News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @09:49PM (#13204046)
Your comment is the worst thing I've seen on HN in a while, and the users who upvoted it should re-read the site guidelines and send themselves to bed without supper. If you want to destroy this community completely, you couldn't pick a much better device.

It should be obvious that smearing another user like this is a bannable offense here, regardless of how wrong you think they are. It poisons the discourse while purporting to defend it, for obviously political reasons of its own. That's unacceptable, even in a thread as thoroughly degraded as this one. Please don't do anything like this on HN.

If you look, you'll notice that I scolded the other user as well for abusing HN for pure politics. That is a bannable offense too. Instead of both sides breaking HN's rules and going at each other, I have a suggestion: neither of you do it.

I am sorely tempted to ban you both to set an example, but on principle we try to warn people first—it's hard to ask users to give each other the benefit of the doubt if we don't do it ourselves. But I can't say steam isn't coming out of my ears right now.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13202383 and marked it off-topic.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by westiseast on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:53PM (#13204228)
I'm cool with that to be honest.

I'd kinda suggest as mods that either (a) just outright stop/ban these kind of political and/or China focused posts, or (b) adopt hardcore moderation if and when they rear their heads.

I comment regularly on China related issues in other forums, and it's pretty boring watching any debate related to China get the same treatment by pro-China commenters. At least in my eyes, an 'ad hominem' attack or callout of 'wumao' style commenting like mine is part and parcel of pro-China commenters hijacking debates about China with endless comparisons to the US and blatant equivocism and falsehoods - i.e. I don't think you can allow one and not end up with the other. HN maintains high standards of debate and behaviour which perhaps aren't compatible with this kind of polarized debate.

All the best :)