for the meat of the actual question you asked - I would recommend that there's no harm in taking things through to completion with the other company and seeing what they have to offer. Even if you decide ultimately for WHATEVER reason, if you handle it gracefully in most cases you can prop a door open for yourself. Assuming you get a great offer from the new company but decide that you'd like to stay where you are for a few more months , if you handle it professionally (maybe phrased as "finishing a project") there is no reason that "no thank you" has to become "no thank you for now".
Most good companies who value talent and the like will not suddenly burn your resume and curse your name if you turn down an offer in a professional manner. The likelihood is that if they wanted you today there's no reason they wouldn't jump at you in 6 months if your situation changes.
Again, TL;DR - Don't burn bridges on either end if you can help it. Manage the opportunities in a way that whichever direction you go you can leave doors open at both if your situation/opinion changes.
The company has invested in you, but you have been investing in the company as well. You won't get the time you spent there back to work on something else.
If you are going to grow or be more challenged more somewhere else, then the future impact will be positive anyway, for you and others. Just be you aren't drinking the new company kool-aid before making a decision.
I would go where you think you'll be happiest where 'happiness' is a linear equation comprising money, interesting work, nice colleagues and whatever else matters to you.
A word of caution: make sure nobody at your current company finds out you're talking to the new company until you have an offer on the table.
Good luck.
If it doesn't work, walk out, making sure you honour your notice period and have a face-to-face chat rather than sending an email.
That's my advice.
J
I don't think you've given enough detail here for anybody to tell you with significant confidence you should stay or go, but I don't see a strong case for going based on what I've heard. You started off by saying less than a year ago you started a new job at a name brand high-tech company where the work is very interesting, pays well and you very much enjoy it. ... And yet you're wondering whether you should leave? sound of record needle screeching I feel like something is missing.
Sometimes people really do "job hop" and for the wrong reasons. Be sure you don't do that or you could regret it. Only you know enough details about your situation to determine that.