drbigglesworth
Respectfully Thomas, ever since the election I've read an unbecoming undercurrent in your comments that wasn't there before.
The error you are making is in placing too much faith in a single study, and possibly in the journalists/bloggers who report on a single study. I have lost count of the number of times I've read a press release or news article that completely misrepresents the findings of a study (i.e., the error is in the reporting, not the article). It's also frequently forgotten that journal articles are written to communicate findings to peers, not the larger public. There are nuances that are understood within a community that are unknown when one is coming from a different background.
Until there is a body of work on a phenomenon, perhaps framed by a review article or two, it's best to regard single reports (regardless of perceived quality) as interesting curios but nothing more.
I enjoyed the work leading to my PhD and the time spent at the startup was educational, but I have to conclude that pursuing the PhD was overall a mistake. I like the idea of the diversity of the sciences better reflecting the population at large, but I'm very angry that expensive education for a career with lousy prospects is being advocated. Considering the career outlook, poor pay relative to demands, and the disproportionate burden of child-rearing placed upon them, I see avoiding a career in the sciences as a rational choice for anyone, especially women.