Re:Zygomys – An embedded scripting language for Go
by iopq on Thursday December 15, 2016 @04:33PM
(#13188643)
> I regard rusts structs + traits as an object system
I don't regard them as an object system because they are à la carte, while objects tie data and behavior together
Re:Zygomys – An embedded scripting language for Go
by lacampbell on Thursday December 15, 2016 @07:15PM
(#13189984)
à la carte in what sense?
I feel like data and behaviour is very much tied together in a rust struct. With the right visibility modifiers it can be completely opaque - it's literally a black box you are sending messages to. The methods are attached to the object in my mind.
But I am by no means a rust expert. I'm curious is to why you think the data and behaviour are not tied together.
Re:Zygomys – An embedded scripting language for Go
by iopq on Thursday December 15, 2016 @07:24PM
(#13190028)
Because you can have free functions that take plain data. So you can have methods or you can have free functions. This is why it's à la carte - you can choose if you use methods or free functions. You can choose if your data has behavior or not.
Re:Zygomys – An embedded scripting language for Go
by lacampbell on Thursday December 15, 2016 @07:29PM
(#13190049)
Right, absolutely. I am by no means claiming rust is an OO language, just that I would consider the structs + traits thing a way of making objects. I suppose I could have been more precise - it's not an object system by itself but it certainly can be very easily used as one. I think for a systems langauge they did a very fine job in designing that part of it.
I regard rusts structs + traits as an object system. But I understand why they chose to not mention objects at all - they don't want to conjure up images of Java boiler plate and heavy mutation, which is sadly what it means to most people now.