News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by BugsJustFindMe on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:59PM (#13195245)
Background: I used to work on these UUVs.

When CNN says "oceanographic research", what they actually mean is building a sonar ray caustics model of the environment, because sound bends just like light does when the medium transmission speed changes, and the speed of sound in water changes noticably with depth,salinity,temperature.

When CNN says "unclear motivation", what they mean is that the motivation is actually pretty clear. China doesn't like that the US is building underwater surveillance infrastructure in their backyard.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:23PM (#13195420)
The fact that this has military applications as well as scientific/commercial ones doesn't bother me. They were firmly in international rather than disputed waters, I'm pretty sure other countries eyeball our ocean shelf too and it doesn't bother me either.

To be honest I don't think China cares all that much either because they're used to the US Navy sailing about as a reminder of our treaties with various other SE Asian countries. They're veen assertive about their territorial claims with the nine-dash line, the building of artificial islands (reportedly now weaponized), and rejecting the decision of the international maritime court recently. Overall I'd characterize relations between the Chinese government and the Obama administration as cool but respectful.

I don't know what's happening with the incoming administration and don't want to make a political argument here, but I do think that publicizing the fact of the conversation between Trump and the Taiwanese President, along with the public questioning of the One China policy, probably seems like a huge loss of face for Beijing. China doesn't mind the US having relations, even friendship, with Taiwan - through private channels. Public recognition of the Taiwanese government as a sovereign entity by the US is insulting though - much as if Premier Xi in China started having friendly chats with the governor of Hawai'i or Alaska while publicly pouring scorn on DC.

Edit: great username btw

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by lacampbell on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:54PM (#13196204)
China doesn't mind the US having relations, even friendship, with Taiwan - through private channels. Public recognition of the Taiwanese government as a sovereign entity by the US is insulting though - much as if Premier Xi in China started having friendly chats with the governor of Hawai'i or Alaska while publicly pouring scorn on DC.

Except that is not analogous at all.

Taiwan is de facto Independent. It has its own currency, internationally recognised passports, military, airspace and democratically elects its own representatives. It has been de facto independent from China for almost 70 years. It never fell to maoism and as a result was spared the both the great famine (Which killed more people than the Chinese civil war and Japanese invasion combined) and the cultural revolution. It peacefully transitioned to democracy over 20 years ago, around the time Chinese troops were killing hundreds of civillians in Tian Nan Men square.

It is independent for all intents and purposes. Even PRC nationalists know this, but they need to keep face by not admitting the truth.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by Analemma_ on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:43PM (#13196603)
I have several close friends from Taiwan, and visit Taipei every couple years. When I go, just for kicks I always ask people how they feel about being part of China. The answer has, invariably, been not just No, but an irritated hell no. As you say, for all practical purposes Taiwan is independent- not just in their government institutions but in the psychology of the populace: they feel like a separate country, and nothing the PRC does can change that any more than Americans could be convinced to "reunify" with the United Kingdom.

China is kidding themselves if they think reunification is going to happen. It's certainly not going to happen voluntarily. And yeah, maybe they could take the island by force, but even if they managed it and it didn't trigger an international conflict, they'd just end up being another US-in-Vietnam/Soviets-in-Afghanistan situation: a forced occupation of an angry, resentful local population, which has no possible outcome other than eventual costly withdrawal.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:41PM (#13197554)
That hasn't stopped them in Tibet. The fact that Taiwan is a smallish island simplifies matters considerably, since China can easily impose a naval blockade and wait for rebels to run out of munitions. Agreed it would work out badly over the long term but strategically it's not hard.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:28PM (#13197476)
I'm not arguing that Hawai'i is similar to Taiwan. I'm saying that China holding friendly top-level conversations with the governor of a state while simultaneously refusing dialogue with the federal government is the only thing I can think of that would result in a similar loss of face (degree of political embarrassment) for the USA.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by sweetjesus on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:34PM (#13195524)
> is insulting much as if Premier Xi in China started having friendly chats with the governor of Hawai'i or Alaska while publicly pouring scorn on DC

speaking somewhat loosely, actually there is no "much as if" in this sense. The Chinese have a "face saving is the most important thing" culture, and the US does not. Think of it more like the tribal regions of the -stans: China is metaphorically ready to do some honor killing over this in a way we can't grok. Doesn't mean we should acquiesce of course. I'd perhaps make the analogy that everybody in the Chinese government is as thin skinned as Trump. (I'm exaggerating to make analogies here, no need to jump all over me, of course it's more nuanced.) Meanwhile, our neighboring Mexican politicians publically pour scorn on the US all the time and it doesn't particularly affect our relations (not sure if Trump can take it tho)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_(sociological_concept)

