Family circumstances at the time had a lot to do with all this, but still, he's the one with the degree in history and I only have a typing diploma and a driving license as my 'educational record'.
Better grades or lower grades doesn't enter in to it.
The educational system works well if you're in the middle of the pack, if you are at one or the other extreme you have a problem.
I'm not sure if a university degree would have helped me in any way, I'll never know and I'm resigned to that.
But I do know that there is more to school than 'subject knowledge', and that in my dealings with people I could have benefited from a deeper immersion in to social structures and how to deal with all kinds of situations.
See my post the other day about my past mistakes, I'm pretty sure a few of those are rooted in my checkered history. I wouldn't trade my life for any other, and in the hiring policies of my company I always tried to look past the grades and to the person behind them and their motivation.
If I got the feeling they wanted to move ahead in life then that was usually the deciding factor, and for the most part they did not disappoint me, even the ones with good grades ;)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1028272
There's some one arguing just that. While I don't see it a lot I have certainly seen the point argued, generally right beside some one claiming Einstein was bad at math.
You could have less than stellar grades, but may have something else to show your ability (side projects or what not).
On the other hand, a high GPA might only demonstrate your mastery of bulimic studying; Memorize and regurgitate.
The American education system teaches its bright students to game the system. Then they go to work for Enron or Goldman-Sachs, and game the system.
I've lived my life viewing the world through a peculiarly British narrative. Upper class twits preside over a broken system with perverse incentives. Why doesn't it fail? Partly because of the plucky grammar school boy who grows up to occupy a key technocrat role and who heroically resists the lure of perverse incentives and does the right thing. Partly because of the inherent decency and solidarity of the working class, who will not shaft each other even if the system pays them to.
So the American experience, in which mainstream people are always looking for an angle and a way to game the system, seems quite alien to me. Duh! It is the way they have been brought up.
I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not. Why are you romanticising the working class? Personally speaking, the breadth of my family oddly encompasses the upper and lower classes, and after being close to all of them over the years I can tell you there is nothing inherently wrong or right about a specific class. Some of the most admirable people I have met you would label as "upper class twits," and likewise there are others from more humble backgrounds that you would point to as evidence of an exclusive core of decency within the lower classes.
In summary, good and bad people exist in the same proportions in every arbitrary class we would wish to create.
Well, the average working class person doesn't have the means to gain from the system in that way. So when they decide to cheat, they do so in more basic ways, like becoming burglars, thieves, dodgy tradesmen, and other kinds of low-level career criminals.
I don't buy your romantic view of "the decency and solidarity of the working class". People in all walks of life are decent - with, always, a small percentage who are not so decent. That's as true of the "working class" as of other classes, if you want to make that split.
With the possible exception of lawyers and politicians of course.
True in principle, but since when did low/mediocre grades become associated with "falling behind"?
I think that's the cognitive disconnect between the two camps - the pro-academic crowd sees poor grades as a general failure, the rest of us do not.
Addressing the article directly:
> "Those who get good grades are the ultimate survivors."
That's awfully generous, if not quite self-congratulatory. As a staunch believer in the disconnect between academic achievement and real programming competence, I would suggest that the comment is true - but you've survived an arbitrary system constructed to achieve very little. It's a little bit like finding your way out of a garden maze - amusing and interesting perhaps, probably difficult, but the relation of this accomplishment to anything else is hazy.
> "They enter an environment, evaluate it critically to figure out what skills they need to succeed and thrive in said environment."
Perhaps - but assuming the goal is to be a great programmer (or whatever else your passion may be), why would you spend all your time and effort defeating this arbitrary system as opposed to pursuing things that actually make you a better programmer? (or carpenter, or doctor, or what-have-you).
That's the disconnect that I see. Academic performance is measured in such a way that doesn't shed light on real ability, and in fact much of the curriculum for a lot of degrees/certificates bear little relevance to the job they supposedly train for. Beating this system is IMHO meaningless, since it contributes little to your professional abilities.
Which is also why I think the medciore grades sometimes get a lot of love - I know more than a few people who eschewed academia in exchange for actually getting their hands dirty and writing a lot of code. They learned what they needed to learn from school, and spent the rest of the time perfecting their craft instead. IMHO these people make stronger programmers than those who spent their time and effort optimizing for something that isn't their end goal.
When I was in college, I knew a few people who were hardcore academics. They hit the books really hard, got great grades, aced exams regularly, and generally were kicking ass. What they were not doing was developing their professional abilities - so they graduated with little to no practical experience under their belt. They were rudely surprised when their intensely deep knowledge of a great number of theories weren't at all attractive to employers who needed people to get things done.
I also knew this one guy who was academic and spent a lot of time honing his real, executable skills. He's a superstar.
Given that, I would say that the real discerning variable here is how much practice you've had at programming - the variable of academic achievements is really largely independent from competence as a hacker.
> "there is nothing that stops a high achiever from being a passionate, free-thinking, risk-taker"
I would agree with this point with some caveats, but this comment strikes me as particularly arrogant:
> "good grades make better anything"
Really man, really? Wow, thanks for reinforcing the ivory-tower holier-than-thou stereotype that academics surely must love having.
[edit] At the risk of being inflammatory, a lot of this "high grades make better everything" hubbub seems like sour grapes from people who optimized for the wrong variable, and are now frustrated that the "losers" from before have become the winners (insofar as employment goes anyhow), and that the variable they were taught to religiously optimize turned out to be a bit pointless (for the purposes of employment, anyhow).
And yes, while we were still close, I had to deal with a lot of resentment along the way. I heard all kinds of nasty things about how I 'magically' became successful after years of lackluster academic performance.
It's silly to say people who do well in school are flawed or are wasting their energy. I think there are many compelling reasons to do well in school. But in my experience there is a sense of entitlement that develops along the way that often leads to a lot of friction and disappointment down the road.
Also, after years of hiring and training people, I firmly believe that grades do not predict ability in any meaningful way.
I think the prevailing sentiment is that it's a poor filter to simply disregard those that didn't do well in school -- the idea is not to abandon high-GPA students for lower-GPA students, but to consider both.