News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by cperciva on Saturday December 17, 2016 @11:04PM (#13204272)
How do you define "popularity"? UNIX is found in many devices end users don't think of as being "computers" at all.

The best software is the software users don't even realize is there, because it just works.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by coldtea on Sunday December 18, 2016 @03:02AM (#13204835)
Well, the meaningful way for UNIX (and Linux) to succeed as a popular product, according to the aspirations of its proponents, was on the desktop. It wasn't just about the server side back then (late 90s, early 00s) it was all about taking over Windows.

If somebody uses some hardware product (e.g. set top box) and doesn't know its Linux, then it's no big win for the Linux community.

And it's not just necessarily that users don't realize it's there because "it just works", either.

The set top box, for example, can be buggy or crappy but just not provide neither a way to dive in and fix it, nor branding related to Linux.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by cperciva on Sunday December 18, 2016 @03:16AM (#13204874)
If somebody uses some hardware product (e.g. set top box) and doesn't know its Linux, then it's no big win for the Linux community.

I have to disagree there. It may not be a marketing win, but that doesn't mean that there are no other benefits. The fact that the PlayStation 4 runs FreeBSD has resulted in a large number of improvements becoming available to us; whether Johnny knows that his games are running on a daemonic operating system is of very little relevance.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by JonnieCache on Sunday December 18, 2016 @02:38PM (#13207192)
>The fact that the PlayStation 4 runs FreeBSD has resulted in a large number of improvements becoming available to us

Is there a writeup of this anywhere? If stuff has been backported/upstreamed/whatever from the PS4 to the freeBSD kernel that would truly be living the dream!

Re:How Unix made it to the top by cperciva on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:14PM (#13207675)
The fact that the PS4 runs FreeBSD has been written about extensively. The contributions they've made, less so... mainly because most of the work they did was before they announced that they were using FreeBSD, and they went to significant lengths to avoid that information leaking out (e.g., shell companies were set up so that code could be contributed without revealing the ultimate source).

Probably the most easily identifiable contributions are in LLVM; Sony is one of the largest contributors to that project, and it's entirely due to the PS4.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by pjmlp on Sunday December 18, 2016 @05:18PM (#13208042)
They talked a bit about it on their LLVM talks.

http://llvm.org/devmtg/2013-11/#talk8

Re:How Unix made it to the top by bluejekyll on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:30AM (#13206340)
> daemonic operating system

I've never seen someone refer to it like that before. Awesome.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by dTal on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:46AM (#13206411)
>the PlayStation 4 runs FreeBSD

wait, what?

Awesome.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by pmontra on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:13AM (#13205005)
The only successful desktop UNIX derivative is MacOS. That ship has sailed.

However the most relevant computing devices for consumers are phones and tablets nowadays, not desktops. UNIX derivatives run almost all of them. Big success, I'd say.

UNIX derivatives are running most servers too and are making inroads into the Windows desktop. The outlook is good unless a new popular market suddenly open with no meaningful *nix presence in it.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by xorcist on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:34AM (#13205056)
Chromebooks are very successful, outselling MacOS desktops in 2016. They run a pretty standard Linux environment.

I don't think anyone thought Linux to take over the office desktop by mass porting office applications but by moving them to the web. That shift is still happening.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by pjmlp on Sunday December 18, 2016 @06:36AM (#13205415)
Chromebooks provide access to the underlying Linux distribution, after doing a magic incantation that the common user doesn't have any idea about.

For the non geek audience, it is a browser based OS. Google could base it in something else, and none of them would notice it.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by coldtea on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:45AM (#13205091)
>Chromebooks are very successful, outselling MacOS desktops in 2016.

That's still products from multiple vendors (Dell, HP, and Lenovo, Asus?, etc) narrowingly beating sales from a single vendor.

And that (a) in a year when the single vendor had stalled updating their product line, and (b) with the Chromebooks being much cheaper, and more mass market, offerings.

So this speaks more to the slow sales of Chromebooks during the previous years than some major breakthrough.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by pmontra on Sunday December 18, 2016 @08:48AM (#13205796)
You're right, according to the the US stats I saw. I probably forgot about them because I never saw one (Italy here) or if I saw them I mistaken them for a Windows laptop. However I think I never heard the word Chromebook in a conversation, either work or friends. We could use a Chromebook everywhere we're connecting to the Internet with our laptops but apparently we're not.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by oneweekwonder on Sunday December 18, 2016 @09:55AM (#13205985)
Chromebooks like you mentioned is a Linux environment, a unix like clone. MacOS is a certified unix OS.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by dTal on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:52AM (#13206432)
It would be a bigger win if the success of Linux on mobile wasn't built on a heaping pile of GPL violations. It's all well and good that my phone runs Linux, but if I don't have Stallman's Four Freedoms on it and the device drivers aren't contributed back, what exactly is the point?