In any case, it would not actually bother the US all that much if China talked to Hawaii, nor does it bother US that China talks to the Philippines; it would be to our benefit if China and the Philippines resolved their differences mutually, and the same with Taiwan; it does bother US that the Philippines would make short-sighted unwise bargains inasmuch as we get the sense that we will be involved in cleaning up the mess later, and inasmuch as it reinforces China's belief that they should throw their weight around more WRT the Biển Đông (the East Sea, off the coast of Vietnam;)

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by gumby on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:19PM (#13195918)
> The Chinese have a "face saving is the most important thing" culture, and the US does not. Think of it more like the tribal regions of the -stans: China is metaphorically ready to do some honor killing over this in a way we can't grok.

Please, can we ditch the outdated stereotypes? The Chinese govt uses the parallel tropes to the US ("we've suffered under years of foreign domination" "Here we're on an anti-corruption campaign so you don't have to suffer under unnecessary taxes" etc. And funding local SoEs to keep the jobs flowing).

Is make America Great Again any different? "Other countries are laughing at us." "We never win any more""We're going to bring back coal"

I just picked MAGA because it was a recent successful platform. But consider dispassionately: 15 years ago a small bunch of bandits killed 3000 people and cause a few billion in property damage. IN return the US has spent trillions killing people who had nothing to do with it in order to to restore its honor. Movies from Rambo to Shooter to anything by Chuck Norris are simply ways to pander to loss of face.

Of course there are differences between the two but let's stick to facts.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by lacampbell on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:59PM (#13196237)
It's not an outdated stereotype. There are fundamental differences between eastern and western cultures. Individualistic vs collectivist, guilt based vs shame based.

The very fact that English has the expression "Lose Face" is because it was translated from Chinese and imported into the language in the 19th century[0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_(sociological_concept)#En...

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by fjdlwlv on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:09PM (#13196870)
You should look up what the movie Rambo is actually about. It's an interesting and important story.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by gumby on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:28PM (#13197027)
That's really my point in those examples: Rambo and Shooter have an explicit story that ties to a particular individualistic-in-group-context narrative, but they also rest upon an underlying group identification and sense of group shame. Shooter is interesting in that I don't feel race plays any role in the group, except through the use of an "outside mercenary"
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:14PM (#13195874)
My in-laws are Vietnamese-Chinese so I'm painfully aware of how upsetting a perceived loss of face can be.

I would say, though, that there's a big difference between Hawai'i and the Phillipines. The latter is a treaty partner of the US but that's still something less than being territory. (Of course many Hawai'ian people would rather go back to being a sovereign nation but I don't want to veer far off topic.)

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by gcb0 on Friday December 16, 2016 @08:23PM (#13198516)
i doubt very much that this has never happened before. but the Pentagon just write it off. like it did when losing planes over usrr.

the political statement is that this time they issued a press release to let everyone know about it.

China haven't changed how they react to the usa, regardless of adminstration. How the Pentagon behave, have changed.

now the million dollar question is why.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by vtange on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:39PM (#13195562)
All this talk about "China/America/Russia"'s backyard makes me feel like we are returning to the days of feuding empires where the little countries don't matter. I guess big countries deserve big backyards and there's no such thing as Vietnam's backyard, or Mexico's backyard, or Sweden's backyard etc.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:45PM (#13196122)
We are; it's very clear that the world is tilting back towards power politics rather than multilateralism and cooperation.

Actually, Vietnam has been asserting its territorial rights in an increasingly sour dispute with China - but it's not reported on as much, because Vietnam is a smaller country. All sovereign countries are equal in some sense as being distinct entities whose existence is recognized by each other, which is a fine principle. but in terms of economic and military affairs size matters and thus the disposition of the largest countries captures most of the attention.

