Re:Revised estimates of the share of national income going t...
by savanaly on Thursday December 15, 2016 @04:26PM
(#13188566)
I think focusing on the trust fund kid worth 200 million is also a red herring though. The focus should be on consumption inequality, not total amount of wealth. If someone is just sitting on a lot of cash then they're not hurting anyone, but if they're outspending everyone else then they are (in a sense) hurting them.
Re:Revised estimates of the share of national income going t...
by jnbiche on Thursday December 15, 2016 @05:00PM
(#13188870)
> If someone is just sitting on a lot of cash then they're not hurting anyone, but if they're outspending everyone else then they are (in a sense) hurting them.
I disagree strongly. That 200 million would be far, far better invested in some pie-in-the-sky social start-up than just sitting there. Spending should definitely not be taxed anymore than it already is, we want people to spend money.
Re:Revised estimates of the share of national income going t...
by savanaly on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:43AM
(#13191316)
When they spend the money, the goods they're consuming or moving around are displaced from where they would have been. Spending the money doesn't create goods out of thin air. So unless they are making an investment that is a good one that somehow no one else knows about, it doesn't really impoverish society for them to sit on it. This argument, of course, applies on the margin and does not apply to every bit of wealth in the system.
Really, it's the top 0.1% I'm concerned about. Most of the top 1% are basically upper middle class people who've met with significant professional success, and the only part of the middle class that done well the past two decades (and good for them).