News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by krapp on Saturday December 17, 2016 @06:43PM (#13203431)
Please don't accuse people of commenting in bad faith. It only poisons the well of discussion and breeds paranoia and suspicion, and political threads are too toxic around here as it is.

Attack the message, not the messenger.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by westiseast on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:01PM (#13203494)
Agreed. My point is kind of that China has been poisoning the well for years by employing paid commenters and schills to parrot the exact same arguments. And then when anyone points this out, they're accused of poisoning the debate :)

This guy is entitled to his opinions, but unfortunately the entire pro-China position is untrustworthy because of this (ref my previous comment).

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by krapp on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:35PM (#13203635)
>And then when anyone points this out, they're accused of poisoning the debate :)

Because they do.

If you're wrong, you're doing their work for them by sowing discord and mistrust in the community. If you're right, you're doing their work for them by distracting from the subject and making the thread about the threat of the enemy within. The one thing you probably won't accomplish is getting them to stop.

The only way to win the game is not to play by their rules, and to not make it personal. If you really believe someone is a shill, report it to the admins, they claim to take this sort of thing seriously.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by xnull2guest on Saturday December 17, 2016 @08:08PM (#13203765)
Please report this to the moderators (I looked but don't know how), as I would like to be vindicated.

There's a downvote brigade on my posts right now and anything I want to contribute gets detailed into accusations of my being some kind of agent.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by justicezyx on Saturday December 17, 2016 @11:46PM (#13204380)
> has been poisoning the well for years by employing paid commenters and schills to parrot the exact same arguments.

What do you mean? Are you saying Chinese government paid people in US to do propaganda for the sake of Chinese leaders? I do not think that's any surprising. You should expect any country to do something to influence their competitors or enemies alike.

But you seem imply that the poster you accused was connected with Chinese government. You should not automatically link the government activity with personal behavior on HN. If there is an factual link between the poster's comments and government sponsorship, then go for it, expose the facts. The tactic of someone behaving pro-China, is certainly a "wu mao", is nothing better than claiming one is a traitor on the ground that he accused US govenment's any wrongdoing.

Could you elaborate?

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by westiseast on Sunday December 18, 2016 @12:48AM (#13204549)
Sure. Sorry for length of this then...

In my head at least, I'm not accusing this guy specifically of being a paid commenter or operative or agent. I have no evidence of that. I feel like its actually irrelevant whether he's paid or genuine.

I'm saying that the content of his comments, the tone of the answers and the rhetorical techniques are basically the same as those seen in hundreds of threads about China where genuine discussion gets derailed by pro-CCP commenters. IMO, genuine discussion about China is difficult/impossible unless there's a recognition and backlash against the poor quality of pro-CCP comments. Eg:

He brings up the USA immediately and repeatedly on a post about China (whataboutism). The underlying message is consistently 'the USA is worse. The USA is the same. If the USA does it, why are you attacking China instead of looking after your own problems?'

He immediately claims the original article is blatant propaganda rather than discussing it earnestly. Similarly, he claims everyone else is living in a media bubble and their sources are not trustworthy (Economist, NYT, 'western media'). He doesn't really mention any news sources of his own that might indicate his own 'media bubble'.

He writes fairly frequent outright lies ("[China] are in and have not been in wars, are leaders of the UN peacekeeping forces, and do not militarily interfere in other countries' affairs") which can be fairly easily destroyed if you can use Google.

To my eyes, a thread about China has pretty quickly become a quagmire of multiple complex and subjective situations related to China, where mud and suspicion is being thrown on everyone, and any opinion anyone projects that might be anti-China is cast as subjective, biased, unresearched etc.

Generally speaking, anywhere you go on the internet where people discuss China-related issues publicly end up like this. Same goes for a lot of Russia related issues discussed in English. I'm sure if you are reading the Arabic internet and bump into issues that the US paid-commenting/auto-commenting systems are interested in, it's the same thing. It's a specific goal of government-sponsored commenting campaigns that you don't try to win arguments; you just muddy the waters, make everyone sound unreliable, destroy reasonable debate.

It's a sticky situation. To my mind, the comments that user posted were immediate red flags. I don't think a single one of his comments added to the substantive debate about the original article. Mine didn't either; it was a stupid response to the poor quality of his comments. Oh well...

[dead]
Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:14PM (#13204117)
No, the political threads are toxic because politics itself is toxic by HN's definition: it makes civil, substantive discussion impossible. That's the raison d'etre of this site, and we ban accounts that don't use the site as intended.

Using a phrase like "these operatives" without evidence is itself abusive. Accusations of astroturfing and shillage are a dime a dozen, and people aren't allowed to sling them around on HN. If you have genuine evidence of abusive behavior, please email [email protected] so we can look into it. Invoking it as an argument tactic or a drive-by smear is not legit.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by FrancoDiaz on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:21PM (#13204133)
You've already pointed out the abusive behavior by the guy and you're fully aware of these tactics, so why the call for an email?

This stuff happens everyday. And if politics is toxic, then why not go back to the no politics rule permanently? Or if it's so toxic then just make it a free-for-all.

Nothing changes. Are there plans to make changes?

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:58PM (#13204249)
Because there's more than one problem here: (a) a small amount of genuine abuse, and (b) a large amount of users lazily smearing one another, drawing on nothing but their own imagination.

If there's actual abuse going on, obviously we need to know about it. We take such reports seriously, and on rare occasions find something. But I can tell you from long experience that there's almost never any there there—just people getting mad at each other and breaking HN's civility rule in a particularly smug way. This behavior is most common from accounts whose comments are generally unsubstantive.

The changes we're going to make are (a) adding the rule that you can't accuse other users of astroturfing or shilling without evidence—and an opposing opinion is not evidence, and (b) banning users who do it.

Just because some accounts abuse the site doesn't mean that other accounts get to sling uncivil accusations. That's an abuse in its own right and does more damage.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by xnull2guest on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:45PM (#13203681)
Great. Let's call a moderator in here.
Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @09:55PM (#13204067)
You've been using HN for nothing but political arguments for a long time now. That's an abuse of this site, and we ban accounts that do it. It's time this stopped, so please stop.

Other users have been abusive, and I'm scolding them too. But HN isn't a primarily political site, so please ply this stuff elsewhere, not here.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by xnull2guest on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:52PM (#13204223)
Thank you dang. This will happen.

More and more, social media platforms have been telling me - or using their algorithms to tell me - that my opinions, as educated and well argued as they are, are not welcome on their sites.

I did not expect to see this from Hacker News. Indeed, after the experiment banning political conversation, I had thought that the opposite decision had been made.

And finally, to be clear, I use HN for far more than political chatter. I read the technical content, and use it as a general news feed (one of my many). I comment where I am inspired to. I did not realize how often that ends up being of a political nature. I care deeply about individual freedoms and the technology that enables and disables these.

Can we find a mechanism whereby my nationality is confirmed? I would like to do this for the sake of my own vindication, as well as clarity to those who were/are suspicious.

Re:The worrying implications of China's social-credit project by dang on Sunday December 18, 2016 @12:02AM (#13204428)
We don't need to confirm your nationality. The people bringing that up had no basis for doing so.

Please use HN as intended from now on.