I have worked in a union carpentry shop, as well as a Swift and Company kill floor.
I also worked for 7 years as a programmer, 5 years working for others and 2 for myself -- in a part of the country where the market for that sort of work, and the pay, is just terrible.
The carpentry job was better than programming as an employee, by far. At least at the places I worked.
The prefab construction job was often extremely physical. It was often dangerous. Every day, I walked into work and there was a backlog of fully finished half-ton pre-fab walls that absolutely had to be moved out yesterday, all different sizes and bizarre shapes. My job was to use some combination of forklifts, hoists, bundles of styrofoam, truck strap, plywood and temporary structures to move, stack and pack the walls into the smallest space I could, and then load them onto a semi trailer with the then-largest industrial forklift that Clark made. Straps broke, racks turned over, thousand-pound walls sometimes fell or swung or crumbled a little too near for comfort, and other people didn't always work safe around you.
You know why it was better than programming? Not because of the overtime pay or the view, although both were superior.
It was better because reality asserted itself more often.
If your boss thinks the hoist can lift 2X more than it actually can, that situation will resolve itself. Fast.
When things go wrong, they go wrong fast and it's easy to assign blame. If your coworkers think that they can lift a 24-foot-long wall by attaching a hook to a single 2x8 stud, they'll find out quickly that they should listen to the people who have seen it done.
We never ended up working like crack-addled beavers for 4 months straight because a team of yes-men convinced everyone that natural laws don't apply to us. Sometimes the company took on more work than it could actually handle. It became obvious very quickly, after a matter of only a few weeks. It didn't stagnate, dying horribly over the course of years as the backlog of unprofitable work dragged out into the infinite future.
The existence of physical limitations made customers more reasonable; no one ever tried to order a 5-story Ruby Tuesdays for the price of a lemonade stand. The equivalent of that happened all the time at the software shops I worked for; I saw them take on jobs that called for the tracking and reporting of complex resource flows, stuff that would be ambitious for even a YC team with 4 months to kill, but the devs assigned were pure designers who had managed to learn just enough vbscript to provide some meaningful interaction on the website templates they sliced out of Photoshop.
I know that there are people out there whose experience has been pretty different. Most of them probably react by moving to a better market, and that certainly seems a reasonable solution, although it wasn't mine.
But to dismiss the reality of crappy programming jobs with a "wow, heavy ones and zeros" -- uh-uh. I literally enjoyed the kill floor better than one of my programming jobs.
There are people out there who will abuse any humble, hardworking, inexperienced employees they have, and browbeat them into truly ridiculous efforts. I remember being 21 years old, being told that a project slated for delivery in 2 months had to be done for a demo to the execs of a chain of hospitals at the end of the week. I worked with zero sleep to get it done, because it was my project.
At the end of the week, my boss slipped and cut his head playing with his kids in the McTreehouseMansion behind his McMansion. So on no sleep, I had to train all of these people in on the new system, people who were executives at our biggest account.
I have public speaking experience; I put on a suit and did it. It was a big success.
I didn't get overtime or a bonus, and I would by far have rather spent that week gutting hogs for a mere 10 hours a day and going home to relax afterwards.
Wait, no, I don't hate to agree with you. You're absolutely right. "Died from too much hard coding"? Yeah right.
Coding is hard intellectual work. And, as you point out, if you're not happy with the trade-offs at work, you can always start your own business. It's really an awesome situation to be in, compared to what we could have been doing a hundred years ago.
Everything's amazing but nobody's happy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8r1CZTLk-Gk
PS: I doubt the coding is what killed "John".
This has nothing to do with "not [being] happy with the tradeoffs". These guys are perfectly happy acting like this; being the hero. But it's absolutely not something I'm going to encourage my friend to do to himself.
It seems like these type of careers just draw that type of driven person. This is just a guess, as I draw from my personal experience.
Simply because we can't change other professions, doesn't mean we can't improve our own. And just because there are some obsessive individuals who "work themselves to death" doesn't mean the rest of us need to try to match them (or encourage them).
And please nobody suggest TDD. TDD has its place but it's not a holy grail and it only tests the tests you think to write. Even if your code coverage is 100% you have certainly not tested every possible input and path if the software is at all complex.
