Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by SamAtt on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @07:42PM
(#1323024)
They probably do need to lighten up but I can see their point here. Ellen's poking fun at herself but Apple's afraid it will translate into "the iPhone is hard to use". Apple's now looking to target the Computer Illiterate folks and the fake commercial could be seen as a sign that it's hard to use. Which is why Colbert and Stewart (who mocked the company and not a specific product) didn't get calls.
Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by zweben on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @11:44PM
(#1323482)
Not really. The Streisand effect would be if Apple's reaction caused the joke ad to be viewed more, and those views hurt them. The ad's harmless though; they just look stupid because they overreacted.
Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by bartl on Thursday May 06, 2010 @12:20AM
(#1323543)
Well, looking at the spot, I wonder myself about Ellen's "thick fingers" compared to the size of the buttons at the bottom of the screen. It looks like it requires a control pen (like the one from the Nintendo DS) to properly operate. And I bet my fingers are actually easily 50% thicker than hers.
It's not Ellen's jokes that makes me wonder, it's just the video itself. Ellen's text just highlights what I was wondering.
And judging by the applause at the end of the spot, it looks like she hit a nerve.
Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by jsz0 on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @10:19PM
(#1323307)
Do we know what Apple's relationship is with the show? Are they paying for positive product placement? According to one reference I found online the Ellen show employs a product placement team that solicits in-show sponsorship. If that is indeed the case here I don't blame Apple for wanting clear cut good PR.
Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by slater on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @08:59PM
(#1323199)
Why would you even think for one second that this "dust-up" isn't fully orchestrated by Apple in the first place? Are consumers really that dumb? That's two days in the running that Apple got (seemingly free) advertising on her show.
Less laughably transparent plugging of products, next time.
Re:After the Ellen DeGeneres iPhone dust-up, does Apple need...
by karipatila on Thursday May 06, 2010 @02:01AM
(#1323693)
Do we even know for a fact that Apple contacted the show? She just said they weren't happy about it, which I took as a follow-up on the joke. They never mentioned Apple insisting on a formal apology, it just got reported so that it was implied.
It's reactionary but not illogical.
It's not Ellen's jokes that makes me wonder, it's just the video itself. Ellen's text just highlights what I was wondering.
And judging by the applause at the end of the spot, it looks like she hit a nerve.
Less laughably transparent plugging of products, next time.
I like this game, let's do it with candy:
Swedish berry, or fuzzy peach?