Think of the world like a zoo, all the different enclosures let you see a wide variety of animals. In nature, some of these animals share the ecosystem with each, others would never meet, such as kangaroos and camels. Now, if you opened all the enclosures and just let the animals go free inside the zoo, it's safe to predict that the elephants, rhinoceros, lions, and tigers will will shape things more (at the outset; over generations in a sufficiently large zoo results may vary) than coyotes, llamas, zebra, and camels. All the animals I've mentioned are optimized for different roles in different environments but some are better equipped to handle confrontation than others. I use the analogy of the zoo because it's small, like the planet as communications and transport technology have reduced epic journeys to a logistical operation. We're effectively walled in with much less psychic and transitional distance between us than there used to be.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jdietrich on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:18PM (#13196400)
> it's very clear that the world is tilting back towards power politics rather than multilateralism and cooperation.

We never had multilateralism and cooperation. It seemed that way to the US, in the narrow window between the fall of the Soviet Union and the rise of China and Putin. The world seems very cooperative when you're the only superpower standing. We're not seeing a fundamental change in the nature of global politics, just the diminishing power of the US.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by blackflame7000 on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:44PM (#13197157)
Very true. You can't have multilateralism and cooperation when no one else is even on your level. Its like cooperating on a software project where only one person knows anything about programming; its very one sided. We are simply seeing the effect of 12 Trillion in debt to the Chinese leading to huge growth for their economy. Russia is still 1/15th the GDP of the US and desperately needs reduced sanctions and for the price of oil to increase. That is why they were happy about Rex Tillerson being SOS.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:24PM (#13197443)
I'm European, not American, and I disagree completely.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by niftich on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:56PM (#13195720)
But do they matter on the world sphere where the playground is dominated by a few players with nukes, navies, and large-enough domestic economies to be able to enact sanctions?

I come from a small country. There's a few in Europe, known for good wines or thermal baths or scenic sights or ethnic foods, but their continued existence is only guaranteed by their membership in a mutual defense pact. Those who aren't part of such an arrangement are out of luck -- "international outrage" does not protect sovereignty, as we have seen time and time again.

Right now, there's little need to conquer territory when you can just make everyone reliant on your for technology (USA), rare earth minerals (China), or natural gas (Russia). But as resources get more scarce, what is Latvia to do? Hungary? The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia? With their cash flowing to foreign powers for technology, raw materials, and energy, rely on tourism, find some unique skill niche, or try to become a tax haven?

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by vtange on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:36PM (#13196063)
I totally agree with you that geopolitics matter, no matter how much one wishes we could just live in a world that isn't "might makes right".

But I'd still argue that using terms like "Russia's backyard" or "China's backyard" dangerously colors entire regions their color without regard for whether the countries in the region want to be associated with their nearby superpower.

Germany once had nearly all of Europe and Japan once had nearly all of Asia. Couldn't one say at the time the U.K. was in Germany's backyard and China in Japan's?

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:02PM (#13196265)
You're not wrong, but the increasingly imperialist tone of public discourse is a reflection of reality as well as a driver of it. My basic read of the world situation is that financialization and globalization have brought a tremendous increase in economic capability but also created massive internal political stresses within many countries - not least the USA - through the abruptness of the disruption.

Historically, countries often deal with internal strife by going to war with someone else, and it's probably been this way since the first cell dealt with an uncomfortable pH balance by squirting caustic goo at a neighboring cell. Almost nobody wants a full-on nuclear exchange but I think some sort of world war is inevitable because peaceful competition has created a lot of losers as well as winners, in both psychic and economic terms. Once about 10% of a population is sufficiently pissed off, strife is inevitable and the only question that remains is how it will manifest..

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by fjdlwlv on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:14PM (#13196902)
Wars aren't to placate the populace. Wars are started by elites grabbing for wealth and power, who propagandize thr populace to their cause.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:17PM (#13197404)
It's hard to propagandize people who are content since they have little incentive to alter their disposition. Of course the populace is propagandized, but you're talking as if they're incapable of having a preference over their own economic situation, which is absurd. People feel sad and angry when their life gets worse, and propagandists can channel such emotions. Angry people are naturally easier to motivate than happy ones, because they want something to change whereas happy people don't. (Obviously I'm phrasing things a bit loosely for the sake of brevity here.)
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by fjdlwlv on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:11PM (#13196882)
The USA major foreign policy problems involve guerillas operating in small states.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by nickff on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:55PM (#13195705)
Whenever I read a story like this or a comment like yours, I remember the following proverb:

>When elephants fight, it is the grass that suffers.

