[0] "On the afternoon of October 1, 2013, officers watched as Ulbricht entered the library and made his way up the stairs to work by the window at a desk in the science fiction section, Kiernan recalled. Meanwhile, sitting on a bench outside of the library, homeland security officer Jared Der-Yeghiayan — who had been working undercover as Silk Road employee "cirrus" — initiated a chat with Ulbricht, requesting that he log in to Silk Road's back end to fix a technical problem. As soon as Der-Yeghiayan could confirm that Ulbricht was logged into the site, FBI agents entered the library.
Two plainclothes FBI agents, one male and one female, walked up behind Ulbricht and began arguing loudly. This staged lovers' tiff caught Ulbricht's attention long enough to distract him from his laptop. As soon as Ulbricht looked up, the male agent reached down and slid the computer over to his female colleague, who quickly snatched it up and handed it over to Kiernan for further investigation."
[0] http://www.businessinsider.com/ross-ulbricht-will-be-sentenc...
http://www.cnbc.com/live-tv/american-greed/full-episode/silk...
In retrospect, it's a pretty obvious attack vector.
For the extremely security-conscious, it could even be a kind of fail-deadly (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fail-deadly) feature that wipes the phone.
The right approach is to recognize what FDE is good at (minimizing the risk that casual thieves will get data in addition to valuable parts, and protecting computers that can frequently be powered all the way off from even advanced attackers), and then use something better to protect sensitive data.
A potential counter measure is for the machine to periodically encrypt itself again and prevent use until a password/key is supplied ("clamming up"). This would prevent an attacker who snatched a logged-into computer from having unbounded carte blanche access to the machine. I'm envisioning something that every 10 minutes locks itself.
Does anyone know of such a solution?
[1] https://www.amazon.com/CRU-Inc-30200-0100-0011-WiebeTech-Jig...
* Casual, opportunistic attackers who will steal any available laptop.
* Targeted attackers who want your laptop in particular.
Against a casual attacker, even if your laptop is stolen unlocked, it's not going to be carefully kept unlocked. Doing so requires sophistication, care, and extra risk. Instead, the laptop is just going to get wiped.
Against a targeted attacker, like the FBI when they took down Ross Ulbricht (who FDE'd his laptop), the attacker will simply wait until the laptop is unlocked.