News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by dawnerd on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:58PM (#13162318)
I've known some homeless people, and for them, it was mental illness that kept them on the streets. They thought everyone was out to get them or control their life. It's a shame that they all want the handouts, but they don't want to follow any rules that come with it.

What I realized is a lot of these people don't want any responsibilities. They're not willing, or able to accept that life sucks for everyone. The governments need to start offering better mental health care that doesn't involve locking people up in hospitals (something an old friend of mine had happen to him, and it caused him to lose trust in everyone).

I don't think giving people hotel rooms is going to solve any problems - if anything it's just enabling it. A better solution is to expand affordable housing and job programs so people start to get back on their feet while ultimately leaving the decisions up to them. Ultimately if they want to live under a bridge that a choice they've made and there's nothing we can really do about it.

Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by tekklloneer on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:05PM (#13162396)
You hit the nail on the head, and then turned it into a condemnation and missed the point and problem entirely.

It's mental illness. The reason they won't "follow any rules" is because they're mentally ill. There's no easy answer, and saying "there's an easy answer, but it won't work for them" isn't actually an easy answer.

Many of them are very mentally ill, and living under a bridge is not a choice they've made willingly.

If someone's too mentally incapable of holding a job, or reading, or clothing themselves, then is it right that we force them under a bridge?

Note: I am responding to your comment, not to the practicality of the article's proposed solution.

Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:00PM (#13162868)
I think we should all be very careful about extrapolating from our limited experiences with the chronically homeless (if you have a particularly rich experience, for instance as someone who works full-time in advocacy or intervention with them, say so!) and, in particular, with anything that suggests the problems of homelessness can be effectively summarized in a short Hacker News comment.

The issue of homelessness is a particularly nutrient-rich substrate for germinations of the Just World Fallacy, particularly among nerds like us, with our affinity for pat narratives.

[dead]
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by tptacek on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @07:48AM (#13166385)
Thank you, yes, this is exactly the kind of broken nerd logic I was warning about, and you phrased it better.
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by drbigglesworth on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @09:30AM (#13166984)
How does this comment not violate the site guidelines re civility?

Respectfully Thomas, ever since the election I've read an unbecoming undercurrent in your comments that wasn't there before.

Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by mistermann on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:46PM (#13168763)
You think that is illogical?
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by tptacek on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:03PM (#13169645)
I think it is very compelling nerd logic.

Nerd logic usually takes the form of conclusions reached by starting from a set of first principles simple and small enough to be captured in a short message board comment, and restricting itself to a series short, plausible extrapolations from those first principles, stopping when a suitably grand and straightforward explanation for complex phenomenon is reached.

We're all in the business of breaking things into their simplest constituent parts. We all react strongly to this Moog Synthesizer logic: all we need is a couple oscillators, plugged together just so, and we can generate any conclusion we need.

I don't think we do it deliberately!

Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by mistermann on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:44PM (#13196114)
Ok, but do you think it is illogical?
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by pavel_lishin on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:25PM (#13162574)
If there is a set of people who want handouts, but aren't willing to follow rules, how likely is it for that set of people to hold down jobs, pay rent, etc?

I would wager that there is another set of people, that doesn't intersect with that first set very much, that are just down on their luck, for whom a place to shower and receive mail and handle phone interviews for some stable amount of time would help quite a bit.

Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by Kalium on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:07PM (#13162415)
It should be remembered that not every mental illness can be readily treated in a manner friendly to outpatient care. Not everyone can be treated in a way that turns them into a "normal", functional, employable adult.
Re:Hotel Stays, Especially in Inclement Weather by seanp2k2 on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:31PM (#13162612)
And not everyone wants to be or do any of those things. Ability and willingness are different, and homeless can be neither, either, or both. It is a complicated problem and I think pretty much everyone agrees that we aren't doing enough to help.