News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The pension gap by jstepka on Monday December 19, 2016 @04:20PM (#13215076)
"More than 200,000 civil servants became eligible to retire at 55 — and in many cases collect more than half their highest salary for life. California Highway Patrol officers could retire at 50 and receive as much as 90% of their peak pay for as long as they lived."

It is simply not possible economically to support these type of benefits. Look no further than the Greece or Italian austerity crisis to see how these type of government payments will play out.

Re:The pension gap by tajen on Monday December 19, 2016 @05:19PM (#13215508)
It's the same in every country: Some historical group's advantage can't be removed because they are enough people to get leverage against any opponent. There's a need for a new advance in democracy, because it has almost-bankrupted a few countries now (including Greece). Perhaps the separation of powers in our democracies (executive, judicial and law-makers) isn't enough. Maybe we should add a 4th weight, which translates hard limits from nature into limits that politics can't cross: "You can't allow a global warming", "You can't increase debt beyond 4%", "You can't let people work dramatically less for 5 decades (like in Greece), unless you justify it with an incredible progress in NGP/GDP/technology" or "You can't have discrepancies between public and private sectors". Somehow I'm happy Europe provides a bit of pushback against my country (France) because God knows how much debt our politics would otherwise subscribe.
Re:The pension gap by twic on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:33PM (#13216324)
How about we weight people's vote by an estimate of how long they've got left to live? After all, the longer into the future you'll live, the more seriously you have to take it.
Re:The pension gap by hkhall on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @09:08PM (#13226258)
I see several thoughts about that interesting proposal(offhand and only related to USA):

1) Those that have participated in government/military have less say than when they served. This could be a positive, but I feel some objection to a POW (my grandfather for instance) having less say than someone who didn't serve. 2) Do _really_ we want the least experienced citizens having the most say? The US already has age limits for certain offices so that sort of reduces my concerns about this, but... 3) Phase in plan? Currently voting is dominated by older voters. I don't see those people rushing to their polling places to vote to have the value of their vote lessened. Could be interesting to see the reasoning that happens for people to vote for or against it from a game theory perspective.

Still, I am interested.

Re:The pension gap by mercer on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @10:14AM (#13229702)
> 2) Do _really_ we want the least experienced citizens having the most say?

That's the first thing that I thought of, but then I realized that I have a pretty dim view of the 'experience' of most older people that I know. They are woefully unable to use computers, and on account of their 'trust' in things like fake news they seem incredibly unprepared to deal with our current reality and are just as susceptible - if not moreso - to populism. And while this is a bold claim I'm not quite prepared to defend, they seem quite a bit more selfish and materialistic than the twenty-somethings I spend much of my time with.

Maybe in times of rapid change like ours, 'experience' doesn't mean as much as it once did.

Plus, it goes both ways. If we should defer to those with more experience, it's only fair that they should take better care of their offspring.

Re:The pension gap by nugget on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @03:59AM (#13218425)
Let people vote with their feet. Avoid bailouts when pain arises from obvious mistakes, corruption and self-dealing. The rest will sort itself out.
Re:The pension gap by nugget on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @03:53AM (#13218401)
There was a fascinating discussion about Greece on HN about a month ago. Based on what some Greek posters were saying, it seemed like the Government has effectively nationalized the housing market by raising property taxes to 5-6% (through purposefully inflated appraisals). If you're a Government in desperate need of revenue then it makes sense, as land and houses are the only assets you can't move out of the country. That may be the endgame for many of these heavily indebted cities, states and countries.
Re:The pension gap by hiram112 on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @08:46AM (#13219670)
Honestly, this has been one of the reasons I've chosen to avoid buying a home even though I could easily afford it now.

Seems like, besides lack of mobility in a era of never stable employers, owning a home essentially weds you to your locality's debts - unfunded bonds, pensions, etc. You can already see how cities with the biggest problems - Chicago, Detroit - are already cracking. They went for the easy things first: traffic cameras, cigarette taxes, huge tourist taxes on rental cars and hotels.

But eventually they'll come after the biggest cash cow which is property taxes.

Re:The pension gap by mercer on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @10:04AM (#13229620)
> But eventually they'll come after the biggest cash cow which is property taxes.

I sure hope so. Actually, scratch that, I'm not sure. It might affect people that I don't want it to affect. It's probably complicated (so by all means enlighten me).

I'm all for someone buying a house and being able to keep it and live in it. But what bothers me to no end is that every single house I've lived in, renting a room for pretty steep prices what with wanting to live in a city, involved a landlord who made a good deal of money on me and my fellow renters, and for no reason other than buying or renting the house a long time ago when it was still cheap.

