News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building Jarvis by haser_au on Monday December 19, 2016 @06:40PM (#13216018)
>> Calling it AI is a bit of a stretch though

Mark replied to a comment along these exact lines. Quote below;

Mark Zuckerberg: That's the thing about AI. It's sort of like magic. We only call things AI that we don't understand yet. Once we understand something, it's just math.

But if you'd asked someone 30 years if a computer system that you could talk to, that could see your friends and let them in, that could learn your listening habits and figure out when to make you toast, if that was intelligent, then most people would have said that would be AI. Now that we know how to do it, it's just math.

Re:Building Jarvis by tomphoolery on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:46PM (#13216399)
In my parents generation, and the generation that came after them (the one my siblings belong to, Gen X), I still think this differentiation between concepts of fictional AI were present. Consider for example the computer systems in Star Trek, and especially The Next Generation, and contrast how they worked with how Commander Data was depicted. The computer systems on Star Trek can be programmed using natural language, and by the 23rd century they're capable of even piloting an entire starship that a crew of hundreds would normally be required for. Yet, these computer systems never engage in the kind of inner exploration (or "character development") that Commander Data goes through every episode. This is what we're seeing here, Jarvis is more like a primitive version of the USS Enterprise's central computer, whereas "true" artificial intelligence, the kind that makes complex decisions on its own and has the capability of self awareness, still remains fiction.

Writers, at least, understood that there were different "flavors" of artificial intelligence. I have a funny feeling that at least science fiction enthusiasts also knew that AI would be separated in this way if it ever came to fruition.

Re:Building Jarvis by shard on Monday December 19, 2016 @08:29PM (#13216582)
Pardon my nerding out, but I think the difference between the computer system and Data was the degree of self-determination given to each system. When the holodeck was instructed to create an opponent capable of defeating Data, it created an sentient Moriarty AI. The computer system was fully capable of being a full AI, it was just never instructed to.
Re:Building Jarvis by iherbig on Monday December 19, 2016 @11:02PM (#13217366)
Moreover, they make the point in one of the episodes (3x06, "Booby Trap", IIRC) that the ship's computer's intelligence is INTENTIONALLY limited. The reason that Data is unique isn't simply due to his status as a fully sapient being. It's because of his positronic brain.
Re:Building Jarvis by adrianN on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @10:10AM (#13220414)
The ship's computer being limited to turning on the lights is just one of many points in Star Trek where the writers intentionally avoid using the fictional technology to its full capabilities in order to keep the plot exciting and suitable for a main stream audience. Transporters and replicators are another example: Suitably used they could be terrifying weapons.
Re:Building Jarvis by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:02PM (#13222814)
> Transporters and replicators are another example: Suitably used they could be terrifying weapons.

One thing I was always wondering is why it took as long as ST:VOY to see transporters being used as a way to deliver armed torpedoes directly into the target.

In later seasons of Stargate SG-1 they sidestepped this problem cleverly - when humans received transporter technology from a more advanced species, they had non-overridable safeguards[0] (and an inspector on-board) preventing them from being used as a weapons delivery platform.

[0] - which, in the best fashion of this series, were overridden several times anyway. A lesson for those who think that if something is banned, it won't be used.

Re:Building Jarvis by ethbro on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:00PM (#13222796)
Star Trek, for all it's technology, was always a story about humans. Even Data's journey is about as human-centric as you can get. In that way even the recent series have mirrored an older age of science fiction ("Using science to opine on the human condition" etc).

The Culture novels managed to convince me that a story about true AI needs to not only look a little different, but fundamentally different. Not least, answering "Why still humans around?"

Re:Building Jarvis by hacker_9 on Monday December 19, 2016 @06:57PM (#13216132)
And yet 30 years we could do all that with a whole lot of if statements. It would just return false positives a lot more. A couple of others have replied saying the same thing as you that this is 'AI', but it's not. As soon as you try to use it for something it wasn't programmed for, it fails. It doesn't even understand what it is doing right now. This isn't me 'moving the goalposts' either, we have literally never achieved anything close to AI. It baffles me that people think this is even remotely AI to be honest.
Re:Building Jarvis by haser_au on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:18PM (#13216255)
Have a read of this; http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/artificial-intelligence-revolu...

It's a very long read, but it will give you a much better overview of AI and the different "calibres" than I could possibly try to in a HN comment.

What Mark has used here is "Artificial Narrow Intelligence (ANI)", the first of three levels/calibres of AI. Level 2 is "Artificial General Intelligence (AGI)", otherwise known as "Human Level AI". And level 3 is "Artificial Superintelligence (ASI)" which is "“an intellect that is much smarter than the best human brains in practically every field, including scientific creativity, general wisdom and social skills.” [Quote: Nick Bostrom].

