Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by tvon on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @01:54PM
(#1321920)
> Posting the information to the Internet is an unorthodox way of asking Apple if they want their property returned, but it ultimately has the same result.
You're high as a kite.
edit: I think your comment is best read in the voice of Fat Tony.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by jshen on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @01:50PM
(#1321903)
let's say someone steals your car. I buy it from them, then brag about it on the internet. I then realize I've drawn the attention of law enforcement and I "return" it to you in a "timely" manner. Is it theft? I mean, my bragging about riding around town in your car is an unorthodox way of asking you if you want it back.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by Mazy on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @02:15PM
(#1321997)
The thing is, in this case, Gizmodo didn't really know if it was stolen - there was no way for them to know if it was a legitimate device or a knockoff from China. After they posted it Apple confirmed it really was their device and they returned it immediately.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by glhaynes on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @02:28PM
(#1322048)
Are they in the habit of paying $5,000 for things that they think are likely Chinese knockoffs?
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by awa on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @02:59PM
(#1322154)
They probably are in a habit of paying money for devices which look interesting and aren't easily available in the US market. So if somebody comes to them with a next gen mp3 player from China and they like it from the looks they probably gonna pay good money for it.
Re:IPhone, Gizmodo, and moral clarity about crime
by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @03:47PM
(#1322306)
'Hello, Apple public relations? Is that Harry Helpful? Hey Harry, John Journalist from famous tech blog Gizmodo here...yeah I'm fine. Listen, someone gave me this thing that looks like a prototype of the new iPhone. Maybe you want to check in with your legal or engineering departments...'
That's the thing though. Gizmodo did in fact return the iPhone to Apple without complaint, in a timely manner. Posting the information to the Internet is an unorthodox way of asking Apple if they want their property returned, but it ultimately has the same result.
If any crime was committed by Gizmodo, it is theft of trade secrets, not theft of the device.