"encyclopaedias aren't meant for obscure topics"
I'm a bit confused by this reasoning. I can see space considerations in a paper environment, but not on a wiki. Why wouldn't Wikipedia try to be the home of all knowledge?
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism
by taco_emoji on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:08PM
(#13160836)
Space has little to do with it. Wikipedia is meant to be a reliable compendium of knowledge, and it can succeed only to the extent that it contains easily verified information. Obscure topics will of course not have much in the way of verifiable information available.
How much research is too much for "easily verified" information?
If you have to do original research to justify a topic's inclusion, you're outside the charter of the encyclopedia. The only "research" Wikipedia accepts are direct citations to reliable sources.
I was more thinking of finding the citations as opposed to research in the discovery of new knowledge sense.
That may be true regarding physical encyclopedias, which are, of course, limited by space and weight (ha!). With an online encyclopedia like Wikipedia, though, those limitations are gone.
I'm looking forward to seeing Infogalactic give Wikipedia a run for its money!
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism
by duckingtest on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @06:33AM
(#13166077)
>If you would like to edit articles on Infogalactic: the planetary knowledge core, you may complete and submit the following form to request a user account.
Please read the Terms of Service before requesting an account.
Once the account is approved, you will be emailed a notification message and the account will be usable at login.
Request an account?!? What an exclusionary language. How did I find that out? Because I tried to make a tiny edit. Then found out I need an account. Then that I need to 'request' account. Yeah, no, infogalactic just lost me forever.
A very nice example of barriers to participation in action.
>Infogalactic has the right to block or ban any user for any reason whatsoever.
Even more totalitarian language... infogalactic seems to be less inclusive & open than wikipedia today.
IMO, encyclopaedias aren't meant for obscure topics. And any products or services with a focus on curation have to discriminate. Of course the criteria for doing so will probably always be controversial.