News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by cthor on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:11PM (#13161938)
When talking about the effect of voting systems on elections, something I think is overlooked is the game-theoretic implications on the candidates.

Take the second diagram in the article and move the candidates around. What's the optimal strategy? To move as close to your opponent as possible, while staying closer to the centre.

Now take the diagram with three candidates, and move them around. What's the optimal strategy? To move as far away from both opponents.

This works even if you consider an n-dimensional space for every conceivable issue. Two-party system encourages both parties to move towards the centre. Three- (or more) party system encourages them to spread out.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by tristor on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:30PM (#13162097)
> Two-party system encourages both parties to move towards the centre.

Either the center has shifted on the total spectrum, or this statement isn't backed by reality. At least in the US, both major parties are moving towards the right and moving towards authoritarian positions.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by cthor on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:56PM (#13162302)
The U.S. reaping these benefits from their two party system is confounded by the primaries. The "centre" of each primary is with respect to the party platform, not the general population.

Presidential candidates' optimal strategy is to be centre of the party base in primaries, then centre of the entire country in the general election. (And they have to do this while avoiding accusations of flip flopping.)

(And there are other confounders that apply regardless of voting system. Nobody involved is working with perfect information and nobody is a perfectly rational actor.)

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by blowski on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:59AM (#13165295)
It's affected by personalities. A lot of people probably voted for Trump the person, rather than Trump's policies. If that's true, his position on the diagram isn't all that important.

I guess this is what you meant by "non-rational actors" - people voting for policies they don't like because they like the person saying them.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by caspianm on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @03:32AM (#13174611)
Primary voters' optimal strategy, if voting within their preferred party, should also be to pick a centre candidate, so they will win.

Could get complex if people vote in the opposing party's primary though.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by kr7 on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:32PM (#13162616)
> both major parties are moving towards the right

Not on social issues. Trump is a moderate on abortion and gay marriage. Bill Clinton passed DADT, DOMA, welfare work requirements, and his crime bill, and called for a crackdown on illegal immigration. He wouldn't be able to win the Democratic nomination nowadays.

> moving towards authoritarian positions

Unfortunately.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by tomjakubowski on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:51PM (#13163843)
Trump's positions on abortion don't seem particular thought-through, but he did say that he would nominate SCOTUS justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade. I don't think that's a moderate position at all.

And while Trump might be less of an extremist on these issues than his fellow Republicans, the party's elected officials (including his running mate) haven't moved an inch towards the center on abortion rights. Mike Pence governed Indiana, a state with some of the tightest (and most ridiculous, honestly) restrictions on abortion in the country.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_positions_of_Donald_...

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by zeveb on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:18AM (#13167898)
> Trump's positions on abortion don't seem particular thought-through, but he did say that he would nominate SCOTUS justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade. I don't think that's a moderate position at all.

'Allowing the states to determine what is allowed' seems more moderate than 'no state may meaningfully restrict something,' no?

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by actuallyalys on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:50PM (#13163837)
I think the public is moving leftward on social issues (with the exception of abortion [0]), but I'm not sure the Republican party has been recently. I mean, the Log Cabin Republicans called the most recent platform the "most anti-LGBT in history" [1]. My sense is that Trump won the nomination by downplaying his personal views on abortion and gay marriage and pledging to nominate conservative justices.

[0]: http://www.gallup.com/poll/170249/split-abortion-pro-choice-...

[1]: http://www.logcabin.org/pressrelease/a-message-on-the-gop-pl...

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by gohrt on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:07PM (#13163912)
Progressivism is tricky -- the definition of the word is for continual change. So, no progressive agenda of Year X would be progressive in Year X+20. A successfu progressive in Year X would be pushing progress the margin choices of the day. In Year X+20, a different set of choices are at the margin. No effective progressive in Year X would have the same agenda in Year X+20.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by hash-set on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:20AM (#13167913)
I really think progressivism is just warmed over Marxism and has been for a really long time. Progressives near the turn of the last century pursued alcohol prohibition. Granted, they also pushed for womens' suffrage. A lot of damage was done by Prohibition, though. A lot.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by tptacek on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:47PM (#13170834)
This is incoherent. The Marxists ended alcohol prohibition in Soviet Russia.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by dragonwriter on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:51PM (#13163550)
> Either the center has shifted on the total spectrum, or this statement isn't backed by reality.

Both statements are true (shifts in the center, including long term trends in a single direction) happen, but are orthogonal to the idea that a two-party systems results in both parties driving for the middle seize the median voter (it would just make that a moving target.)

OTOH, all of the examples from experience show that two-party systems don't actually have that effect, and we have good ideas why:

1. Engagement falls off as a party's position gets further from a citizens, and

2. Political views are rarely unimodally distributed to start with, and two-party systems tend to promote more of a bimodal distribution on the main axis of variation.