If you think software developers (or bus drivers, or airline pilots) can get paranoid, you should see what happens before test flights on airplanes.
A lot of people put the value of a life at around the expected work society gets from it - and then try to argue that that's not what they really think, obviously, because doing so would be immoral.
Of course, you need a break every now and again, and not eating/exercising is going to catch up with you, but I am guessing this guy is quite young.
For me each has it's ups and downs. If you are sitting in a chair all day you are quite likely to develop postural and muscular problems, as well as being at a higher risk of obesity and other exercise related health issues.
Working outside generally means a higher risk of (skin) cancer, but your body is doing what it evolved to do: carrying your consciousness around while you manipulate the physical world.
Personally I find I have to go to great lengths at the gym to make my body feel like it is getting the exercise it requires when I'm coding, whereas when I'm working in a more physical job I generally feel very physically content at the end of the day... But, as always, to each their own.
Talk to someone building an asphalt road in the summer about hard work, or a farmer during a bad year, an ambulance driver or a police man.
Hard work means that your body is going to fail you long before it normally would have, hard work means that your hands have calluses.
We're bloody lucky that brains are rewarded as much as they are, I certainly wouldn't make it for a long time working in a mine or a field (the two options that you had roughly where I'm living not that long ago).
Sure, working under pressure can be tough, and demanding customers can drive you to the brink of insanity. But only if you let it.
You've been a cook, I worked in a mail room at the ripe old age of 17, scrawny little kid trying to drag a mailbag twice my weight. I didn't give up but I can tell you I came close those first weeks. It certainly helped me to appreciate my good fortune later in life.
He gets paid the big bucks for the 5%. Occasionally i'll ask how his day was and i'll get a burning car kinda story and then he'll ask how my day was.
"I'm an overpaid typist."
Those jobs take a special kind of mentality to be able to do them well.
I do agree, however, that many of us are lucky to have avoided the factory life. Read _Out of This Furnace_ sometime to appreciate the hell many immigrants lived through.
However, a quick search on the internet for "health unemployed" (without the quotes), turns up articles like http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/feb16/creed/creed.html
I also heard of other studies that found that top managers, despite having lots of stress on the job, are still more content and less prone to stress-related ills, than people who get their stress from being low on the social pecking order. (Perhaps somebody can find that study?)
However, the situation you describe for yourself is not the same situation discussed in the article. You are making your own decision to work how ever many hours a day you work. And you are reaping the rewards from that work directly (I'm assuming you are self-employed, since you said you are your own boss). You are not being asked to work 80 hour weeks by someone else, and then not getting compensated even in the form of gratitude from your employer for going the extra mile to get something done for the company. I (and multiple friends of mine) have been in that situation before, and it's no picnic. When you are expected to deliver on deadlines that are beyond completely unrealistic, and are pressured on every side to "just get it done" by people who know absolutely nothing about developing software, and are reprimanded for coming in late after working long hours the night before it can be extremely hazardous to your health. Stress can kill you, and the body does need sleep. Long hours day after day for weeks on end catches up with you, and yes it can cause serious health problems. BTW, the fact that you are sitting on your backside the whole time actually makes the situation worse, not better.
Happily, it has been a long time since I've been in that situation, and I intend to continue to do everything I can to keep it that way.
I'd imagine that cocaine use is relatively rare in technology, but it occurs in finance quite a bit. That's the dirty not-so-secret of the long hours in investment banking. I also think it's safe to assume that cocaine use is a lot more dangerous than long coding binges.
Wow, those ones and zeros must have really been heavy!
Every time I see landscapers, construction workers, farmers, nurses aides, or anyone in one of my customers' factories or warehouses, I thank my lucky stars that I was born when I was, I had an aptitude and interest in programming, and I found the perfect career for me.
Sure I work hard, but my hard work is hardly the same as their hard work.
I've spent a career on my ass, building applications that hopefully make the lives of those who do physical work just a little easier.
My last career was a cook. After a 6 hour shift in a 110 degree kitchen serving 2,000 meals, a 12 hour stint in an air conditioned office in my Aeron chair seems like a vacation. Oh, and did I mention I earn more in a month than I did in a year as a cook?
I never expect my boss to thank me for anything. My boss (me) gives me the best bonus I could ever ask for. I get to do it all over again tomorrow.