That doesn't mean its good for anyone not working for the government, explicitly (as an employee or contractor) or implicitly (as a data collecting company which can be forced to share).
IMO a) collecting data on users and b) doing it in a way that does not preserve user privacy makes you complicit to mass surveillance.
Edit: directly -> explicitly
I totally agree. I'd argue that it's objectively bad for anyone not working for the government. But I'm talking about from the company's point of view.
Also, if there were a proponent of this kind of collection, wouldn't it be fine for a company like Google, Facebook, Microsoft, etc... if someone with the position of US President wanted to "sit in the datacenter with an open laptop"? Because then they'd be using data as a currency, which they are already very comfortable and capable of doing to meet their own and the "gov" agendas.
No matter how many examples we get of far better funded companies getting hacked.
I think the masses are not scared enough to encrypt their communications and that's why such an apparatus has crept in so brashly and abruptly, sort of a 'surveillance creep'.
The moment the masses are conscious of the fact we are going through our second 'crypto war' is also the moment they might encrypt. Not that crypto is some munition they can use, as is wrongly spouted by the cypherpunks (IMHO), but that crypto can provide viable amounts of privacy for their needs and it doesn't need to be absolute privacy as spouted by the 'go dark' movement. Just enough that I can surf the web without my eyeball hours being monetized or that the pressure cooker I am interested in buying is not a potential tool to be used in a terrorist attack several weeks later.
https://www.google.com/search?num=100&client=firefox-b&q=tot...
s/nixon/goebbels/
and there's no need to imagine it
It just doesn't matter that much, because the inconvenience is minimal for the average person, so the backlash is minimal. I mean, most people cannot even be bothered to use different passwords (!). That's how low the bar is. Say something gets hacked, unless you experience identity theft, nothing happens. Banks will reverse any fraudulent charges. Not even a minor inconvenience. So people won't learn and won't care. Brand damage is minimal. Not worth spending on infosec if the maximum fine is less than your CEO earns in a month. Meh.
Video: https://youtube.com/watch?v=GAXLHM-1Psk