News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by drunkpotato on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @09:02AM (#1321013)
In order to "keep on" advancing rationality and freedom we would first have to start advancing rationality and freedom. Both are in short supply.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by DrSprout on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @10:38AM (#1321315)
You could start by making a rational argument instead of appealing to a cynical belief that everyone is irrational and intent on restricting freedom. The essence of the irrationality that pervades American political discourse is exactly that sort of "everyone is crazy" mentality. There are plenty of people advancing rationality and freedom. You aren't one of them.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by CWuestefeld on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:21PM (#1321625)
appealing to a cynical belief that everyone is irrational and intent on restricting freedom

I don't see that in the GP. It looks to me that he's working from the observation that personal liberty is decreasing, presumably revealing that the decisions being made are not rational. In particular, there's no reason to read into this anything about scope ("everyone"), nor their intent (to restrict freedom).

Clearly it would be incorrect to impute this to everyone when the restricted liberty can only be caused by the few in power.

Also, it may not be their intent to restrict freedom. Indeed, their intent may be to save our freedom, but due to the observed lack of rationality, their efforts carry the (assumedly unintended) side effect of restricting freedom.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by drunkpotato on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @06:50PM (#1322908)
Thank you, that was a very clear and succinct rebuttal.

I would add to it, that "advancing freedom" is one of those phrases that is, when you examine it, quite poorly defined. Freedom is more a set of associations than a strict definition, though I'm sure one can find philosophers who have attempted to strictly define it, so you get "freedom sub Professor X". Freedom is much easier to talk about in the abstract than to define, and lends itself to pithy (or, less charitably, glib) phrases that can be twisted to whatever one's own definition of freedom is.

My original post was flippant and lacking in nuance, to be sure (still not warranting the personal attack; I do, in fact, attempt to point out logical fallacies and bring about reasonable discourse). I am not immune to making the odd sound-bite myself, though calling my post cynical and then making a strawman attack also does not advance the cause of rationality.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by CWuestefeld on Thursday May 06, 2010 @08:55AM (#1324289)
"advancing freedom" is one of those phrases that is, when you examine it, quite poorly defined

I agree, which is why I instead used the term "liberty" in some places. While the term "freedom" has in modern times become clouded particularly with the notion of "positive" freedoms, I believe that the term "liberty" tends to be more strongly associated with the more traditional notions of "negative" liberty.

But I must concede that even this difference is at the grossest level, and there remain much more nuanced differences in definition beyond the negative/positive distinction.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by boredguy8 on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @06:42PM (#1322878)
I hate to admit it, but I quick-clicked the upvote on your parent basically -as- I started reading your comment and thinking. Normally I'm firmly in the "misdiagnosing stupid" camp.

It's sad and frustrating to realize that we, too, are human! and so must constantly self-check on these sorts of things. While the word "community" gets over-used, I think that's part of what community can do.

Or perhaps: civilization.

Thanks for the gut-check.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by slackerIII on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:15PM (#1321614)
Please study some history before you make claims like that. Have you seen any witches burned recently? Have 100K Japanese people on the west coast been put into camps recently?
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by billybob on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @05:37PM (#1322679)
Depends on how you define "recently." I think the idea that humans are getting smarter and nobler is hogwash. There were plenty of professional philosophers in Rome while the emperor was burning Christians on pikes as party candles. And Rome was certainly the pinnacle of civilization in its day.

The worst evils of the 20th century were done by people with lots of scientific, industrial and psychological knowledge propping them up. And the worst evils of the 21st century will be no different.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by india on Thursday May 06, 2010 @03:10AM (#1323789)
> I think the idea that humans are getting smarter and nobler is hogwash.

No, there is quite some evidence behind that idea[1].

[1] http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_of_violen...

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by chbarts on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @09:12PM (#1323215)
> I think the idea that humans are getting smarter and nobler is hogwash.

OK, find me a duel and a bear-baiting match in America and I'll believe you. Otherwise you're just mindlessly cynical, like any number of other teenagers.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by nl on Thursday May 06, 2010 @01:09AM (#1323630)
A Duel? UFC doesn't count? How about this, just from a quick search: http://current.com/news/92277104_a-near-fatal-shoot-out-betw....

You're probably right about bear-baiting. But there is plenty of organized dog fights and cock-fights around.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by roel_v on Thursday May 06, 2010 @07:39AM (#1324147)
UFC is not a duel in the traditional sense, nor is it 'violent' in the same way a war or aggravated assault is 'violent'. It's a technical sport (well UFC is a league of MMA fighters, where MMA is the sport) with well-defined rules designed to minimize damage to participants. Saying that the popularity of MMA shows that our society is getting more violent doesn't make sense, on the contrary - it's proof that we are able to channel primary urges to measure ourselves with our fellow humans in controlled and structured ways.