I first heard it mentioned with respect to the Cold War in Africa, but the (Kenyan tribal) proverb seems to apply quite widely.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by hang on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:24PM (#13195428)
My government just did the right thing.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by forgotmysn on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:27PM (#13195464)
If this had occurred within Chinese waters, I might be inclined to agree with you. However, this occurred in International waters, and your government had no right to steal the vehicle.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by whybroke on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:40PM (#13195570)
Contrary to international opinion, China believes the South China Sea is in territory owing to an 1940s document containing an '11 dash line'

So in the legal opinion of all the world minus China it is theft. In the legal opinion of China it is not.

Unfortunately this subtly can not be expressed in a 140 char tweet so the situation deteriorates weekly.

(EDIT: beautiful details by jwtadvice here ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13195427

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by forgotmysn on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:32PM (#13196034)
The situation deteriorates because China refuses to acknowledge international law, not because their bull shit excuses not to don't fit in a tweet.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by fjdlwlv on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:14PM (#13196912)
International law isn't law if it isn't acknowledged.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by whybroke on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:13PM (#13197371)
Unfortunately being right is of small consultation if the situation is plunged into economic, diplomatic and military disaster by an ill-informed tweeting leader.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:54PM (#13195702)
I'm willing to bet if the US picked up a Chinese drone in international waters you'd respond differently.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by obstinate on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:23PM (#13195964)
To be fair to China, you'd simply never see them deploying drones in waters off the coast of Mexico. At least, if I model them correctly.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:41PM (#13196580)
That's true, their focus is more regional. They do have a large fleet of "fishing vessels" that are highly active within their region however.

Essentially all naval powers engage in some form of this, within the limits of their capabilities.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by forgotmysn on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:51PM (#13196177)
if you model what correctly?
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by obstinate on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:43PM (#13197147)
Chinese leadership and macroscopic geopolitical strategy.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:28PM (#13195475)
Perhaps, but without providing reasons for your answer it's kind of meaningless.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by nullnilvoid on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:18PM (#13195382)
It is very clear that the US is trying to spy on China. I don't blame China for taking the drones. If Russia sends drones to Hawaii, the US will take them too.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by forgotmysn on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:26PM (#13195454)
I don't think that's clear at all. This drone was in International waters, not Chinese waters, and it sounds like this device was not capturing any actionable intelligence but data on how sound travels through water.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by sleepingeights on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:46PM (#13197176)
Well, they needed both drones to locate the source of any sounds detected in the water. With only one drone, their tests can determine what sounds were made (and maybe some general vicinity), but not as accurately from where.

The Chinese already surprised a US carrier fleet by deploying a submarine fleet that "ambushed" a carrier when one of their subs surfaced in kill range to the carrier, undetected.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by MrZongle2 on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:24PM (#13195431)
The drone was operating in international waters. How, then, is China justified in taking it? Isn't that simply theft?

It would have been another thing entirely if the drone were operating within Chinese territory.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by roywiggins on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:27PM (#13195469)
In international waters? I'd call it piracy.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by dragonwriter on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:49PM (#13196667)
It can only be piracy if done for private ends. Done on behalf of a government, it's simply an act of war.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by dragonwriter on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:59PM (#13196767)
As is often the case in international politics, the justification is "well, what are you going to do about it, then?"
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by hang on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:24PM (#13195435)
and yeah they don't do that!
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:05PM (#13195793)
You are mistaken. Russia maintains survey vessels as well and regularly patrols just outside the US's exclusive economic zone.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by forgotmysn on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:34PM (#13196048)
Exactly. And we respect their right to hang out there because it's international waters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by bpodgursky on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:28PM (#13195474)
Welp. For a while I thought HN was too low profile to fall to the astroturfers.

I guess all good things end.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by whybroke on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:55PM (#13197243)
This is actually a very serious problem.

Not necessarily astroturfing but high quality topics are easily swept from the front page or the replies turn into an endless slop of loony-spam by people who's ideology is threatened.