To illustrate your point, Facebook censored the Pulitzer Prize-winning photo taken June 8, 1972 with crying children, including 9-year-old Kim Phuc, after an aerial napalm attack on suspected Viet Cong hiding places.
That photo violates a several of Facebook "ban" rules, but is an exception to the rules. After much outcry, Facebook reversed their rule-based ban.
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by tptacek on Sunday December 18, 2016 @09:40PM
(#13209141)
Yes, this happened, and yes, it's dumb, but so what? Who here thinks HN would end up with that policy?
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by rokosbasilisk on Sunday December 18, 2016 @09:45PM
(#13209159)
To be fair, Im sure the person who posted it on facebook might have thought something similar.
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by tptacek on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:34PM
(#13209526)
This seemed clever the first time I read it but now I'm not sure what it really says.
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by StavrosK on Monday December 19, 2016 @07:44AM
(#13211044)
It probably wouldn't end up with that specific policy, but I'm reasonably certain it would end up with a policy that would have comparable edge cases.
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by tptacek on Monday December 19, 2016 @10:22AM
(#13211923)
Why? What makes you certain of that? I'm not suggesting that Dan and Scott stop moderating, just that it's possible to make a clear, coherent statement about bigotry in the moderation guidelines.
Re:Facebook’s internal rules of deletion
by StavrosK on Monday December 19, 2016 @10:58AM
(#13212185)
My experience with moderating large communities and, mainly, my inability to define bigotry to any satisfactory degree. I certainly urge you to give it a go, maybe you'll be able to solve the problem for all of us.
Hell, I can't even ballpark where your freedom to speak ends and my freedom to not feel bad starts.
I think you were attracted to the improvement of writing rules down, but that has a host of other problems, including the fact that you are then forced to enforce the rules, even where they don't make sense (e.g. you have to remove some comment because of the letter of the law, even though it wasn't actually inflammatory, it just ran into an edge case).
I moderate(d) a large reddit community (millions of subscribers?) and you pretty much can't win. If you don't have rules, you're "murky" and "wanton". If you have rules, you get "these rules suck" or "you're only enforcing the rules whenever you feel like it" when you try to go by the spirit of the law rather than the letter.