Do I need to read more than 10 sentences before getting to this part of the article?
The overseas edition of The People’s Daily, the Communist Party’s flagship newspaper, said on its social media account Saturday night that the Chinese capture of the drone was legal because rules about drone activities had not been clearly written. “This is the gray area,” the newspaper said. “If the U.S. military can send the drone, surely China can seize it.”
In its statement, the Defense Ministry scolded the United States over what it called its longstanding practice of conducting “close-in reconnaissance and military surveys” in waters claimed by China.
It's true that quote is in the last half of the article, but it seems to provide the context that you say is missing, or do you think the article should be several times longer?
It's a glaring editorial error to present a dispute as being concluded with your own opinion. That's what the Times has done. Whether its readership is aware of it or not.
I furthermore disagree with the assertion that the average Times reader is no doubt familiar with the context.
I find it troubling you present the context improperly yourself (China v. UNCLOS) in writing your opinion here.
Disputes are fractal. Any summary will be incomplete to some observer.
The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, to which China is a party (but the United States is not) [1], ruled with the Philippines on the South China Sea's territoriality being drawn by UNCLOS rules. Others in the region disputing China's claims take similar positions [2]. The UUV was seized closer to the Philippine shore than to mainland China.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Convention_on_t...
[2] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/India-and-Indonesia...
http://www.un.org/Depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/uncl...
Article 298 limitedly exempts Section 2. This makes sense because the purpose of UNCLOS is to settle maritime territoriality disputes.
See §§ 397 - 412 of the ruling [1] for the Tribunal's reasons Article 298 does not apply to many salient pieces of the Philippines' case, including those pertaining to "Scarborough Shoal" (§ 400), "Mischief Reef, Second Thomas Shoal, or Subi Reef" (§ 401) and others.
[1] http://www.pcacases.com/web/sendAttach/1506 page 140
It's unfortunately going to take a few days to read this in full.
Ultimately, international law is a convenient fiction. South China Sea territoriality will be decided by the United States weighing the benefits of freedom of navigation against the cost of enforcing UNCLOS boundaries with force. Sending drones and forcing them to be returned is less risky (and less effective) than piloting manned ships through the area.
They used to be a legitimate news organization and I agree with parent post.
If their claims go that far, that seems almost absurd.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_disputes_in_the_So... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nine-Dash_Line
The point I was making is that across US broadcasting, there has been an attempt to associate the geography "South China Sea" with the term "International Waters."
Thus, international waters.
The long and short? The Qing Dynasty had territory over these islands before WWII. It was never a powerful naval power. The Japanese took them and more during WWII. The US (San Fran Conference, Cairo Conference, Potsdam Conference) demanded the Japanese remove themselves from these islands (including Spratlys, Paracels), and give islands back to China (including, notably, Taiwan). China, during the Cold War, traded some ownership back and forth with Vietnam of Pacific islands in SCS in order to avoid their being involved in Cold War disputes.
Now China is seeking, for National Security purposes, to build infrastructure (including civilian, rescue, emergency response, shipping and military) on these islands. The United States sees this as area access/area denial - it could be denied the ability to project naval power into this area. The Chinese want to be able to protect naval trade, and protect themselves from their historical vulnerability (embargo).
US has tried multiple ways to prevent or slow this project. A recent effort to get the Philippines to contest the waters failed when the Philippines backed off of their claim.
Western reporting likes to present the South China Sea as a consensus, but it's not. It's been very difficult for the United States to get Asian Countries - those involved in the area - to side with the United States about the waters and their future.
UNCLOS ruled in favour of the Philippines. The Philippines are not willing to enforce their claim against an emerging regional hegemony. That's different from backing off.
> The Chinese want to be able to protect naval trade, and protect themselves from their historical vulnerability (embargo)
This is a fair thing to want, but it conflicts with neighbouring states' claimed rights to freedom of navigation. It is in the United States' and China's neighbors' interests to prevent China from achieving regional naval hegemony. Presenting this morally just serves to confuse the issue.
> It's been very difficult for the United States to get Asian Countries - those involved in the area - to side with the United States
India and Indonesia, amongst others, have supported the ruling [1].
[1][ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/India-and-Indonesia...
http://www.un.org/Depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/uncl...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13203195
[2] http://www.pcacases.com/web/sendAttach/1506 §§ 397 - 412
There's also an attempt by China to associate the geography "Taiwan" with "China", when it's obviously a separate country.
We're back to pretending opinions are facts, are we?
> There's also an attempt by China to associate the geography "Taiwan" with "China", when it's obviously a separate country.
Interestingly here, Taiwan's constitution and official policy does not claim there are two Chinese states. The United States and world consensus also recognizes the People's Republic of China as a government, but not Taiwan.
Do you explicitly disagree with ROC, PRC and the US about the status of Taiwan as a separate country?
It was Iraqi opinion that they were winning the war. It was US opinion that the US was winning the war. One of those was a fact and the other wasn't.
Technically Crimea belongs to Ukraine and most of the world acknowledges this.
But in all practical realty--de facto--Crimea is now Russian territory. It's not foolish to acknowledge this.
Yes, for the same reasons the "Indian Ocean" isn't India's territory.
Personally, I find it very understandable when two countries or cultures have differing viewpoints about what's right or not. However, I think it's imperative for their integrity to accept rules and international courts if you sign up for it. Many countries have been culpable of such incidents, and they're always in the wrong for unilaterally breaking such agreements. This time, it's China doing so. Don't sign up for common rules if you don't intend on following them.
Sure there are propaganda and opinions everywhere, but the question of integrity and ethics is clear in this example.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/04/25/pentagon-russian-... https://www.rt.com/usa/russian-nuclear-sub-gertz-097/
The US response was:
> "We respect the freedom of all nations, as reflected in international law, to operate military vessels beyond the territorial seas of other nations."
Here are reports of Russian plans and ships patrolling the Californian coast in 2014:
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/russia-jets-fly-to-california-co...
Only by some divine Providence. Or this guy:
Vasili Arkhipov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasili_Arkhipov
Thank you Vasili Arkhipov, the man who stopped nuclear war https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/oct/27/vasili...
You (and Almost Everyone You Know) Owe Your Life to This Man. http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2016/03/25/you-and-a...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S.%E2%80%93Soviet_Incidents_...
The sub was seized something like 50 miles from Subic Bay in the Philippines. In international waters. A long way from the coast of China.
So it would be more like a Russian sub cruising around Venezuela or something.
One of the crucial aspects to understanding the South China Sea situation is the dispute of the sovereignty of the waters. The New York Times doesn't provide context on the sovereignty disputes, or provide the Chinese argument. Instead misleads its readership by quoting "international waters in the South China Sea."
This is an editorial error of enormous magnitude affecting the quality of the publication. An non politicized publication would write "disputed waters in the South China Sea."
Indeed, you can read back only a couple of years where US media reporting did exactly this. The recent propaganda push inside US media has been to use the term "international waters" in association with the geography to affect public opinion.