So, a big part of what parties position for is keeping their base engaged, not appeal to the center.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by nosuchthing on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:35PM (#13162137)

  Either the center has shifted on the total spectrum, or 
  this statement isn't backed by reality. At least in the US, 
  both major parties are moving towards the right and moving 
  towards authoritarian positions.
Which seems to be a result of FPTP, which fosters the limited choice between RED/BLUE.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by ubernostrum on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:59PM (#13162334)
Many countries which do not use FPTP nonetheless end up with stable long-lived de facto two-party systems. The hypothetical ideal of a many-party coalition state is rare regardless of voting system and apportionment.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by abecedarius on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:10PM (#13164372)
I don't think a multi-party system is quite the right goal to aim for. In the current system in the US, people with preferences underserved by both D and R don't just lack a respected party, they face a giant barrier to even making the lack visible. Green-leaning? Fuck 'em, what'll they do -- vote Republican? To make your preference unambiguous by an actual vote, under our system, you have to be seriously into the fringe. This creates a kind of activation-energy barrier to coordinating on a change: very many people can feel that, say, smoking pot is OK, without their preference mattering -- without it even affecting their vote. This fraction could even exceed 50%, unless it's common knowledge that it's over 50%: you don't "throw away" your vote when you expect everyone else to also vote strategically according to preferences which aren't common knowledge.

So a voting system with less of a strategy problem could make common knowledge of real voter preferences easier to arrive at -- the preferences people would honestly vote by, given the chance. You could still have just two major parties, but disciplined by a real option of serious competition if they don't address these no-longer-deniable preferences.

Caveats: 1. AFAIK we still need a clearer understanding of how much strategy people exercise in approval or score voting in practice, once they've gotten used to the new system. And 2. these are just my thoughts as a random citizen trying to see to a way to less large-scale insanity. I'm not a political scientist and I haven't seen one say anything like this about common knowledge and voting systems.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by dragonwriter on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:01PM (#13163622)
> Many countries which do not use FPTP nonetheless end up with stable long-lived de facto two-party systems

No, they don't. Heck, even many systems that do use FPTP (e.g., the UK) support more parties with representation in the main national legislative body than the US.

A two-party system isn't one where merely there are two stronger parties that tend to form governments or executive administrations.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by ubernostrum on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:29PM (#13163989)
So as long as there are some seats going to other parties, you don't care if there's an uninterrupted streak of two dominant major parties such that one of them always forms and leads the government?

Because that is the case in many countries, even countries which don't do FPTP, even countries which do things that people argue are good electorally, and that does not seem like a categorical improvement over what happens in, say, the US.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @01:11AM (#13164901)
> Because that is the case in many countries, even countries which don't do FPTP,

No, it's emphatically not, especially if you mean exclusively forms the government (not in a coalition.) And, if you don't mean that, it's pretty substantially weaker than the duopoly in the US.

Heck, even FPTP systems that aren't also Presidential systems (another structural factor that reduces competitive parties) generally don't do what you describe, at least in the form of exclusively non-coalition governments.

> and that does not seem like a categorical improvement over what happens in, say, the US.

Whether the difference is merely a substantial quantitative improvement with some creatively-defined common category or a categorical improvement is ultimately immaterial.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by smw on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @05:00AM (#13165741)
Having a third party candidate be a real possibility in a non-FPTP voting system would ensure that there was an escape valve if a party moved too far from the center, right? So it would be strongly motivated not to?
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by gohrt on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:03PM (#13163894)
"authoritarian" isn't a left/right issue. Mao and Stalin were leftist authoritarians.

Your claim that authoritarianism is non-centrist is not obvious, I don't even agree it's true.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by tristor on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:53PM (#13164064)
> Your claim that authoritarianism is non-centrist is not obvious, I don't even agree it's true.

I made no such claim. My sentence has an "and" in it.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by mastax on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:34PM (#13162130)
This is usually explained by the idea that the 'Center' moves about over time. Perhaps in this instance the center was just further right than the parties expected.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by brianolson on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:50PM (#13162259)
I feel like the parties split some axis of what people want, but are both pulled well off center of the population by MONEY.
Re:To Build a Better Ballot by dragonwriter on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:35PM (#13163467)
> Two-party system encourages both parties to move towards the centre.

If you assume things (unimodal distribution of preferences and/or participation [propensity to vote, in simple models that ignore campaigning] that is constant across the spectrum and insensitive to distance between the voters preference and the nearest party position) that turn out not to be true in practice, sure.

In the real world, two-party systems don't usually encourage centrism, they encourage polarization.

The median voter theorem is a solid mathematical result given the very simple parameters it applies to, but has less practical application to the real world than many people like to think.

Re:To Build a Better Ballot by brianolson on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:29PM (#13162087)
3 parties would take up position around some population center, with some differentiation, but not too much. Probably they each move to the center of mass of the third of the population they represent, except that there's some incentive to be a little centrist of that to try and poach marginal voters from the other two parties. If a party moves too far out from center, centrist voters on their margins defect to the other two parties. I'm not sure what the penalty for being 'too centrist' is.