As for desktops, the market share still slowly creeps up. Desktop Linux has definitely graduated from "uber-nerd" to "power user" territory. Plenty of people I know who aren't particularly into Free Software, UNIX etc dual-boot Ubuntu.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by deaddodo on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:49AM (#13205103)
> UNIX is found in many devices end users don't think of as being "computers" at all.

No, Linux is.

http://kernelbook.sourceforge.net/pdf/ch-intro.pdf

Some devices run BSD derivatives, but I'd still hesitate to call those Unix vs derived from Unix.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by aap_ on Sunday December 18, 2016 @06:09AM (#13205346)
The name UNIX is just not well defined. Saying Linux is a UNIX is perfectly valid imo, but everyone has a different idea of what UNIX means.

That pdf btw has quite a few misconceptions about the history of UNIX.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by jamiesonbecker on Sunday December 18, 2016 @10:55AM (#13206186)
> The name UNIX is just not well defined. Saying Linux is a UNIX is perfectly valid imo, but everyone has a different idea of what UNIX means.

The trademark UNIX® and its specification is (still) tightly controlled[1] and licensing and compliance was far too expensive for Linus to think about it for his tiny Linux-like OS. (A Linux distribution did recently get certified as UNIX® but that's a recent exception.)

There have been multiple lawsuits between different companies about what could be considered UNIX. The original Linux distribution was basically GNU (GNU is NOT UNIX) utilities wrapped around a deliberately non-UNIX kernel called Linux.

Back when people were trying to explain Linux to UNIX users, it was called "UNIX-like" or a UNIX® clone. Now that Linux has clearly eclipsed UNIX, even now no one really calls Linux, "UNIX" or vice-versa. They are very similar but they are different.

There is also another specification called POSIX. Even Windows NT had a POSIX-compliant layer for a while, and Services for UNIX had some licensed IP, but no one would claim that Windows NT was UNIX.

See also Lisivka's comments [2] further down: Linux is not UNIX.

See also the Single UNIX Specification[3].

1. http://www.opengroup.org/subjectareas/platform/unix

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13204551

3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_UNIX_Specification

Re:How Unix made it to the top by aap_ on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:46AM (#13206405)
The SUS is irrelevant to this question, just like POSIX, which you mention yourself. Probably not a single version of UNIX from Bell Labs could be called UNIX by these definitions, which is silly. Of course they are UNIX, more so than any other operating system. So what makes an operating system a UNIX? Decide for yourself! UNIX != UNIX®
Re:How Unix made it to the top by pjmlp on Sunday December 18, 2016 @05:20PM (#13208053)
Of course they could, after all they are the genesis of such certification, at very least the v1.0 of it.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by aap_ on Monday December 19, 2016 @02:53AM (#13210117)
No. There's no way any Bell Labs UNIX could conform to either POSIX or SUS.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by AsyncAwait on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:24AM (#13206314)
I think Linux is perfectly UNIX in terms of userland and 'spirit', if you will. It's not UNIX officially, but that's because nobody bothered to pay for the licensing, since it's not worth it, not because it couldn't get certified as UNIX if somebody wanted to do it - in fact D. Ritchie himself said:

"I think the Linux phenomenon is quite delightful, because it draws so strongly on the basis that Unix provided. Linux seems to be among the healthiest of the direct Unix derivatives, though there are also the various BSD systems as well as the more official offerings from the workstation and mainframe manufacturers."

K. Thompson is also using Linux. I think that's the ultimate testament to it being 'Unix', unless you want the trademark for marketing purposes, like Apple does.

Re:How Unix made it to the top by aap_ on Sunday December 18, 2016 @11:46AM (#13206410)
Ken uses OS X.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by dekhn on Sunday December 18, 2016 @12:03PM (#13206485)
He also said he worked on the alpha version of Linux.
Re:How Unix made it to the top by AsyncAwait on Sunday December 18, 2016 @02:09PM (#13207071)
As per[1], "According to a 2009 interview, Thompson now uses a Linux-based operating system." He probably uses multiple systems, including macOS in some capacity, am sure, but it looks like he uses/used Linux.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Thompson

Re:How Unix made it to the top by aap_ on Sunday December 18, 2016 @02:28PM (#13207140)
I can't find the source right now but Russ Cox posted to some newsgroup or mailing list that most golang developers use OS X these days (rsc, rob and ken for sure).
Re:How Unix made it to the top by gkya on Sunday December 18, 2016 @07:47AM (#13205619)
This is an incredibly unnecessary nitpicking here.