News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by mschuster91 on Saturday December 17, 2016 @06:49AM (#13200333)
Please not. The problem is that railway cars, track fees etc. are the same for all operators (buying/renting railway cars may actually be more expensive for smaller operators due to lack of volume), so the only way to save costs (and thus be able to operate at a lower price than incumbents) is saving on employees (aka wage dumping) or safety/maintenance.

Neither is good for society.

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by jpatokal on Saturday December 17, 2016 @04:35PM (#13202782)
Yup, which is why airplane safety has gone down the toilet and prices have skyrocketed since that market was liberalised... oh wait, they haven't.

Trains are admittedly more complicated because tracks need maintenance, and it's easy to screw up the operating model (see: UK), but if we can solve this for air traffic control and airports, it shouldn't be too hard for track either

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by smhg on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:18AM (#13200441)
I was thinking about this for a second. Specifically about saving on employees.

I guess it is safe to assume on-board jobs don't have a bright future. Those are up for automation.

So maintenance staff remains? But can't that be a separate entity? Just like with cars? That might solve the safety issue too. One has a bad rep? You go to another.

It's just that one public operator doesn't seem to work well either (lots of issues in countries with those too).

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by Symbiote on Saturday December 17, 2016 @12:51PM (#13201600)
Track and signal maintenance is a separate, public entity in the UK ("Network Rail"), with trains owned by the banks, and leased to companies that run services, like Virgin (yes, that Virgin) or Southern.

In the 1990s, the track and signals were maintained by Railtrack, a private company, but that caused several bad accidents. Since Network Rail took over, the British railway network has become one of the safest in the world -- I don't think a passenger on a train has been killed for a decade, and only a very small number (2?) of maintenance staff.

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by smhg on Saturday December 17, 2016 @05:53PM (#13203196)
Yes, it sounds hard to create competition for track and signal maintenance.

But the parent was talking about the companies that run the trains. I meant the maintenance those trains need (repairs/safety/cleaning/...). On that level competition might make more sense (like with cars). So they wouldn't do that in-house. Maybe it already works like this?

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by Symbiote on Sunday December 18, 2016 @04:55PM (#13207900)
In Britain, that's all done privately.

I think the only exception is the maintenance of London Underground trains, and possibly cleaning. eVen the other publicly owned railways in London contract out cleaning and maintenance.

Re:Germany's New Crowdfunded Train by crdoconnor on Saturday December 17, 2016 @01:29PM (#13201744)
>I guess it is safe to assume on-board jobs don't have a bright future. Those are up for automation.

If neoliberals really believed the "magic robots are coming to steal everybody's job" story they're pushing they'd not have a problem with raising public spending. Automation is inherently deflationary and the more of a 'danger' it is to jobs the larger the deflationary impact it will have.

You'll notice that they're still scaremongering about inflation, recommending against increasing infrastructure spending and blaming the lack of jobs on magic robots rather than austerity.