Re:Building Jarvis by hacker_9 on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:35PM (#13216337)
sigh this is why I don't usually get involved in arguments about whether something is considered AI or not; it just devolves into people trying to define and redefine what the word 'AI' even means.

Final word: I follow this stuff closely and read the research articles, and what we currently have is really great, but it's still just pulling the wool over your eyes. These techniques and algorithms trick you into thinking they are intelligent when in fact they are anything but. What we have now is a parlour trick in comparison to what the brain is doing. When true AI actually comes along, no one will doubt it.

Re:Building Jarvis by enobrev on Monday December 19, 2016 @08:26PM (#13216562)
To be fair, I fool people into thinking I'm intelligent all the time.
Re:Building Jarvis by sdenton4 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @01:54AM (#13218017)
Superintelligence will be achieved by: a) Training a system to trick the smartest people on the planet that it's smart, and then b) Asking it to prove itself by solving the Riemann hypothesis.
Re:Building Jarvis by ecopoesis on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:45PM (#13216389)
I was unaware that we knew how how human intelligence works. </sarcasm>

If we can build systems that can fool us into thinking their intelligent (which I will agree that outside of limited scopes we have not), then we built intelligence.

Re:Building Jarvis by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:07PM (#13222877)
I agree.

What I see we have now is lots of bricks - often overly problem-specific (and it's important to stress this; a lot of things that get called "AI" in the news is really lots of compute thrown at super specific heuristics). To call it AI, we still need to connect them together into a system that can use those components to learn and solve problems it didn't see before, without bricking itself in the process.

Re:Building Jarvis by ethbro on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:29PM (#13223078)
> parlour trick in comparison to what the brain is doing

That's a good turn of phrase, because it speaks to the real rub between algorithmic insufficiency and hardware insufficiency. From my reading, it seems fair to say that "strong general AI" will require some product of both to be realized and that our current hardware capabilities likely fall short of the minimum requirement (even with optimal algorithms).

Were they imagining exascale computing when Quicksort was dreamed up in 1959? No. But does that make it any less important?

Re:Building Jarvis by joesb on Monday December 19, 2016 @10:41PM (#13217283)
Or may be you give your brain too much credits.
Re:Building Jarvis by tim333 on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:41PM (#13216363)
You couldn't do face or voice recognition 30 years ago with if statements.
Re:Building Jarvis by sorbits on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @04:22AM (#13218499)
According to [1] there was a system in 1968 that “consistently outperformed humans when presented with the same recognition tasks”.

As someone who was into programming and electronics in the eighties, I also feel a need to object whenever people say things like “we thought it was AI until we could make a computer do it, and now it’s just math” (paraphrasing).

We (those of us interested in the subject back then) had a pretty good idea about what would be possible in the future (because of faster machines and more storage) and what would not be possible in the future (unless a breakthrough was made in understanding intelligence).

Now, I do think we underestimated how fast things have developed, and especially the resources people have access today via the internet, but none of what I have seen today would have been classified as AI by myself back in the eighties.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_recognition_system#Hist...

Re:Building Jarvis by tim333 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @07:25AM (#13219234)
I also mucked around with computers in the 80s and agree with most of that. I guess a lot of whether stuff is AI comes down to how you define it. The Oxford English Dict has:

>[mass noun] The theory and development of computer systems able to perform tasks normally requiring human intelligence, such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making, and translation between languages.

So obviously by that speech and Zucks type of face recognition are AI. I note the '68 system was hybrid and required humans to measure the faces and enter data for where the features are so it was more analysing numbers.

There was actually speech recognition software in the 80s but it used a neural network approach rather than if statements and didn't work terribly well https://www.wired.com/2013/11/tech-time-warp-of-the-week-ibm...

Human level thinking type AI is obviously still to come.

Re:Building Jarvis by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:11PM (#13222912)
But as a data point, you could do it 10 years ago. On a cheap desktop PC. And without Internet connection or cloud computing.

Source: around 2006 I made a Star Trek-like music control system with Microsoft Speech API and an electret microphone hand-soldered to a long cable and an audio jack. With ~30 minutes of training on my voice it worked as reliably in noisy environment as Google works for me now.

Re:Building Jarvis by Twisell on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:56AM (#13218218)
Theoretically you could, but as you were actually limited by hardware (camera resolution, CPU, etc...) anyway nobody really tried.
Re:Building Jarvis by mynameisvlad on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:19PM (#13216261)
There's a difference between a strong/general AI, which is what you call AI and a weak AI, which is what the rest of the world calls current AIs.

An AI doesn't need to do something it wasn't programmed for or understand what it's doing to count as one.