As for your link, an anecdote does not data make. If you want to argue that our society is getting more violent you need to prove that the amount of violent episodes now is higher than in the past, not that there happen violent events now. And as a matter of fact, overall in most of the Western world, the amount of violent crimes has been on a steady decline for the last 50 years at least (the amount of other crimes has gone down too, by the way).

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by slackerIII on Thursday May 06, 2010 @12:01PM (#1324706)
UFC is a lot less violent than boxing (and you simply haven't watched both if you claim otherwise), a sport that it is a rapidly displacing.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by Qz on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @08:22PM (#1323117)
Are you forgetting Darfur? North Korea? Iraq? Pervasive forced labor worldwide?

Maybe you should study some recent history. The list goes on an on.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by slackerIII on Thursday May 06, 2010 @12:00PM (#1324701)
Darfur, from wikipedia: "Sudanese authorities claim a death toll of roughly 19,500 civilians [72] while certain non-governmental organizations, such as the Coalition for International Justice, controversially claim that over 400,000 people have been killed.[73]"

Compare that to WWII: "Most suggest that some 60 million people died in the war, including about 20 million soldiers and 40 million civilian"

Looking at North Korea and Iraq, every single person in those countries could die and that still wouldn't exceed the body count from WWII, not to mention WWI or any of the truly pointless European conflicts before that.

Even comparing Iraq to Vietnam, do you know what that war did to that country? Millions and millions of civilians were killed, an order of magnitude worse than even the extreme estimates of Iraqi civilian deaths.

Forced labor worldwide? Slavery was legal in the US 150 years ago. Now it is not -- in fact, we just elected a black president.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by Qz on Thursday May 06, 2010 @09:17PM (#1326357)
I didn't compare any of those examples to all of WW2, but rather you rour example of the 100k japanese interned during WW2. And despite that, suffering can't be gauged merely on the number of people killed.

You said: "Have you seen any witches burned recently? Have 100K Japanese people on the west coast been put into camps recently?"

And my response was to indicate that tragedies like those are still happening in modern times, for very much the same reasons.

"Forced labor worldwide? Slavery was legal in the US 150 years ago. Now it is not -- in fact, we just elected a black president."

You response seems to have little to do with my point. Forced labor is a worldwide problem. Reciting US history to me does little to discredit that. I'd like to know what Obama has done recently to stop the sex trafficking of girls from Eastern Europe or Southeast Asia.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by chbarts on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @09:13PM (#1323218)
Are you insisting that Darfur and North Korea are representative of the world as a whole? Do you really have that little conception, child?
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by Qz on Thursday May 06, 2010 @09:18PM (#1326362)
They are representative of the state of the world in that we still allow them to go on. If you think your hands are clean in any of that, then you are sorely mistaken.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by chbarts on Thursday May 06, 2010 @10:29PM (#1326528)
> If you think your hands are clean in any of that, then you are sorely mistaken.

Oh yes, original sin. Wonderful. That makes sense. Can I buy some plenary indulgence from you, or is it a 'salvation by grace' thing now?

> They are representative of the state of the world in that we still allow them to go on.

The world once allowed the Black Plague and religions based on human sacrifice to 'go on', as you say. Darfur and North Korea are nothing compared to those.

Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by Qz on Friday May 07, 2010 @12:50AM (#1326742)
Wow, you have some serious distortion glasses on there. When did I say anything about original sin? And as for 'allowing' the Black Plague and human sacrifice to go on, that's an entirely different timeframe when the world wasn't globalized in the way it is now. At that time, people were isolated enough that direct social effects across societies were hugely limited. This isn't true now -- everything that goes on in the US directly affects the quality of life for people around the world, and vice versa. Any other poorly thought out responses you want to throw this way?
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by shaunxcode on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @11:48AM (#1321512)
and yet your comment was created on a machine built upon rational being used to communicate on a network built upon freedom. start? more like recognize and celebrate what has already happened whilst rejecting the birthing pains.
Re:Why Aren't There More Terrorist Attacks? by CWuestefeld on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:24PM (#1321635)
used to communicate on a network built upon freedom

Actually, it was built by the Department of Defense, aka The War Department. The freedom aspect was purely unintentional.

Indeed, I suppose that the reason that the best way to make the network robust results in making it free, creates an interesting analogy to the original point. At the very least, it proves that it's possible to be both more free and more secure, simultaneously.