Re:The Myth of the Underachieving Genius
by jacquesm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @11:01PM
(#1320203)
I don't know. My brother and me are a nice case study, of course that's just one more anecdote and not exactly science but still. People said that I would go to university and do all kinds of stuff, nobody paid much attention to Maurice. But he was the one to end up going to university, I dropped out in high school.
Family circumstances at the time had a lot to do with all this, but still, he's the one with the degree in history and I only have a typing diploma and a driving license as my 'educational record'.
Better grades or lower grades doesn't enter in to it.
The educational system works well if you're in the middle of the pack, if you are at one or the other extreme you have a problem.
I'm not sure if a university degree would have helped me in any way, I'll never know and I'm resigned to that.
But I do know that there is more to school than 'subject knowledge', and that in my dealings with people I could have benefited from a deeper immersion in to social structures and how to deal with all kinds of situations.
See my post the other day about my past mistakes, I'm pretty sure a few of those are rooted in my checkered history. I wouldn't trade my life for any other, and in the hiring policies of my company I always tried to look past the grades and to the person behind them and their motivation.
If I got the feeling they wanted to move ahead in life then that was usually the deciding factor, and for the most part they did not disappoint me, even the ones with good grades ;)
Family circumstances at the time had a lot to do with all this, but still, he's the one with the degree in history and I only have a typing diploma and a driving license as my 'educational record'.
Better grades or lower grades doesn't enter in to it.
The educational system works well if you're in the middle of the pack, if you are at one or the other extreme you have a problem.
I'm not sure if a university degree would have helped me in any way, I'll never know and I'm resigned to that.
But I do know that there is more to school than 'subject knowledge', and that in my dealings with people I could have benefited from a deeper immersion in to social structures and how to deal with all kinds of situations.
See my post the other day about my past mistakes, I'm pretty sure a few of those are rooted in my checkered history. I wouldn't trade my life for any other, and in the hiring policies of my company I always tried to look past the grades and to the person behind them and their motivation.
If I got the feeling they wanted to move ahead in life then that was usually the deciding factor, and for the most part they did not disappoint me, even the ones with good grades ;)