News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Suggest HN: Studies based on small sample sizes shouldn't... by gus_massa on Sunday December 11, 2016 @11:43AM (#13151822)
There is a lot of dubious Physics that is very popular here.

My antifavorite is the Em-drive:

Most popular article: "EmDrive study officially published" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12995125 (595 points, 21 days ago, 432 comments)

(My second choice is Cold fusion / LENR.)

This has slightly less votes that the most popular stories about colossal experiments:

"Second Gravitational Wave Detected at LIGO" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11910700 (621 points, 178 days ago, 175 comments)

"Higgs Boson Explained by Cartoon" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4193590 (646 points, 1622 days ago, 128 comments)

The problem is that most people like nice stories, and a massless thruster that can make space travel much faster is interesting. And it's much easier to explain than why we need the Higgs's boson or gravitational waves.

The two later have no possible application in sight. They are interesting results, but it's not clear how they will change your life. (I'm optimistic, let's see what happens in 30 years.)

The Em-drive looks more promising. Cheap and fast space travel soon, for some definition of soon. It's easier to explain, in particular because the theoretical explanation is worse than the experimental setup. No one tries to explain something about gauge invariance of curvature tensors.

Re:Suggest HN: Studies based on small sample sizes shouldn't... by Kenji on Sunday December 11, 2016 @01:48PM (#13152443)
As far as I know, the EmDrive is still considered controversial and it is not certain whether and how it works. It is interesting because it could cause a revolution to how we view impulse, so it might be a colossal thing just as much as it might be complete nonsense. So I think the comparison is disingenous.
Re:Suggest HN: Studies based on small sample sizes shouldn't... by gus_massa on Sunday December 11, 2016 @09:02PM (#13154965)
It's difficult to explain in a short comment, but the Em-drive is as controversial as the yeti.

If it were true, then it breaks the current laws of physics. In particular the conservation of momentum and energy. There are some bogus explanations that try to make it compatible with the current laws of Physics, but they are nonsense.

Breaking the current laws of Physics is not bad if you have a good experiment. The problem is that they are measuring a very small force that is very close to the experimental error. And there are many other forces that are difficult to calculate and may explain the force they are measuring.