My previous landlord made a profit on the rent-controlled apartment he snagged a decade or so ago. While the rent is a significant portion of our income, he makes a profit and gets to kick us out (in a friendly way) once he wants it back. The fact that this guy was a major squatter back in the day only makes this more frustrating.

My current landlord does fuck-all and has some kind of disability that has kept him from working for a while. I'm pretty sure that the rent I pay at the very least pays his mortgage, and perhaps even leaves him with some profit, all because he's older and he got there first. Meanwhile I, in my early thirties, am paying a significant sum just to be able to live in 'the city'.

I'm happy he's got a place, don't get me wrong, and I can afford it. But it feels more than a a little unfair to see my younger siblings and friends struggle to pay rent when he's got a whole apartment all for himself for no particular reason other than 'times changed'.

I could go on and involve my 'Boomer' grandparents who are throwing all their money at improving their home in bum-fuck nowhere that none of their offspring will ever care about, while they've got kids and grandkids who could really use a bit of money, but I'll leave it at this.

It reminds me of 'We Suck Young Blood' by Radiohead, and while I suppose that's what we get in a society that emphasizes the individual over the collective, it still sucks, and quite frankly I feel no remorse over never visiting my grandparents once they're in a home and waiting to die. Let them die alone and unsatisfied with their fancy house.

(okay, I'm exaggerating. I'll visit them and I do care for them. But man does this stuff bother me!)

Re:The pension gap by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @12:43PM (#13222043)
It seems like that would be unsustainable since that would kill off construction of new housing. It would be more sustainable to do it only for the land, but not the buildings themselves.
Re:The pension gap by nugget on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @12:56PM (#13222191)
Sometimes systems have to crash before they can reboot - part of the normal life cycle and trying to prevent pain can end up making it worse.
Re:The pension gap by ubernostrum on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @02:04AM (#13218042)
It is simply not possible economically to support these type of benefits.

It is possible to support these types of benefits. It's just not possible to do it while also using the public workers' pension fund as a backup piggy bank when the rest of the government budget needs help.

When you dig into these types of stories you almost always find that millions or often billions of dollars have been raided out of the pension fund by the legislature or the executive in order to make their budget numbers look good. Same is true for other publicly-funded initiatives which are always touted as "too expensive" or chronically "underperforming".

Of course, the same is true in the private sector as well, it's just that there at least the leadership has to go through the formality of declaring a bankruptcy in order to raid the pensions and repurpose money to their own preferred projects.

Re:The pension gap by zaroth on Wednesday December 21, 2016 @07:43AM (#13228628)
Sometimes this does actually happen, "His predecessor, Gov. Pete Wilson, took $1.6 billion from CalPERS accounts in 1991 to help close a state budget gap." But the overall trend is exactly the opposite.

TFA is called 'The pension gap' for a reason. According to TFA, billions are flowing from general funds into the pension fund to cover the short-fall. $24.6 billion in the last decade, and another projected $20 billion in the decade to come. [1]

When the pension benefits amount to $2.6 million annuity at the day of retirement after 30 years on the job, yes, it is objectively too much of a benefit and unaffordable. If we were talking about an annuity worth just 5% of salary for each year worked, it would be a different story. But $2.6m divided by 30 is $86,666. That is just insane.

[1] - http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-me-pension-crisis-davis-d...

Re:The pension gap by Amezarak on Monday December 19, 2016 @04:43PM (#13215234)
That depends on how much is paid in and if it's mismanaged.

It's also recommended to have your 401k set to pay your final monthly pay for your remaining months. We think that's sustainable, don't we?

The real problem in America is gross mismanagement of pension funds. It's going to get worse. I live in a county where it was suddenly discovered administrators had been lying both about funding the pension and it's performance for years and now employees are screwed.

Re:The pension gap by user5994461 on Monday December 19, 2016 @04:55PM (#13215323)
Lived in a country without 401k and without private pension funds... turns out it's gonna collapse too.
Re:The pension gap by kobeya on Monday December 19, 2016 @04:49PM (#13215281)
Unless the global economy collapses, and your 401k along with it.
Re:The pension gap by Eridrus on Monday December 19, 2016 @06:43PM (#13216038)
As opposed to having state funded pensions which are invested in the market and when the global economy collapses everyone else who just lost their savings has to pay even more to the people on fixed income plans?

When the global economy tanks everyone is in for a hard time.